
The 20th Century Fox promo that teased the upcoming first trailer for the Ridley Scott-directed Prometheus certainly seemed different from Scott’s iconic science fiction film Alien — but does one small clue at the end indicate there’s a closer tie to the franchise than previously believed? Fox and Scott originally set up the film to be a prequel to Alien, but that changed when Damon Lindelof came in for a rewrite job and ended up changing the focus enough that the combination of Jon Spaihts and Lindelof’s script is considered an original. But a look at the producing credits at the end of the promo raises eyebrows. Scott is credited as producer along with David Giler and Walter Hill. The latter two had nothing to do with this film, but Giler and Hill were producers on the original 1979 film, and they have gotten credit of some kind on every single Alien film, including two Alien vs. Predator spinoffs. An insider spoiled my hunch I’d found something here. They told me that the producing credit came from a long-ago settlement with Giler and Hill, and was warranted because of the origin of Prometheus before it broke away from the iconic Alien. The fact that the script credit only goes to Spaihts and Lindelof, with no mention that it’s based on characters created by original scribes Dan O’Bannon and Ronald Shusett, proves that it’s an original, I was told.


this falls into the “who gives a crap” category. The original Alien is over 30 years old and no one under 25 has seen it or cares about it. This is fanboy wank territory at best. Prometheus will rise or fall on its own. Don’t burden it with such ludicrous expectations.
do you feel that way about film that is older than 25 years? Is all cinematic history before 1980 lost on you? Pity.
no. cinematic history isn’t lost on me. That wasn’t the point. The point was that some itty-bitty sliver of Alien connectivity is only of interest to about 10 people on the planet and trying to connect these threads is going to end up hurting Prometheus, not helping it. Alien is a classic. With all love to the Godfather and Toy Story, Aliens might be the best sequel of all time. But the rest of the sequels and spinoffs have been awful, even by some really talented people directing like Fincher and Jeunet. So, why feed this frenzy at all? The bar gets set so high, particularly with Ridley being at the helm, and it will never live up to those nostalgic memories that Alien fans have, nor to the reviewers who will all lead with “it ain’t no Alien” no matter how good it is.
Actually I’m only 24 and I can say that there is a large portion of my age group (at least in my area) that have not only seen the Alien series but still find it enjoyable. I attribute mine to my dad being a big fan of Sci-Fi and quite a few of my friends were introduced to the movies via similar channels (i.e. older siblings, parents, etc.)
I do have to agree with your last bit though- Prometheus should (and most likely will) be treated as its own movie. Setting it up as part of the Alien franchise has a small chance of bringing in people but also sets it up for bad reviews if it doesn’t “fit” what people expect. Personally I’m tired of sequels and remakes so it would be nice to see something fresh(ish) in theaters.
What an idiotic comment, just because people are young doesn’t mean they don’t sometimes seek out older movies.
really im 23 and ive seen the original Alien about 50 times soooooooo get your facts right! Hell now that i think about it my sister is 18 and she has seen it and so has my cousin and hes 22 so yea you def need to get your facts right ppl will go and see this movie and people my age AND YOUNGER do appreciate older movies! The fact that you say that is a slap in the face! save your self some time and, “Don’t burden it with such ludicrous expectations”
All of this is PR magic. And I’m loving every single second of it. Wonderful way of building mystery around the film. All that said, there is no doubt in my mind that this is an Alien movie. Even further, I predict it will end with the derelict crashing on LV-426, incinerating the space jockey (who will in fact be the creator of the alien race – created as a weapon for colonization, perhaps even targeting earth which would necessitate the team giving their lives and crashing the ship). Can’t wait for the return of real, thoughtful science fiction!!!
By the way – you need only listen to Ridley’s audio commentaries on the recent Blu Ray’s to know that this is the direction he always wanted to take the series if he came back on.
could it be that this film contains a great twist at the end that lays bare its origin and the filmmakers are doing everything they can to keep that surprise under wraps?
I for one cannot wait for this movie, but I wish they would just decide how to market it. The cast and crew keep saying it’s not an Alien prequel. If that is the case, then it’s pretty crappy of Fox to completely market it like one, down to the same music from the Alien trailer. This could be a huge bait and switch.
What’s there to analyze here? There are understandable reasons why Fox doesn’t want to market it as an “Alien prequel” per se, but everyone involved (Scott, Lindelof, the cast) has confirmed that it is set in the same universe as Alien, takes place before Alien, and has narrative elements that tie in to Alien.
Also, I’m not sure that the absence of O’Bannon and Shusett’s names on the poster means that they won’t be credited on the actual film. But I don’t know enough about WGA credit policies to be sure about that.
Ridley Scott has already stated that the xenomorph will NOT be in Prometheus. But the ‘Space Jockey’ (that big fossil elephant man briefly glimpsed in the original) will be. So clearly it has at least one connection to Alien regardless of what Fox are saying.
I’m actually 16 and saw the alien movies approximately 3 years ago and have since become a huge fan.
Personally, this kind of information helps solidify wether or not PROMETHEUS is an ALIEN prequel/spin-off/original story.
Scott has been very cryptic with his information, and even though I have been following the production of this movie since before it was named, this kind if information still helps.
My opinion, that’s all
Excuse me, but I’m 17 and I’ve watched the Alien films since I was 4, thank you.
your parents let you watch the Alien movies when you were 4??? Um, Child Services I think would like a word with them.
I’ll say it again – Walter Hill’s name in the credit block is a dead giveaway. Funny that they’re trying to keep it all under wraps when the credits give it away instantly.
So, the title slowly emerging in the first half of the trailer and the eerie screams, both from the original marketing of ALIEN, isn’t a big enough hint?