A study published today in the medical journal Pediatrics has concluded that preschool-aged children who watch fast-paced TV cartoons performed significantly worse on executive function (like self-regulation, working memory and attention span) than children who watched an educational cartoon or drew for the same period of time. Researchers used a 9-minute snippet from an episode of Nickelodeon’s SpongeBob SquarePants for the fast-paced portion of the lab study — vs. a PBS series and drawing with crayons – in which 60 4-year-olds were tested and then evaluated. On the surface, it seems they could have saved some money lab fees for this one, as it’s not exactly breaking news that busy, fast-cut programming with loud noises and fantastical images can turn kids’ brains to mush. Still, there has been little data compiled on the subject, and the researchers concluded: “This result is consistent with others showing long-term negative associations between entertainment television and attention. Given the popularity of some fast-paced television cartoons among young children, it is important that parents are alert to the possibility of lower levels of [executive function] in young children at least immediately after watching such shows.”


Wow. Groundbreaking.
Yet according to the show’s creators, SpongeBob is aimed at 6 to 11-year-olds. Way to research your study material, Pediatrics.
I know I’m a mess from watching too many Road Runner cartoons as a child. Damn you, WB!
This just in: Sugar rots your teeth and sex with hookers give you the klap.
I’d be more worried that kids were watching Caillou, which is the “educational” program they lumped it against in the test. All that show teaches kids is how to be a whiny bitch. Oh, Canadian programming!
Strikes me as more sensationalism from a media culture that tells us video games and Michael Bay incite people to violence.
They had 60 kids total, with 20 watching Bob for 9 minutes. Hardly a big enough sample size to draw these kind of conclusions, and the articles I’ve read about the experiment don’t even answer basic questions (who are these kids? How were they selected? What are their backgrounds? How were they divided up? What did they have for lunch the day of the ‘experiment’?)
Never mind that the selection of shows themselves (the control was PBS? Really?) seems to invite a certain kind of bias.
Complete and utter horseshit. I knew this was about a hidden agenda the minute I read the baseline was PBS. PBS??? They used to show PBS “educational” shows in my elementary school…for the really stupid kids. Didn’t help any. The smart ones watched all those fast-paced WB Looney Tunes classics at home. Apparently, somebody doesn’t like super-successful SpongeBob winning in the free market-time to “level the playing field” for government-funded PBS.
Chill out. You can complain about this particular study all you want, but study after study after study has shown that Sesame Street gives kids a leg up.
The ironic thing is that kids are fine with slower-paced shows. I adored Mister Rogers when I was little.
What silliness. C’mon. Too much correlation over nothing here people. Unbelievable. I am betting, if you asked many of the Top Exec’s. of today if They watched these so called fast Paced Cartoons as young Children, most would say they did. It’s not any particular media that changes the Child, it’s the Child’s make up in general, that controls How they View/React to anything.
Listen news stop tryen to start stuff thats why it says Y7 when it starts and if parents want to let kids watch it!!!
if fast cutting rapid images are corrosive to children’s minds, why not target their #1 purpetraitor, COMMERCIALS!