Michael Harrison, producer of I Dreamed A Dream, the musical biography of Susan Boyle that starts its out-of-town UK tour in March 2012, tells me he is in talks with U.S. impresarios about bringing the show to America. “Obviously there is huge potential for the show in America, so that is very much part of the plan,” he says. I Dreamed A Dream is the musical life story of Boyle, 50, who was a dumpy Scottish misfit before Simon Cowell sprinkled his stardust over her and she became the Britain’s Got Talent and YouTube singing sensation. Boyle will step out onstage at the show’s finale and sing the show tune that made her famous. The clip of her singing I Dreamed A Dream from Les Miserables has had 300 million YouTube hits to date. And her Grammy-nominated debut album has sold just over 10 million copies, while follow-up The Gift racked up another 4 million. The British tour kicks off in Newcastle and then travels around the provinces — although surprisingly there is no London date. “The West End will come later,” Harrison assures me. Elaine C Smith, a British actress who starred in the West End stage version of Calendar Girls, will play Boyle onstage. Presumably they will have to find an American star to play Boyle in the U.S. version. So (deep breath), which American actress would be right to play SuBo, as she’s affectionately known over here?

Rosie O’Donnell. She sings and is obviously right ohysicaly. Bernadette Peters? In other words , short, plump musical theater actresses of a certain age.
Why cant Elaine C Smith play the role in the USA. Loads of US actresses play roles in the UK so why cant a UK actress play in the USA?
Glenn Close.
Glenn Close would be great. She sings well enough (Mama Mia) & is a huge draw for American audiences.
Sorry I got Glenn Close confused with Meryl Streep. I think she should play Susan.
Kathy Bates
I think Elaine Smith should play Susan here in the US, too. Why not have a Scottish actress play a Scottish singer? Elaine Smith is a good actress and is believable for the role.
Kathy Bates is too pretty.
I agree with Cathy–Elaine Smith should play her. If not possible, Kathy Bates. By the way, Susan sprinkled stardust on Simon!
I agree,my vote goes to Elaine C Smith to play Susan here in the USA.
Donna Murphy.