SUNDAY AM, 6TH UPDATE: Hollywood’s scary 3 months of slumping North American box office is officially over — appropriately enough at the start of Halloweek. In fact Paranormal Activity 3 (which cost only $5M) recorded the biggest horror opening of all time and the biggest October debut this weekend not adjusted for inflation or ticket pricing, according to Paramount. Its worldwide cume is now $80M. For decades, studios have had to spend more and more to keep their big franchises aloft. Not the Paranormal Activity series, and in this economic climate that’s become a very attractive model for the studios.
1. Paramount’s Paranormal Activity 3 as predicted is setting a franchise best with what rival studios say is $54M for the weekend after opening to $26.2M Friday and $18.2 Saturday in 3,321 theaters. So kudos to Oren Peli and Jason Blum who returned to produce the small-budget big-secret feature. True, audiences gave it only a ‘C+’ CinemaScore. Then again how many horror films are well-reviewed enough to receive 80% fresh on Rotten Tomatoes with raves from Time Magazine and Entertainment Weekly? “Our usual crowd of older teens and 20 year olds were joined by a big increase in folks in their 30s and 40s where the great reviews really helped,” a Paramount exec told me Sunday morning. Of course, there was a -30% drop from Friday to Saturday. (PA2 dropped -35%.) That’s because PA3 took in $8M midnights from 2,200 U.S. locations overnight Thursday which was +30% higher than the sequel Paranormal Activity 2 which earned $6.3M from 1,800 locations. Pre-release, Paramount was lowballing the threequel to gross at least $35M in domestic box office. But PA2 made $40.6M its 2010 pre-Halloween weekend, then competitor Saw 3D debuted the following Friday. PA3 has no such rival this time around. So Hollywood knew it would make a lot more money.
PA3 is a game-changer since the track record in the U.S. for almost all franchises is that the sequel opens bigger than the first but then the threequel opens slightly lower than the second. Paranormal Activity 3‘s strong tracking for weeks showed wannasee not just with young males but also with older moviegoers. Exit polls showed that moviegoers were 46% male vs 54% female, 53% under age 25 vs 47% over age 25. So no surprise this bloodless thriller broke Hollywood’s 3-month-long box office slump this weekend. Not since Fox’s Rise Of The Planet Of The Apes ($54.8M) on August 5th has there been a big grossing domestic opener beyond $30.1M (Disney’s Lion King 3D). PA3 cost only $5M, making the low-budget high-grossing franchise “the gift that keeps on giving,” as a studio exec tells me. (PA1 did $108M/$85M foreign, while PA2 did $85M in the U.S. and $93M foreign.)
I remember the marketing strategy for the first Paranormal Activity: midnight screenings in a few college towns, build word of mouth over several weeks, then slowly open it across the country. Now the 3rd in the franchise gets a wide release from the get-go. “We always market this franchise in a very specific way- we try to stay true to the fanbase,” A Paramount exec tells me. “We don’t betray the conceit that the footage is real, and we rely on core fans to spread the word by doing playful stunts and allowing them to see it first.” Paramount highlighted its Thursday midnight opening in all its media. The trailer launched with Rise Of The Planet Of The Apes on August 5th – just 2 months before release, which is kinda late. The TV campaign consisted of lots of cable and very little network as well as the highest percentage of online of any movie Paramount has ever handled. ”We spend half of what most other wide releases spend in P&A and continue to let fan buzz propel release,” a Paramount exec boasted. Then again, I have to laugh at what Ariel Schulman, who directed with Henry Joost, said about how they got the PA3 gig. Oh, to have been a fly on the wall of that studio meeting: ”Catfish had a lot to do with it. Paramount were big fans and we had been on their radar. When we first interviewed with the president of Paramount, he actually said, “If you tell me right now that Catfish is fake, you’ve got the job.” And we just went real silent. And then I said, “I’m sorry, I can’t tell you that.” Because it was real. I think he figured that if we could create that authenticity dramatically, then we could do it again for this. Ultimately, we convinced them of exactly that. Catfish is completely real, but I think we have a knack for identifying the authentic moments in home video, and it plays like a narrative.”
