
This morning, I reported rumblings I’d heard that the Peter Jackson and Fran Walsh-financed Sundance documentary West Of Memphis would likely drop some revelations that could provoke the state of Arkansas to take a closer look at the 1993 murder of three youths that was originally pinned on West Memphis 3 defendants Damien Echols, Jason Baldwin and Jessie Misskelley. The film’s first press screening is still going on, but a release has just been sent out from Echols’ legal team about the new revelations that are in the Amy Berg-directed film and came from a WM3 tipline arranged by the legal team fighting to get the three defendants exonerated. Here is the release:
(Mountain Home, Arkansas – January 20, 2012) Terry Hobbs’ nephew, Michael Hobbs Jr., allegedly told his friends “my uncle Terry murdered those three little boys,” according to declarations under penalty of perjury recently given to Damien Echols’ defense team. The three new witnesses were polygraphed about what they stated Michael Hobbs, Jr. told them.
“One day Michael picked us up in his truck. He was very quiet and upset. Michael then said to us, ‘you are not going to believe what my dad told me today. My Uncle Terry murdered the three little boys.’ According to Michael, his dad called this ‘The Hobbs Family Secret’ and he asked us to keep it a secret and not tell anyone.”
Another witness stated, “One night last winter, Michael and I were playing pool in his basement when the third friend asked about the West Memphis Three case which had been in the news. Michael responded by saying, ‘My uncle killed three kids in West Memphis.’ Michael was dead serious when he said this.”
The three little boys referenced in the declarations were found brutally murdered in West Memphis, Arkansas in 1993. DNA consistent with Terry Hobbs, stepfather of victim Stevie Branch, was later discovered in the knot of a shoelace used to restrain victim Michael Moore. Three eyewitnesses have also provided sworn statements that they saw Terry Hobbs with the three children on the day of the murders, immediately before they disappeared. Terry Hobbs has maintained that he never saw the three boys the day they were murdered.
A third witness stated that he was at Michael Hobbs Jr’s home in 2003 or 2004 when he was told by Hobbs Jr. that the two of them could not go down to the basement to play pool because Michael Hobbs Sr. was down there having a conversation with Hobbs Jr.’s uncle. The witness said that he “ listened with Michael Jr. at the top of the stairs. I heard two men talking. One appeared to be very upset even crying and he said ‘I am sorry, I regret it.’ The other man was trying to console him and said, ‘You are in the clear, no one thinks you are a suspect, those guys are already in prison.’”
Echols’ attorney, Stephen Braga of Ropes & Gray, said: “This is critical new information which reveals that the people closest to Terry Hobbs, his family members, may know much more about Terry’s involvement in the West Memphis Three case than they have ever acknowledged. If this is the Hobbs Family Secret, then what a horrific cost that secrecy has imposed on the lives of so many people – perhaps most significantly Pam Hobbs who deserves to know what really happened to Stevie on the night of the murders, as do the Byers and Moore families. With the secret now out, let’s hope that someone in the Hobbs family has the heart, the soul and the courage to come forward to tell the truth directly. In the meantime, I have given our investigative materials concerning these new witnesses – along with other related information – to District Attorney Scott Ellington for his review and action.”
The new witnesses came forward after seeing a recording of the CBS News 48 Hours special on the West Memphis 3 case. At the end of that broadcast, attorney Stephen Braga was asked what’s next in the effort to gain exoneration for the three after their plea deal. He responded: “Hopefully, some day we will find that smoking gun, that key piece of inculpatory DNA or a deathbed confession or a witness will come forward and say, “You know, this is really what happened.”
Hearing those words moved the new witnesses to contact the West Memphis 3 Confidential Tip Line just a few weeks ago. The new witnesses were then interviewed by the Echols’ defense team, signed declarations under penalty of perjury and passed polygraph examinations concerning what they say Michael Hobbs Jr. told them.
The Confidential Tip Line number is (501) 256-1775.


Um, wow.
i can see hobbs wanting to kill his stepkid, maybe he was just beating him (as we are told he did on many occasions) and let’s say the boy died.. and the two other boys saw.. and then hobbs killed the witnesses.. it seems much more probable than now what we know about the 3 they carried on a witch hunt for, and took 18 years of their life. god i hate religion.
What does religion have to do with anything Andrea? Stop bringing in your own personal prejudices into this. Isn’t that the reason for this entire miscarriage of justice? Jurors and the public brought in their prejudices against the three teens because they listened to heavy metal music and were a little weird?
That sort of thing works both ways.
