Ray Richmond is contributing to Deadline’s coverage of TCA.
After the TCA session, I asked MSNBC president Phil Griffin to clarify the status of MSNBC pundit Pat Buchanan, who has been off the network since October 22nd while making the rounds promoting his controversial new book Suicide Of A Superpower: Will America Survive to 2025? The book has been criticized by numerous groups including the Anti-Defamation League for its purportedly racist and anti-Semitic views. Griffin told me after the panel, “I don’t think the ideas that [Buchanan] put forth [in the book] are appropriate for the national dialogue, much less on MSNBC.” Will Buchanan be back at all on MSNBC? “I have not made my decision,” replied Griffin, who did say he will be tinkering with the network’s format as the year goes on. “Pat’s a good guy. He didn’t like [being removed from the air], but he understood.”
On the subject of MSNBC’s 2012 election coverage, Griffin noted after the session that he had expected Fox News’ victory the night of the Iowa Caucus to be far bigger than it was. “It’s just interesting,” he said. “Nobody blew it out. I think it speaks to the country’s reaction to politics today. Given that this was such as Republican event, I thought Fox would just dominate.” (Fox News drew 2.6 million viewers in primetime vs. 1.3 million for CNN and 1.2 million for MSNBC.)
The morning’s subject was MSNBC’s well-rated Morning Joe early AM show anchored by Scarborough and co-hosts Mika Brzezinski and Willie Geist. It was widely reported during the summer that CBS made a big play to get Scarborough and his team. After briefly joking “there’s no truth to it,” Scarborough confirmed that he “hears from all of the different networks that they want us to go work for them and do a show for them. … But we have an opportunity to talk to people that you just can’t on other networks.” He also said he’s proud to be associated with a show where “people know they can come on and not be browbeaten and humiliated. … Part of the problem with this presidential field is you have a lot of candidates who realize that the only way they can make a connection with voters is to go on cable shows and call their opponents socialists or fascists or marxists.” On that note, he added that he agrees with others who have called the current Republican presidential hopefuls the worst collection of GOP contenders in history.


Michael Steele does a great articulating the GOP POV. Maybe pair him up with Ezra Klein to do a Crossfir type of show?
I totally agree with MSNBC starting a crossfire type of show.
Yes’s a Crossfire idea is great! What we really need on TV is more people just yelling at each other.
BUCHANAN BAD, SHARPTON GOOD! Imbeciles.
I agree about Michael Steele. He has really grown into his role as an “analyst” and gets the GOP point across without coming across as absolutely partisan.
Great Idea!!!! Perhaps someone could bring back The Capital Gang as well. I miss good debate with intelligent Washington insiders. Now we get beige porridge and hot air roundtables where “both sides are equally at fault” is replayed every week.
Has there ever been collection of presidential hopefuls, republican or democrat that wasn’t the worst ever? Name one pool of candidates in the last 50 years. I mean they are politicians…those truly qualified would never raise their hands.
Buchanan needs to go to FOX. MSNBC is a left only channel. They don’t like to have opposing views featured. Just let Pat go and find a home where he’ll be appreciated.
Morning Joe is a 3-hour program in which the most prominent viewpoint is that of Joe Scarborough, a conservative former congressman.
People act like MSNBC and Fox are mirror images, and its not true. MSNBC evening programming leans left, but its morning programming leans right. It’d be like if Fox hires Alan Grayson and gives him 3 hours in the morning to host “AM Alan.”
Yeah, MSNBC only has pinko commies like that Republican ex-congressman Scarborough who has three hours every morning.
I bust up laughing everytime I see some moron say “Pinko Commies”? Guess these ignorant people don’t realize the “Commies” left are in China, Cuba, North Korea, that’s it, get your facts straight and do some reading and research, you may? learn something.
Lighten up; it’s a figure of speech, left over from the 50s and 60s, generally used by liberals in a joking manner to refer to themselves.
Fox News probably will not hire Buchanan. Fox News is GOP run and the GOP hates Buchanan for his running as an independent in 2000.
Also…Fox News is quite liberal when it comes to issues like Free Trade and Globalism (no different than CNN/MSNBC) and Buchanan is one of the loudest voices against those issues.
In fact, I doubt if it is the alleged “anti-Semitism” that is having Buchanan removed at MSNBC (most Dems/Liberals actually support many of his anti-Israel positions). It is Buchanan’s opposition to Free Trade, WTO, Globalism, that is getting him removed.
As if any network that would keep such a hateful, hurtful, vitriol-spewing dirtbag like Ed Schultz on the air has room to talk. What, now they are suddenly aware of the fact they’ve been staffing their offices with creeps of the worst sort? Yeesh.
Someone call Jon Stewart, so he can remove that kind of trash from the air (again).
Michael Steele? Are you insane, or a liberal. Steele backs down too easily to the slurs of the hateful left. That’s why he was fired by the GOP, thank God!
completely disagree. he has gotten much stronger in his commentary since his disastrous debut on HARDBALL. and i would take Steele any day over that blowhard Keith Olberman.