Internationally, Paranormal Activity 3 scored $26M overseas from some 50 countries. Cumes were way up from PA2 often posting double-digit increases. UK opened with $5.7M, Australia $3.2M, Russia $2.9M, France $2.8M, and Mexico $2M. Germany, Japan and 6 other territories are left to open. To pump up global grosses, Paramount indulged in a global stunt: the first-ever worldwide tweet-to-see-it-first contest. There were 20 round-the-world fan premieres in 8 countries after a contest based on the most Twitter activity. Out of 250 cities, the winners included Melbourne, Tel Aviv, London, Sao Paulo, New York, and Hollywood’s Arclight, where thousands of fans turned out for gourmet food trucks and franchise star Katie Featherston.
2. DreamWorks/Disney’s Real Steal reeled in $3M Friday and $4.9M Saturday from 3,412 theaters at the start of its 3rd week in release. There was another nice family matinee bounce on Saturday settting up a $10.9M weekend (-33% drop from a week ago) and $67M cume. So the pic moved into second place ahead of Footloose. But DreamWorks can’t get what it needed on this film: a $125M domestic hit.
3. After a disappointing start last weekend, the Footloose reboot is having strong one-week hold for $3.4M Friday and $4.5m Saturday driven by word of mouth and its ‘A’ CinemaScore. Footloose is looking for an estimated $10.5M for the weekend (-33% from a week ago) with a $30M cume by Monday.
4. Summit Entertainment is distributing newcomer Three Musketeers 3D financed and produced by Constantin Film. Starring Milla Jovovich and Orlando Bloom, pic already opened in other parts of the world with an anemic international cume to date of $48.2M. A total of 23 additional foreign territories opened this past weekend, to bring the total to 40 currently in release including North America. But what has to be the 113th rendition of this pathetically played-out premise couldn’t make a box office dent even with (or because of, depending on your POV) Paul W.S. Anderson directing. It opened with only $2.9M Friday and $3.6M Saturday in 3,017 theaters for a weak $8.8M weekend. That’s well below Summit’s pre-release estimate of low teens. I’m told the West Coast didn’t hold up despite audiences giving it a ‘B’ CinemaScore. The film was tracking strongest with older male moviegoers and to reach them Summit focused the media spend on male-oriented programming with a concentration on sports. Constantin held a worldwide press junket in London completed with set-up shots for media outlets in front of The Tower of London, which stars in the film. Orlando Bloom (he’s still acting?) was booked for North American talk show appearances. There also was a promotion tie-in with leading TV maker Viszio.
Perhaps the most interesting marketing ploy was debuted on Friday by Milla Jovovich herself when she took to Twitter to bitchslap Summit over the promotion for Three Musketeers 3D. Jovovich texted that the film wasn’t marketed as a “fun family film” and that Summit is “resting on their laurels” because of the Twilight franchise and “making no effort” for her film. A sample: “3 musketeers” opens in the US 2night! Do you think ppl know abt the movie? Ask your friends! Do they know it’s a fun family film?… Summit hve swept “3 Musketeers”, a grt family adventure film, under the rug in the US. Shame on them. SHAME ON YOU “SUMMIT”. I asked Summit last night what it thought of Milla’s accusations, and an executive pointed out that the actress had been up in Canada shooting the next Resident Evil installment ”and probably didn’t see the campaign. She doesn’t know what she’s talking about and we don’t know where she’s coming from.” On the other hand, Jovovich is married to Three Musketeers 3D director Anderson, so it’s hard to imagine she is completely clueless to how Summit marketed the film. Nevertheless, Summit points to awareness in the 80s as a sure sign that the movie was marketed adequately. ”Wouldn’t you think she would call us first about this? It’s frustrating. it’s not the right way to behave. If she has a problem then come to the studio and talk about it.” Milla was tweeting on her flight to Japan where Three Musketeers 3D is debuting at the Tokyo International Film Festival. I wonder if Summit will cancel her car pickup and strand her at the airport for mouthing off.
5. Sony Pictures’ adult political thriller from George Clooney, Ides Of March, holds well again for $1.5M Fridayand $2.4M Saturday from 2,042 theaters at the start of its 3rd week in release and a weekend around $5.1M (-28%) for a $29M cume.