Puim, the prosecution’s argument was that the teens were involved with the Wiccan religion, and the murders were part of some kind of satanic ritual. So it was a RELIGIOUS prejudice which fuelled the collective hysteria that led to the convictions. It was a fervently Christian town, and it would not have happened in a secular one. It wasn’t JUST religion – a lack of education and intelligent thought were a big part of it too, but the religious fanaticism was the flame needed to ignite those highly susceptible local minds, and start the wildfire that quickly engulfed the lives of these three men.
Not all religion is like that, but blind, fundamentalist fanaticism is one of the most dangerous things on earth, and religion is its parent.
Stupidity and religious fanaticism: a symbiotic relationship.
How about both of you waking from your delusions to see the police had their murderers from the beginning? Have you ever considered how much effort and how many cops and prosecutors would have to get together to conspire to frame these boys? And then to keep their stories straight and none of the dozen or so co-conspirators ever coming forward with an attack of conscience. All three of them admitted the murders to numerous sources. I read the Misskelly confession and while problematic, that boy was most assuredly telling the truth. I understand the legal problems but that gives me no reason to think they are innocent. And the celebrity freaks don’t influence my opinion one iota.
It’s obvious that Terry Hobbs killed those boys, and this new info/witness just reaffirms it. Problem is, I don’t see anything being done to bring the real killer to justic and/or fully clear the 3′s names any time soon. It’s all about ego. You think the cops and district attourneys and judges and all involved on the prosecution side will EVER admit to wrong doing even if they are PROVEN absolutely wrong? No. They will fight to keep the “secret” that they messed up and prosecuted the wrong people. All we can hope for is that this docu will create enough outrage that there will be no choice but to do the right thing….FINALLY.
ego and money with the alfred plea they cannot sue the state for wrongful incarcration
Unfortunately Mike it won’t matter. The state of Arkansas aren’t going to reopen the case. If they did and really found out the truth, the state would have pay those 3 ALOT of money.
@tvcon — unfortunately the west mephis 3 can not sue the state. That is why the state offered them the alford pleas. In fact that was probably the main reason the state was okay with it. Yes, it allowed the wm3 to be released but under the auspices that they are guilty. Consequently, they can’t sue for wrongful prosecution. Sad. But I think Damien had a bunch of medicial issues and that they really need to get him out of prison. My whole thing is that the real killer should be punished. End of story. If they can prove who he is, with forensics and dna evidence, he should spend the rest of his life in prison for killing those boys.
Actually if they reopen the case and the REAL killer gets what he deserves, the Alford plea will no longer stand. The WM3 then will be free to sue the state of Arkansas for wrongful imprisonment. But like I said they won’t reopen the case.
When they took there Alford plea it was on condition that they will never sued the state so you statement is wrong
Yea well, they should give them a lot of money, but no amount will give these three back their youth and everything they missed!!!!!
I eagerly await this documentary. I watched The Hbo Doc–Part Three about these boys last night and it made me sick to my stomach for all involved. And made me feel shame that though I had seen the prior two HBO docs, I had done nothing about it, didn’t even send in a ten dollar donation to them to help them, I just kinda watched the films and went on with my life. Ugh. If ever there was an example of why the death penalty should be completely obliterated, this situation is it. I salute the lawyers, advocates, supporters of the innocent and the exonerated and the documentary filmmakers who made the HBO films. What a contribution to good! Seriously. Films can change lives, and this one clearly has.
ditto
@tvcon
The state of Arkansas will never pay a dime to the WM3. Part of the deal to get out of jail is they are never to sue the state.
They didn’t get a get out of jail free card, their freedom is limited and could go back to prison if new evidence comes up (of course we all know they didn’t do it).
You’re not listening to what I’m saying. If they ever reopen the case (which they won’t) the Alford plea will no longer stand if the REAL killers are prosecuted. Basically they will innocent. Like I said the deal with be voided.
The State of Arkansas MUST be held accountable and must also be forced to consider all of this new and compelling evidence. It’s one thing to say that three possibly innocent men were wrongfully imprisoned for 18 years – it’s even worse to think that there could be a triple-child-murderer who has never been held accountable out walking the streets. It’s a horrendous miscarriage of justice and if the people can’t pressure their own representatives to seek out truth and justice in the interest of the public good, then there isn’t hope for law and order and the system is irrevocably broken. Fiat justitia ruat caelum – Let justice be done though the heavens fall.
So wonderful to see a film speak with such power and artistry. I hope it makes the impact it’s intending.
