
The broadcast season unofficially kicks off tonight. And just like in a kids board game, the youngest of the networks, the CW, got to start first, unspooling its new series Ringer starring Sarah Michelle Gellar. Also launching tonight are the new seasons of the CW’s 90210 and NBC’s Parenthood, marking the unofficial start of the new season, which kicks in on Monday. Here are the networks’ standings going into the fall season:
With Yankees, Red Sox and Phillies on tap for baseball’s postseason this year, along with the heavily promoted The X Factor and new big-budget dinosaur drama Terra Nova, Fox is in a position to significantly outperform last fall when the network carried the National League Championship Series and had two DOA shows, drama Lone Star and comedy Running Wilde. The question marks at the network this fall are the new comedies, New Girl and I Hate My Teenage Daughter, though both are propped up by solid lead-ins, Glee and X Factor, respectively, and whether Glee and House can rebound after a disappointing 2010-11 season. If the stars align and X Factor lives up to its ratings expectations, Fox may win the fourth quarter as it did two years ago when it also had the American League Championship Series and the highly rated freshman season of Glee.
Fox’s main rival for the top spot in the fall will be the epitome of stability, CBS, which will get a ratings boost from the re-launch of Two and a Half Men. The consensus is that CBS has potential breakout hits on its hands with new Monday comedy Two Broke Girls, which is launching behind the much-hyped return of Two and a Half Men, and possibly Thursday drama Person of Interest. The network is getting high marks for taking its aging series such as the CSI franchise and Survivor and relocating them to troubled spots on the schedule that they shore up. The network is expected to accomplish that again this season with the mothership CSI series, which is moving to Wednesday 10 PM, with its replacement on Thursday, Person of Interest, looking to do at least as well as CSI if not better. The only question marks at CBS are new Thursday 8:30 comedy How To Be a Gentleman and where Men will settle after the initial ratings spike.
Three Words — Sunday Night Football. With the NFL football ratings monster showing no signs of slowing down as evidenced by Sunday’s opener, which drew the franchise’s largest ratings ever, NBC is assured at least a third-place finish for the fall. With the Super Bowl slated for February, NBC looks poised to finally move up a spot from the dreaded bottom No. 4. Still, a lot of question marks. The biggest one in the fall: The Sing Off. Only tested as a short holiday limited series airing with no competition, the singing competition is now thrown against ABC’s reality juggernaut Dancing With the Stars, given two whole hours of primetime real estate and asked to carry Monday, including launching new drama The Playboy Club at 10 PM. All of NBC’s new scripted series are question marks too, the biggest being comedies Up All Night and Free Agents given the difficult task of opening a second comedy block on Wednesday.
The good news for ABC is that its attempt to open a second comedy block on Tuesday seems to have a stronger anchor in the Tim Allen freshman Last Man Standing. The network has locked in a Dancing With the Stars cast that people are buzzing about and should get a small bump from making this the final season of Desperate Housewives. Other than that, there isn’t much else that is certain, with all of the network’s new series as question marks. Unless something breaks in a big way, with no major sports to fall back on for most of the season, ABC is destined to fall to fourth.
The network is taking one big risk with Ringer, which is older-skewing, more complex and more sophisticated than the regular CW fare. The rest is adding more of what works, with another soap, Hart of Dixie, and another Alloy-based genre piece ala Vampire Diaries, The Secret Circle. Without a breakout hit in the past couple of seasons and with Smallville gone, the CW needs one this year.
TV Editor Nellie Andreeva - tip her here.


NBC is stupid for starting a new comedy block – they should have cut out two comedies from their order (probably Bent and Whitney) and launched Up All Night after The Office and kept Free Agents till midseason.
I agree that Up All Night should have gone to Thursday nights. I’d much rather see it there than Whitney.
But I don’t begrudge NBC for trying a new comedy block. Though it’ll be an uphill battle for sure.
I honestly don’t see X-Factor being the American Idol sized hit for Fox everyone thinks it will be. While I don’t see it completely bombing if I had to out a mortgage payment on it I’d say the US version of The X-Factor is a ‘one and done’ affair.
Between Idol itself and The Voice American audiences have their singing competition needs taken care of even if they aren’t on the air at the same as X-Factor.
But then again, I’ve been wrong before.
I don’t know what you think a breakout hit for the CW is, but I’m pretty sure The Vampire Diaries counts and it’s only two years old.
Ugh, it infuriates me to no end that Fox manages to even be a contending network with, what, its 5 shows: “American Idol,” “The X Factor,” “Glee,” the World Series and perhaps “Terra Nova?”
Seriously, two competition shows – I still can’t figure out why “American Idol” is still relevant – an annoying show about a glee club and a high-concept time warping show? (I’ll give them kudos for even greenlighting “Terra Nova,” but still.)
…Or not have picked up Free Agents at all. All the clips I saw were abysmal and I’m calling it now– it will be the first new show canceled this season!
“Without a breakout hit in the past couple of seasons and with Smallville gone, the CW needs one this year.” Uhmm.. I believe The Vampire Diaries WAS a breakout hit… it’s as big a hit as the network is gonna get… All of the other hypes shows, ala Gossip Girl, 90210, Melrose Place have fizzled and were kept afloat because of the pride of the network (and DVD sales). The Vampire Diaries is the only show that really proved itself on the network (other than Smallville and Supernatural, neither of which I watched).
Do you work for CBS? They get high marks for shoring up trouble spots on the schedule with old shows? Have u looked at details – rather than follow their hype?
CSI NY did worse on Fr than on Weds – and the shows in its Wed slot did worse than CSY NY the previous yr.
CSI MIAMI was worse on Sundays then on Mon (where it was doing very nice – how dare they move it!) – and Hawaii 5′O did worse than miami
Survivor did okay on Weds – but worse than on Thurs and Thurs 8-9 was worse because 830-9 was so bad – which hastened CSI’s demise because nobody was watching before CSI came on. And moving Survivor made it easier for Fox to finally move Idol to Thurs for good – which they always wanted to do but didn’t till now – which hurt CBS even more.
so it is bs to say they made good moves – cuz these moves did not pay off with any improvements except wed 8-9
Ringer?!? “more complex”?!? I take it we didn’t watch the same horrendous pilot.
FOX is going to blow the competition away with The X Factor. I’m not sold on Terra Nova though. Given how much that show costs, I feel like that its a massive bomb waiting to explode.
The CW should have one of its most successful seasons yet. The Secret Circle is an automatic hit a la Vampire Diaries. Ringer, although not great, will pull in consistent numbers thanks to SMG and Hart of Dixie has a good shot at taking off as well.
It’s weird to put multi-cam Whitney after three single cam comedies. They should’ve put Up All Night on Thursday and had Whitney and some other new show start a multi-cam night.
“…Person of Interest, looking to do at least as well as CSI if not better. ”
I’m sure it will do at least as well as CSI did this Spring — running 4th behind The Office, Grey’s Anatomy, and Bones.
The pilot for up all night was not funny at all.
I thought free agents was Dow based on clips and commercials. Saw the pilot though and it is promising. 10x better than up all night
Just give me HOUSE and I’ll be happy!!!