6. Alcon Entertainment/Warner Bros’ Dolphin Tale 3D stays afloat for $1.2M Friday and $2.1M Saturday from 2,858 theaters at the start of its 5th week in release and an estimated $4.7M weekend rising to 6th place for a $65M cume.
7. Sony Pictures’ Moneyball has another great hold for $1.3M Friday and 41.9M Saturday from 2,353 theaters at the start of its 5th week in release and a $4.4M weekend with $64M cume.
8. Universal’s low-budget Johnny English Reborn (1,551 theaters) opened just $1.1M for Friday and $1.4m Saturday despite audiences giving it a ‘B’ CinemaScore. That translated to a poor $4M opening for the weekend. But the studio opened this Working Title pic internationally back on September 16th and the foreign gross has reflected star Rowan Atkinson’s enormous popularity overseas. This weekend, the film is poised to reach $100 million at the international box office. It opened No. 1 in almost all of the 43 international markets where it’s been released and, with 20 international territories yet to open, it’s well on its way to grossing $200 million or more worldwide. The film opens in 6 more international markets this weekend, including France. Does the U.S. marketing plan really matter? Nah…
9. Not even Halloweek could help Universal’s horror holdover The Thing prequel which went down -59% from a week ago for $1M Friday and $1.3M Saturday from 2,995 theaters and a $3.1M weekend for $14M cume.
10. Summit’s 50/50 dramedy hangs in the Top 10 for $927K Friday and $1.3M Saturday from 1,932 theaters at the start of its 4th week in release and a $2.9M weekend with just under $29M cume by Monday.
FRIDAY NOON UPDATE: Unfortunately, Rentrak is unable to download any grosses thus far today, so there will not be any estimates based on noon averages.
Editor-in-Chief Nikki Finke - tip her here.


Just like with Wall Street: Money Never Sleeps and Too Big to Fail which were also about the global recession, Margin Call is a very important movie.
‘Margin Call’, ‘The Mighty Macs’, ‘Oranges and Sunshine’, ‘Retreat’, ‘The Reunion’ and ‘Snowmen’ should have all gotten a nationwide theatrical release. If they were given a fair chance, any one of them could have been No. 1 this week. They all have interesting casts (‘Margin Call’ – Kevin Spacey, Paul Bettany, Jeremy Irons, Zachary Quinto, Penn Badgley, Simon Baker, Mary McDonnell, Demi Moore, Stanley Tucci) (‘The Mighty Macs’ – Carla Gugino, David Boreanaz, Marley Shelton, Ellen Burstyn) (‘Oranges and Sunshine’ – Emily Watson, Hugo Weaving) (‘Retreat’ – Cillian Murphy, Jamie Bell, Thandie Newton) (‘The Reunion’ – John Cena, Ethan Embry, Michael Rispoli, Amy Smart) (‘Snowmen’ – Ray Liotta, Christopher Lloyd) with some stars who should be doing more mainstream movies. I wanted to see how they would have done commercially if released nationwide and they deserve better than to go unnoticed by the public now.
The Musketeers movies have been done to death and have become increasingly repetitious and monotonous. How many times have they made this same movie already? It’s the same story, just with different actors.
With all due respect, “The Reunion” and “Snow Men” look god-awful – there are probably good reasons for why at least those 2 were held away from national release.
Could they have put more people on the Three Musketeers poster?
I just don’t understand why there’s 2 Orlando Blooms
That’s not the story. The story is Paramount and Paranormal Activity. As a writer, it gives me hope, because yes, it’s a sequel, but someone took a chance on the original. Paramount is backing lots of money trucks up to the studio because they took a chance on an original property. If it’s original (AND GOOD), people will go. They’re dying for good movies.
Congrats to all, including, yes — MARGIN CALL people. Also an original story, even if it’s appeal is limited and its didactic.
why is it that nobody ever mentions that the name Paranormal Activity was snatched from the opening credits of the X-Files?
Margin Call was an utter disappointment – with that cast you should be able to produce something that has real Oscar aspirations but it’s completely inert. The final scene is one of the worst “trying to be metaphoric” attempts ever – embarrassing. Handed to a director with a clue of how to produce a movie and it may have been half-decent.