A testament to filmmaker Joe Berlinger’s original curiosity in this case.
Yeah the state set themselves up nicely. No chance of being sued and they got the alford guilty plea. So to the state the WM3 are guilty and they can’t sue. Hopefully someone has the sack to re-open this case. Hobbs seemed way too evasive in his answers during depositions for the Natalie Maines case.
Its going to take someone like Bill Clinton to become vocal about this case. This whole thing is a blight on the state of Arkansas and he, as one of their sons, has the voice and really the responsibility because of who he is to throw his hat in the ring on this. I hope he does. If not, I hope some way there is justice down for those poor children and their families. It’s depressing this has taken place in our country in his day and age.
I Hope Terry Hobbs gets what is coming to him. Kills 3 little kids and pins it on the outcasts of the town…
While it’s obvious that the guy did it, it’s still just heresay and won’t be admissable even if they re-opened the case which they will never do.
It’s going to take a very brave prosecutor and judge to tackle this case. Only thing that can be done now is to keep embarrassing the state with these documentaries and reports.
hearsay exception 801(d)2): admission by party opponent?
does anyone know how long it will take for the west of memphis documentary will be released? i am anxiou to see this one
Their lawyers should go after the state anyway and just take it to the Supreme Court, in an effort to get that plea deal thrown out because it was signed under duress, and under entirely false circumstances. These boys are victims who were string armed by a state government in order to avoid humiliation. Get the Supreme Court to overthrow this plea, so they’re declared INNOCENT, their records are cleared, and then they can sue. Once the real killer is nailed, all bets are off and the US judicial system should make an example out of the state that acted erroneously, deceptively, and borderline CRIMINALLY in this case.
uh, unbelievable
Powerful documentaries, but, still, they haven’t had the impact that “Metallica: Some Kind of Monster” has, and they never will. Berlinger’s best work.
People should realize that while the State considers the case closed and the WM3 guilty, pressure can still be put on the district attorney to present new evidence to a grand jury which might necessitate a new trail and reopening of the case. The Alford Plea is null and void if the case is reopened and they are exonerated. The WM3 will be free to sue, as they should, for the blatant wrongful persecution and imprisonment they endured for 18 years. I’m not sure how Arkansas officials can sleep at night putting their own careers and reputations in front of doing the right thing. I mean, at least LOOK at the evidence. And it’s compelling – and it is – move the case forward. Even if there was the slightest chance that the real killer was still out there, it would be the only sensible thing to do.
The reticence on the part of the Arkasas legal system to own up to thier culpability in railroading three innocents, in the face of all this overwhelming evidence, will strengthen the case of every single prisoner who makes claims that they were victims of “justice gone mad” in the state. The collective blindness in spite of all the light shed on this case has given my pause to consider every single death row case in Arkansas. This is especially worrisome in the cases of imprisonment of the racial minorities in the state whose cases would not generate as much attention as the WM3. Arkansas still has 3.9 times the number of black people in prison than white. What are the chances that innocent black prisoners are rotting in Arkasas jails without the benifit of a feature length documentary being made about their case or visits from teams of pro bono lawyers and Eddie Vedder?
The scary thing is that there are still people who will argue to the day that they die that the West Memphis Three did it and should have been executed.
Oh please! I’m from Arkansas and my mind has never changed regarding their guilt. This isn’t evidence, it’s a lot of hearsay. This guy said that, and that guy said that guy said this! What is the motive for Hobbs to kill those kids? I’ve not read that mentioned in any article so far. I would love to know.
Maybe you should watch the documentary currently playing on HBO. His motive and lack of alibi is far more compelling evidence than the “those kids are satanists evidence” that convicted those 3 innocent guys.
Exactly. Do people even realize how unusual it is for a person to be killed in a “satanic ritual” let alone for three kids to be killed in one? The vast majority of murders are committed by someone close to one of the victims. The whole theory that the boys were killed in a satanic ritual began from a little kid the same age as the victims who lied about having witnessed the murders and said that Spanish-speaking satanists did it. All of these idiots are following a theory started by a grade school student!
I would ask you what was the motive of the guys wrongly convicted of the crime to murder three children? And if you honestly, with a straight face, can say “satanic ritual” or something equally as moronic, then I’m sorry to have disturbed you. It must be nearly time for your meds and I’m sure there’s a TV screen somewhere you need to be drooling in front of.
