After some heated back-and-forth yesterday during the House Judiciary Committee’s markup of the Stop Online Piracy Act, the panel adjourned today without a final vote on the contentious bill, which seeks to shut down access to foreign websites deemed to be infringing copyrights. The fight pits content creators — like Hollywood studios and networks — who want their wares protected against tech companies who fear censorship and a curb on innovation. The delay means a vote on SOPA won’t take place until House leadership is called back, which probably won’t be until January. (The Senate’s piracy legislation, the PROTECT IP Act, already has passed out of committee.) House Judiciary Chairman Lamar Smith, R-Texas, was well on his way to striking down various amendments to the bill, meaning it eventually is likely to be approved by the panel and head to the House for a full vote. “The Judiciary Committee’s overwhelming support for the bill shows that the legislative process, when allowed to work, can result in strong, bi-partisan legislation that will protect millions of American jobs and creativity,” Michael O’Leary, the MPAA’s policy chief, said today. The Hill blog said Smith was more open to a suggestion by members to allow a study by cybersecurity experts to weigh the impact of some of the proposed legislation — a concession that has heartened opponents of the bill. “NetCoalition is encouraged that Chairman Smith is considering the requests of many on the committee that additional hearings be conducted, particularly on the issue of Internet security, in order that the committee be fully briefed on the potentially serious and negative consequences that the proposed legislation would create,” NetCoalition executive director Markham Erickson said.


Gee, all those decades of demonizing Republicans in everything that came out of Hollywood doesn’t seem like a smart thing now, does it?
Sweetie, many Republicans have been for this piece of crap bill that skips right over traditional American values like “due process.” So I don’t know who the hell you’re laughing at, unless you’ve got a problem with the Founding Fathers.
Not all content creators are in favor of this bill – I create content in the industry, and I am vehemently against it. Obviously something needs to be done to help curb piracy, but this bill will effectively censor the internet as a free, global medium of communication while the pirates will merely go further underground. It’s ineffective and short sighted. Passing it would be a disaster.
Ditto “writer” above. I earn 100% of my income via copyright. My books have definitely been pirated — easy to find on the torrents. But this bill is a dangerously stupid overreaction.
Amen. And also a naive one. Writers and publishers have probably lost more royalty money to Amazon making it absurdly easy to buy used copies of a book than we ever have/will on deliberate piracy. I suspect some of the DVD sales the film/TV industries think they’re losing to pirates are probably also going to legit second-hand sellers on Amazon.
Vote delayed until January. That means that the campaign contribution bidding war for congressional votes will go up. A great new revenue stream for an election year.
My bet is on on the internet and equipment industry winning this one, for now. They have more money and power on the hill than the MPAA etc. They are also many orders of magnitude larger that the entertainment business.
The war is over. Entertainment needs to live in the new “real world”
Now about those photocopy machines, audio cassettes, VCR’s, and dreaded DVD’s. What is Chris Dodd going to do about them???
what’s an audio cassette ?
SOPA has NOT been postponed to 2012! The Committee members who support SOPA quietly changed the hearing date to the 21st, trying to trick the American people into thinking it was over for the year. This is dirty politics and should be illegal. Fight back. Let them know this is not over.
Piracy is indeed bad but this bill is worse.
Is anybody else sick of these companies that profit from piracy using their illegal funds to block this wonderful legislation? We need to shut down these rogue sites such as Reporters Without Borders, the ACLU, Human Rights Watch, American Library Association, the Electronic Frontier Foundation and the Brookings Institute ASAP.
In my opinion the only way that this bill will get passed is if congress ignores the people. I am not an expert on politics but its clear the American people don’t want this bill passed, passing the bill will not only violate the obvious rights, but will clearly violate our democratic way of life. The ruling is Mr big wig we dont want this passed.