Obviously, all entitled to their opinions, of course. But I really loved Margin Call, including the haunting last scene. I loved it. And for whatever it is worth, so did all of the major critics in the country — AO Scott’s review yesterday in New York Times, LA Times, Wall Street Journal, Rolling Stone, New Yorker, Entertainment Weekly, Variety, New York Magazine… etc. Most of which are saying it deserves awards attention for Kevin Spacey, Jeremy Irons, and the writing and directing. Demi Moore and Penn Badgley were even good in it.
Again – not for everybody, I’m sure. But I thought the writer-director guy did a great job. I’m not a financial person, but it was the movie I wished Wall Street 2 had been.
The “writer-director” guy? You know all the favorable reviews, and take the time to list them, but you expect us to believe that you’re not the writer-director guy? Posting about himself?
ha ha, so true!
I saw Margin Call this weekend on Video On Demand. It was excellent. All the performances were really good and a great cast.
The last one also did not have 10pm shows
Yes it did. I saw Paranormal Activity 2 at 10 PM last year and I know many other theaters also showed it at that time.
It also opened on 400 more screens.
I wish this movie would flop! How many more times can you beat a dead horse! Boo! A shadow of a person! Boo! An actor being tugged backwards! PA4 – The grandparents were haunted too!
Saw it last night at a 10PM screening, it was terrifying, easily the scariest one yet. The last 15 minutes are wild but it’s hard to see how the franchise is going to last after this one as it uses all the tricks in the arsenal.
I saw it at 6pm today. People were screaming their heads off. Definitely the scariest of them all. With that hellafied ending they really got the audience jazzed for part four. This is going to be huge. H U G E!
PA2 did indeed have 10PM’s, though this one did open on more screens.
Don’t get your hopes up, Hollywood. Nothing else opening this weekend is worth a damn.
Once word get out how terrible this movie is it will be on DVD DL real soon.
Whenever your film makes back it’s budget and then some off of the midnight showings alone, you know you are doing SOMETHING right. I am curious though if Paramount still spends under $20M marketing these things. Anyone have the P&A numbers?
Still, a sequel should be announced within the week. I saw it and was surprised how well the suspense still held up even three outings in and that they managed to keep a semi-good plot going, just winging it every year. The SAW writers should’ve taken a note from these writers on how to script a franchise off the cuff.
Making back the budget from midnight screenings does not tell the whole story. In addition to the P & A costs (already mentioned by others) the profit participation deals will take a sizable chunk out of Paramount’s coffers, even with creative accounting. Not that the movie won’t still be hugely profitable.
‘Margin Call’, ‘The Mighty Macs’, ‘Oranges and Sunshine’, ‘Retreat’, ‘The Reunion’ and ‘Snowmen’ should have all gotten a nationwide theatrical release. If they were given a fair chance, any one of them could have been No. 1 this week. They all have interesting casts (‘Margin Call’ – Kevin Spacey, Paul Bettany, Jeremy Irons, Zachary Quinto, Penn Badgley, Simon Baker, Mary McDonnell, Demi Moore, Stanley Tucci) (‘The Mighty Macs’ – Carla Gugino, David Boreanaz, Marley Shelton, Ellen Burstyn) (‘Oranges and Sunshine’ – Emily Watson, Hugo Weaving) (‘Retreat’ – Cillian Murphy, Jamie Bell, Thandie Newton) (‘The Reunion’ – John Cena, Ethan Embry, Michael Rispoli, Amy Smart) (‘Snowmen’ – Ray Liotta, Christopher Lloyd) with some stars who should be doing more mainstream movies. I wanted to see how they would have done commercially if released nationwide and they deserve better than to go unnoticed by the public now.
My buddy saw this film and said it sucked ass.
Guess beggars can’t be choosers, though.
HATED IT. And this coming from someone who spent a sleepless night after the first. The second was fairly entertaining but this one is just a worthless retread and cash grab with nothing new to offer.
Agree. Hated It! Loved the first one. They took out all the scares at the end. What happened to the great thrilling scenes we saw in the previews? That’s what I signed up for. Not blah, blah, blah story at the end. Give me scares. If they do a PA4, I’ll be skipping it.