Eric, Hobbs had a short fuse and a long criminal record including shooting someone. He is violent. His ex-wife (mother of the boy killed) publicly states he was very abusive and that is why she left him. She also suspected he may have killed the 3 boys. So Hobbs’ motive was rage, a proclivity to become violent, and perhaps he was punishing his step-son and maybe his wife at the time. It is documented and in plenty of articles as well as the Paradise Lost HBO series. You may be from Arkansas, but you really ought to check this out.
In reference to Eric’s comment, I also am from Arkansas and vividly remember when this crime occured. I am ashamed to admit that at first I also thought the wm3 were guilty. Christine J. tells you exactly why Hobbs should be investigated thoroughly as to his involvement. The real killer (and i think it IS Hobbs) should be brought to justice so that those three precious boys can finally rest in peace> Also remember that that the wm3 were boys as well who lost out on their youth and endured unspeakable “punishment” in prison. Shame on the state of Arkansas if this is not resolved for all those involved.
As stated in Paradise Lost 3 Terry Hobbs had a very violent past, including abuse to Pam hobbs and her son. It was also stated that he thought that Pam was cheating on him and vowed to get revenge on her for that wrong. A few days later her son comes up murdered. Seems like more of a motive to me then someone wearing black and listening to metal
At last someone mentions this,of coarse thats a motive,and a very real one that happens a lot with murdered children,get back at the wife.
Terry Hobbs sued the Dixie Chicks when he did that he opened himself up to questioning under oath. He said two weeks before the murders, Pam Hobbs had allegedly cheated on him, his comment was along the lines of “I’m gonna get you back in the worst way possible, I’ll hurt you like you’ve hurt me.” And he has never had a legit alibi….
He admits in the Paradise Lost 3 documentary that he caught Pam kissing another man in their hom just a couple of weeks before the murders happened. And that they fought the whole two weeks prior and that he use to beat Pam. Sounds like probable cause to me. -Revenge on his cheating wife.
Hobbs motive? Have you seen the documentaries? He’s obviously mentally unstable. I was convinced pretty early on that he was the killer (about 99 percent sure). What really sold me on the idea was when he described his feelings at the funeral. He selfishly reverted back to a childhood memory of pain and torture that reeked of guilt. It was eerily out of place and very telling of this guy’s psychological state. There’s also his wife’s mysterious death/suicide… his outlandish, hell-fire theatrical condemantion of the three teenagers, the bite marks and the false teeth (he had his teeth removed after the killings) and that bloody knife.
Robert, you’re referring to Mark Byers. The evidence points to Terry Hobbs.
Which book about the WM3 is the most compelling? I just opinions, no speeches. I’m ANTI-death penalty, no matter what. Most murders happen in the south (“Bible Belt”) and most executions happen in the south. Such a pity, that it cannot be more uniform!
Clara
Clara,
I haven’t read it yet but I hear that the book “Devil’s Knot” by Mara Leveritt is the best book about the murders and the west memphis three. Check that out
Really, most murders are in the south? I mean, really? 1 of the top ten cities for murders is in the south, it is #1, but 2 of the top 10 cities are in MO. That makes most murders in the South?
1.New Orleans – 49
2.St. Louis – 40
3.Baltimore – 34
4.Detroit – 34
5.Newark – 32
6.Oakland – 22
7.Washington DC – 21
8.Kansas City – 21
9.Buffalo – 20
10.Cincinnati – 20
South = 49
Midwest = 115
Your point: null and void, idiot.
The other fact that this case demonstrates is how impossible it is, due to the high cost of defense, for the poor and most likely, the low end of the middle class to get a fair trial. The case has made me sick from the beginning. If this case gets reopened a lot of members of the Hobbs family could be behind bars as accessories after the fact. What kind of people are the Hobbs that they could just sit back and say NOTHING while these three young men had their lives sucked out of them? Are there no federal statutes that would carve the path for justice for the murdered children and the West Memphis Three?
It is so scary when the police (who mostly try to do their best) take the easy way out…mmm… it all points this way so it must be true. It makes you angry for the victim/s, their families, & the poor buggers (& their families) who are accused incorrectly. However, the whole Rodney King thing…. how can you not find them guilty with that overwhelming evidence?! Maybe it’s just me.
I live in AR, and the stepfather has been a whispered suspect from the beginning. This is not news. The cops moved on the WMT because Misskelly, who has an IQ under 75, said they did it after three days of interrogating.
Millions of $$$ made off of three dead children. The true killers are now out and collecting $$$ and attention from gullible supporters. See calahan8k.com for case archives. There you’ll find lots of facts that the killers and the docudrama makers don’t want you to learn.