Diane Haithman is contributing to Deadline’s coverage of TCA.
HBO’s new series Luck is about horse racing, but at today’s TCA panel, the sport in question was prize-fighting — whether reported friction between the strong personalities involved in the show led to ego clashes behind the scenes. The contenders: Stars Dustin Hoffman and Nick Nolte, pilot executive producer/director Michael Mann and pilot executive producer/writer David Milch. All four acknowledged their reputations for being difficult, but insisted that peace reigns on Luck. Concerning rumors of contention on the pilot set, Mann said: “It’s ridiculous.” He explained, “There’s a time when any director wants the set to himself” and said a request to have non-participants step away at one point “got contorted into something else.” After the session, Mann said testily, “We’re not four difficult people. People who are insecure don’t have strong egos. We’re good at what we do, so we don’t have insecurity.”
During the panel, jokes were flying about the “difficult” label. Hoffman goaded a questioner to use a stronger word. “I think you are being diplomatic. Now you can just say ‘a prick.’ We saved the best for last,” Hoffman said. Obligingly, the questioner called Hoffman a prick — and said Nolte also has a reputation for being difficult. Cracked Nolte about Hoffman: “Yes, it’s
difficult to communicate with him when he looks the way he does in mug shots.” On a more serious note, Hoffman repeated Mann’s mantra that four strong personalities can play nice because there’s no weak link. “When you are working with heavyweights, there’s no problem,” he said. “ A director has to be OK with a suggestion. If you suggest something to s director and his face clouds over and all the color drains from his face, I know he’s not a collaborator.”
Speaking for himself, Hoffman said there has also been no conflict in his transition to television. “I have no reason to butter up HBO, the contract is signed, it’s too late to fire me,” he said. “You cannot do your best work in the (movie) studio system. They buck heads with people they shouldn’t buck heads with. At HBO, once they give a go, there is no committee, no meetings.” Hoffman added that he had expected the TV series experience to be “20 pages a day, moviemaking on cocaine” but is finding it to be the opposite. Michael [Mann] hired all film directors. We were given our shot to do our best work.” At about the same time, Nolte went off on a riff about how the TV world is OK provided it doesn’t go 3D. “It disconnects the brain and causes psychotic states,” he said, and no one else on the panel had anything to add.


HBO seems to value these marquee directors more than their creators/showrunners. TV used to be all about the writing. The drop in quality of HBO shows and films is a direct reflection of this.
Drop in quality? HBO is as hands off a system as there is. If you hire quality you’ll get good shows. The networks could stand to pay more attention. FX, USA, Showtime, AMC… they all got the message and the quality of their programs shot up dramatically in the last ten years.
Drop in Quality? Well, I hope they continue on this path. Their “drop in quality” is producing some terrific television.
Onward,HBO!
I have so much respect for actors who have walked away from the studio system. My favorite is Deanna Durbin, the prodigiously talented young beauty who walked away from it at age 28 to become a wife and a mother. She never regreted it, never looked back, never sought nor granted an interview. God bless her. She’s 90 now.
T. B- sending you a cyber-kiss for that spot on insight! To paraphrase Pres Bill C “It’s the writing, stupid”…when it comes to quality TV series–directors help to heighten, but they can’t elevate something that is DOA…
Why don’t you watch the show before you make a judgement.
Absolutely agree. Which is why we get dullfests like Boardwalk Empire. It’s writers like Alan Ball, David Chase, and David Milch who made HBO “Not just TV.” But lately HBO has been playing timid. Do a safe miniseries on John Adams or a movie about Winston Churchill instead of a play like Angels in America. HBO has gone from bleeding edge to PBS Masterpiece Theater.
If you actually think Boardwalk Empire is “dull” then you need to adjust your tastes. The show is engaging, inventive, surprising and entertaining as hell.
Not everything needs to be Jersey Shore you know.
Did Michael Man create and write this show? This TV not a movie. Maybe the pilot was so uninvolving because the writer wasn’t more directly involved.
“People who are insecure don’t have strong egos. We’re good at what we do, so we don’t have insecurity.”
What?
Amen.
Is HBO going to make any shows for adult women? This and Boardwalk Empire aren’t gonna to do it. Watching the pilot of Girls gave me a stomach ache. What’s in the water over there?
Try the broadcast networks, Jelly Roll, women have pretty much taken over. Especially ABC and NBC.
Um, well… as an adult woman, I like watching men, so… B-EMPIRE and Luck are testosterone-loaded so that’s fine by me… however, if we are looking for inspiration, who better than Gretchen Moll, Paz Vega in B-Empire and Kerry Condon… I read Joan Allen will be in LUCK – what’s in your water?
Macho nailed it Jelly Roll. There’s four entire networks (and two on cable) devoted totally and entirely to female-oriented fare. That is unless you’re going to tell us that The Good Wife, 2 Broke Girls, Desperate Housewives, Cougartown and half the slate at PBS somehow slipped your notice.
What’s in the water? I believe Kate Winslet’s in the water. Aside from that it’d be really nice to not make shows a gender issue. P’s & V’s love the same HBO programs for the same reason: they’re top notch… Me? I’ll avidly watch anything that’s intelligent and interesting.
Does that mean you watched both Sex and the City and Sopranos?
Face it, we all got in the business to watch titans like these work. How exciting to see them create, and tangle. Should be great. I’m in.
A few years back HBO optioned a novel I wrote to develop into a series. I wrote a pilot script… ultimately, we didn’t get a green light but the experience was by far the best one I have ever had in the business… supportive and creative. HBO is thee place to work in the business.
Saw that Luck has a big ad on the Luxor in Vegas. Too bad it’s up there illegally… they will need luck on their side not to get slapped with a big fine!