So all you haters of everything Hollywood is making – who wouldn’t stop whining last weekend – here comes Paranormal Activity 3, a joke of a franchise from a business perspective, it’s good – not taking anything away from it – but still a joke… and you all run out and see it.
You don’t see Drive, you don’t see Warrior, some of you see Moneyball – and you complain that hollywood doesn’t have an ounce of creativity – yet you run out to Paranormal Activity 3.
In other words, STFU.
True this.
(Although I doubt those who’re angry at HWood over a lack of creativity/good product are those rushing out to see the crap “PA” movies)
DRIVE was great, but an art film. No word of mouth. That said, it will be very, very profitable.
WARRIOR was good, but two unknown actors with a sport that hasn’t captured the imagination. Kinda too soon after THE FIGHTER, and no women had any reason to go. Guys knew it was a cliche story, even if it was good, so it’s no reason to spend the cash.
MONEYBALL did well, given its a hard sell. It was a great script, good performances, but not worth paying for if you already know the ending, which most guys did.
The only movie of these that was truly original was DRIVE, but gutting the script of all dialogue wasn’t smart if you want a wide-release film.
Apples and Oranges. Both Drive and PA3 were equally good relative to their respective genres. Aside from the fact that PA3 is another sequel (better a sequel than another reboot) and Drive is an original film, they both satisfy their target audience.
Is this Herman Cain?
It took me a second, but you did make laugh…
I don’t think people complaining about Hollywood are complaining that it lacks creativity; I think everyone assumes that there is very little creativity or artistic ability in Hollywood. I think what they are complaining about is the complete lack of quality in the films that Hollywood churns out week after week. PA might be a dumb film, but it’s one that people want to see. That’s more than can be said for the vast majority of films Hollywood has released lately.
I saw DRIVE, WARRIOR and MONEYBALL and PA3. So what does that make me? I’m also a woman who loves movies. I read this board with a half ear as I know half the people who post out there are pissed off studio/producer folks who wanted their movie to do better at the box office.
You know who you are. The half of you who don’t give a fuck (yeah, I’m a woman saying FUCK) about the artistic sense of movies anymore. All you see are dollar signs cha-chinging in your eyelids.
BTW, I think Hossein Amini should get an Oscar nod for DRIVE along with Ryan Gosling. Brilliant movie!
henry: “Paranormal Activity 3, a joke of a franchise from a business perspective.”
these three films have made over 450 million dollars worldwide, and counting — and they cost 8,015,000 million to make.
…what the hell ‘business’ are you talking about?
I guess Nikki really loves this film…In her honor I will watch Brides Maids tonight.
Oh PS…Hated Paranormal 1…I am still sitting in that theater seat waiting for the scare…No desire to be tricked again…
Paranormal 2 was sooo good that I think a lot of people will see part 3.
I wanted to see Margin Call but sadly it’s not playing in my state
The mystery remains…where the hell is Area 51????????????????????????? That’s what everyone wants to know!
Will be released in 2012.
wrong poster. That is the poster for the 2nd film
Fail.
…or, that was a very witty comment on the state of this series. They’re all the same movie. They’re all done the same way. Why shouldn’t the posters be interchangeable?
I take it none of you have seen the movie yet, since a most glaring, awful thing has occurred and no one is talking about it yet: NOT ONE SCENE OF THE TRAILER IS IN THE MOVIE!!!!!!
Deceptive advertising is wrong on many levels…but this one takes the cake!
Are you serious? No exaggeration, not a single scene?
Can’t somebody file a class-action lawsuit about this?
I love that so many of the scenes in the trailer are not in the movie because it keeps you on edge. You’re nervous waiting for those scenes to show up (and they don’t) and then you get scared when stuff happens that wasn’t in the trailer.
People usually complain when trailers give away too much, geez.
Although true (about people complaining that too much is given away), I’d rather be shown too much of what’s IN the movie versus being completely side-swiped by all new material. There was enough other stuff in the movie that wasn’t revealed that they could have kept the trailer scenes intact. They did this with part 2 as well, with scenes that weren’t in the final film. But at least most of what was in THAT trailer made it IN!
