The WGA East like other unions and guilds has been a supporter of the Occupy protests that have cropped up around the nation, especially in New York City. But Occupy Wall Street’s recent siege of a Manhattan set for NBC and Wolf Films’ Law & Order: SVU — a show written and produced by WGA East members and featuring a crew from other industry unions — has got the guild peeved. The set was part of an episode that centered on a crime committed at the Occupy camp site at New York’s Zuccotti Park, and protesters made their opposition to it known by “occupying” the location at midnight before the NYPD cleared them out. The city pulled the show’s filming permit and the shoot never happened. Here’s WGA East’s open letter to protesters and the police, whom it takes to task for making them strike the set.
To Occupy Wall Street and the New York Police Department:
The Writers Guild of America, East (WGAE), an affiliate of the AFL-CIO, has strongly and actively supported the Occupy Wall Street movement from its inception. Our union members and staff have participated in many OWS actions, and we have endorsed OWS’ important message that corporate greed and economic inequality are wrong.
So we were disappointed to learn that last week people associated with Occupy Wall Street disrupted the set of an episode of Law & Order: SVU, written and produced by members of the WGAE, and crewed by other entertainment industry union members. The demonstrators’ actions were as misguided and inappropriate as the City of New York’s response – revoking Law & Order’s permit for the shoot and directing the dismantling of its set. Presumably the protesters and police did not set out to achieve a common end but together they prevented the scene from being filmed and the story from being told.
Freedom of speech is freedom of speech, whether it is the OWS demonstrators’ right to peacefully assemble and protest without fear of retribution or Law & Order’s ability to film in the streets of New York and tell its stories without fear of vandalism from protesters or overreaction by the police. New York City has worked very hard to encourage television and film production, and we know it will continue to do so. Everyone who works in the industry supports this, including the Writers Guild, East.
We continue to support Occupy Wall Street’s aims and in the tradition of a city with a long history of upholding the right of free, peaceful speech for all, urge both the members of OWS and the police to treat last week’s occurrence as an isolated incident, vowing that it not be repeated. We would be happy to meet with your representatives at any time to discuss this further. Thank you for your attention.



I support a lot of what the OWS stands for too but what they did was just really stupid.
What do you gain from shutting down Law & Order?
“The Revolution will not be televised.”
Everyone’s a liberal until their profits are interfered with.
Maybe they were protesting the fact that Law & Order is still on the air?
“21 years?!! Enough!”
maybe they should have talked to the OWS people before hand and this wouldn’t have happened. But no, like most all things, those with the power and money assume that everyone will see it their way, because we are supposed to believe them. I think that Wolf probably is sympathetic if not supportive of OWS but they never made an attempt to engage OWS until it was way too late to figure out. It’s a shame because they normally dramatize current events in a creative and thought provoking way…
I’m assuming you missed the final season of the original L&O, which was anything but “creative and thought provoking.”
L&O routinely rips off the headlines for its own use. Looks like OWS beat them at their own game. Touche OWS!
The letter makes a valid point, but it will only fall on deaf ears, since the movie set “occupation” was merely a wave of hysteria generated by mob mentality.
But the incident serves to perfectly highlight the most common element shared by most of the groups that protest anything in this country: HYPOCRISY!
OWS – and all its derivatives – is a movement that depends upon the First Amendment right to freedom of speech, yet its participants have no qualms about suppressing that same right for others.
If the Producers had approached OccupyWallStreet in the first place, as opposed to the union now saying “We would be happy to meet with your representatives at any time to discuss this further” Id guess this wouldn’t have happened. These people felt exploited and chose to act.
The protestors were right, in my view. While visibility is what OWS seeks, the light needs to shine on Wall Street and it’s excesses, corporation influence on politics. And, not just in art dept made signs. Depicting a sexual assault at the camp only hinders any sort of support the writers and this union could assume their highlighting the movement could bring.
What do they get from shutting down L & O? Now, the millions of people who would have seen that, will not see the isolated incident that led mainstream media to claim it was “dangerous” at OWS camp. I’ve never felt more safe anytime downtown (OccupyLA, anyways)
approach… who?
The movement is very proud and vocal about the fact that they have no leaders.
Your report is inaccurate — the city didn’t pull SVU’s filming permit. SVU had a permit to film in Foley Square but they didn’t have a permit to build a set on Foley Square. Their location department neglected to get the proper permit — and so SVU WAS IN VIOLATION OF CITY FILMING REQUIREMENTS.
OWS didn’t shut down filming, they walked through an empty set the night before filming and then left after an hour.
OWS exercised their freedom of speech and didn’t stop anyone from exercising theirs. It’s the SVU Location Department that screwed up.
I’m sure Dick Wolf knocked some heads senseless over their permit fuck-up.
blame the location department? nice try. did u watch the u tube videos? set was not empty, it was built & then looted. I’m sure the mayor knocked some heads senseless too.
Sorry, you’re obviously not familiar with film/tv production. The set was empty – i.e., there was no filming going on, no camera, no actors — just a set with a couple of p.a.s keeping watch. BTW, the set was not looted.
And yes, the location department fucked up by not getting a permit to build a set in Foley Square.
The shoot took place today in ft lee, nj, birthplace of cinema. The OWS set was way better than the real OWS, which is a bunch of rich wannabes, at least in NYC. Seriously, I knew three of the original thirty or so protesters and each came from the kind of wealth that would make a CEO blush. One actually had an argument with her amex black card concierge while protesting the banks.
Bells, you are the minister of misinformation. OWS did “walk through” the set at midnight the night before. They also vandalized and looted the set. It is on their own video which they posted on Youtube. The police responded, and again, on the same videos, they announce the permit has been revoked and the set must be dismantled. Ten hours later, scrambling for a reason for the permit’s revocation, they told the press SVU didn’t have the right permits. EVERYONE in New York tv knew that was a smokescreen. SVU and L&O have shot a thousand episodes in NY. They know what permits are needed when. NYPD needed to rationalize shutting a production down, so they unearthed a never required “rigging permit” technicality. Rigging permits are for heavy equipment, not tents.
Bells, you don’t know the facts, or choose to disregard them. Kudos to the WGA for reminding us that neither political groups or NYPD should prohibit free speech.
Finally, no, OWS shouldn’t have a write to preview a script before deciding whether or not to “Moccupy” a set. I support them on many things, but they treated others the same way NYPD has treated them.
All anyone has to do is go to a General Assembly. They will be heard if they want to be.
Their idea is to get noticed. If I’m not mistaken this has gotten a little attention.