Are you kidding? You “rather be shown too much of what’s IN the movie versus being completely side-swiped by all new material”?? That makes no sense. I don’t think you understand the point of a horror film. You are supposed to be scared and surprised and sideswiped by unexpected frights. That is the whole point. If you have already been shown “too much” then the movie has failed and will not deliver a satisfying experience.
That’s exactly what was great about it. Normally all the money shots are in the trailer to such an extent that you don’t need to see the film if all the best shots have already been used in commercials. This was genius to use deleted scene type footage that looks spooky but then when the real money shots (kitchen scene is all I will say, if you saw it then you know what I mean) happen in the film you have no idea they are coming.
love the site but have I missed something? Where are all the autopsy reports promised?
Was wondering that myself just the other day.
I’m with you on the call for more autopsies, J. I was just sitting here and wondering what the heck happened to “MACHINE GUN PREACHER” with ‘super star’ Gerard Butler…. the advance hype and marketing tie-ins, along with quasi-religious undertones, seemed to hint at the potential for a hit, especially in rock-ribbed “red” part of America. Instead, the movie went quietly into the good night. Anyone know what the hell happened to that train wreck? Now, THAT is an autopsy I would pay to read…
Did the first Johnny English make money in the US?
rowan atkinson is just not remotely funny to us americans.
25mil friday but “as much as 45″ wknd total? is the box office that front loaded on something like this?
if friday is 25, 45 wknd seems an anomaly
Part 3s that opened higher than part 2 – Scream 3, X-Men 3, Harry Potter 3, Lord of the Rings 3, Spider-Man 3, Saw 3, Bourne 3, Star Wars Episode 3, etc… Why is Paranormal Activity 3 a game changer again?
damn you are right…thanks for pointing that all…looks like most franchises that make it to a #3 is hot enough for #3 to open bigger than #2..Nikki might need to drop the “game changer” line.
When is anyone going to talk about the steaming pile of s*%t Musketeers took?!?
Okay.
Hey everybody, the 3 MUSKETEERS 3-D Steampunk videogame remake crashed and burned! Perhaps there’s hope for the future of cinema after all.
No one gives a shit.
“This is a game-changer since the track record in the U.S. for almost all franchises is that the sequel opens bigger than the first but then the threequel opens slightly lower than the second.”
Eh? Gamechanger? What now? For tentpoles agreed it is not too common, but certainly not unheard of (Harry Potter, X-Men, Lotr, Bourne). For “midsize” horror films its is actually very very common. The Final Destination, Saw, Resident Evil franchises all had bigger OW 3rds than 2nds and now so does PA. Nothing new here
Spot On da truth. Apart from the above you and Scott Mendelson mention there are many more – ie Batman Forever, Jackass, Indy, Rocky etc.
Nikki you need a course in Box Office history
She never said it didn’t happen, she was suggesting a general trend. There are always exceptions to the rule.
“She never said it didn’t happen, she was suggesting a general trend. There are always exceptions to the rule.”
– how is the line..” A GAME CHANGER” mean she was suggestion a general trend…man that was a dumb ass line…carry on
Yes, and in this case the RULE is that third parts in low budget horror franchises do in fact increase. The exception woulda been if it hadn’t…
Well ever since the Paranormal Activity fims which have been made not single one didn’t come to Vicksburg Ms. Not even the third installment. Nor did Mighty Macs etc. And the Help didn’t open here either I might add which was an insult.
Sorry Chuck. You live in what Deadline refers to as “flyover” country. You and your movie opinion does not matter.
If Paranormal Activity it playing on 3,321 screens in the US this weekend, I’d guess it has coverage in almost every city and town with a population of over 10,000 from California to the New York islands.
Maybe the theater chain(s) that run things in Chuck’s town have previous commitments?
I looked up what’s playing in Vicksburg, MS: The Thing, 3 Musketeers, Dolphin Tale, 50/50, and Dream House. That’s on one theater with four screens. Looking at the schedule, you’d think the managers of the Pemberton Square 4 could make room for Paranormal Activity. (Drop Dream House?) For whatever reason, they have not.
I would have loved to have seen Johnny English Reborn this weekend, but it’s not playing within two hours of me. I saw the first one on opening weekend at my local theater, but this one is opening on a lot fewer screens. Guess I’ll just have to re-watch the original until this one makes it to DVD.
…which will be soon