Wait a minute no one went hard on Michael Steele like the Republicans. They complained about him every day despite him raising the most money for the party in decades and assisting with the elections of those tea party candidates to the House.
They used him and when they were finished bye bye,
No to Pat, but yes to every progressive lefty on Huffpost. Even Morning Joe is a joke. A watered down conservative who when not hosting his own show, has it totally taken over by liberals.
…”controversial new book Suicide Of A Superpower: Will America Survive to 2025? The book has been criticized by numerous groups including the Anti-Defamation League for its purportedly racist and anti-Semitic views. Griffin told me after the panel, “I don’t think the ideas that [Buchanan] put forth [in the book] are appropriate for the national dialogue, much less on MSNBC.” Will Buchanan be back at all on MSNBC? “I have not made my decision,” replied Griffin, who did say he will be tinkering with the network’s format as the year goes on. “Pat’s a good guy. He didn’t like [being removed from the air], but he understood.”
Now isn’t that just like America?
The “ideas’ put forth in Buchanan’s book aren’t appropriate…but Buchanan’s a “good guy”?
Wow…where have I been all this time?
Guess if the ratings were really high…and tons of money was consistently pouring in, whenever Buchanan’s on the air…and being that good guy; then there might not be a thought of dismissing him.
So, it is, really about the profit margin. The bottom line. Regardless of what is done or said.
This is the same Buchanan who worked and profited in and after supporting the President Nixon administration? Too bad about that Watergate screwup. Guess if Buchanan had gotten those hotel reservations done correctly and ahead of time, their Cuban guests wouldn’t have made that big of a stink.
I’m as Lib as they come, but I dig Uncle Pat. Curious as to what his book is about now.
All you white guys in America need to ban together and tell guys like Buchanan to STFU.
The whole world’s watching, waiting with bated breath – veering between abject terror and side-splitting laughter – hoping like hell we get it together before ignorance and rank stupidity become American exports.
Look for Buchanan’s name in the history chapter analyzing why anyone with two brain cells EVER took the extinct, ignorant, Southern, white American male seriously. It will conclude with the suggestion that had we stuck their socks in their mouths and confined them (indefinitely) to underground detention camps every time one of them started spewing their anti-intellectual, evolution-and-climate-change-denying crappola, the whole planet would have been much better off.
Men like Buchanan (and Gingrich, W – oh shoot, the list is simply inexhaustible) put in serious jeopardy mankind’s claim to the label “intelligent life.”
To the rest of the civilized world, news of the dwindling majority of whites in America is beginning to look – as Martha would say – like one hell of a very “good thing.”
Wow – you want to put people in “underground detention camps” because of their color and ideas?
No hate like liberal hate. As usual. Unhinged and pro-censorship.
@ Reality: Too bad you’re too ignorant to realize the truth. It’s why the GOP & its supremacist Koch funded oligarchy is careening towards obsolescence.
msnbc only hired pat buchanan to try and belittle him and give him as little time as possible to express his conservative views and when he had his say he made more sense than anybody else thats why liberals hate him now the head of msnbc doesnt want to let him go so that fox wont give him more air time and inform the public how intolerent and bigoted the left really is!
You write that “Morning Joe” is well-rated? Have you seen his ratings (they stink) or is that what they told you? MSNBC is where the truth went to die.
I agree. More partisan bickering is just what America needs to bring the people together. Smh.
It’s great to see that people like Phil Griffin are the ones who get to decide for 300 million people what is “appropriate for the national dialogue.” Not a comment about Buchanan’s ideology or it’s “appropriateness,” nor about the political leanings of any one channel or another.
The MSM can’t die fast enough.
“Pat’s a good guy” Really? Since when.? He is a bigoted, bloated, blowhard. Not my definition of “a good guy.” Bye Pat.
Good. About time MSNBC. Buchanan’s misogynistic, bigoted views are very dated and lack any vision of the future.
Pat softened his stances a bit for MSNBC, but he represents the old guard, that of middle aged whites, who think that through the virtue of the skin color you were born with in this country, you should still enjoy all that affords you. He referred to President Obama as a boy on Al Sharpton’s horror of a show, and when given the opportunity, espouses his racial bigotry through the guise of intellect differences. Plus I hate that f**cking combover, go away!!
Pat Buchanan will end up on Fox News where he belongs, and where people will actually see him.
Unlike the 12 liberals that watch MSNBC.
It’s always a hoot to laugh at pro-censorship liberals, though. Talk about backwards people.
@Reality Objecting to offensive and/or racist comments is not censorship. Neither is absolutist thinking.
I appreciate that you’re trolling but shouldn’t you be out looking for someone who advocates true conservative beliefs? Unless you conservatives really are all hypocritical, reactionary bigots that is.
Would anybody like to pal around with any of the conservaiive pres front runners. What kind of fun do any of them enjoy?Is everyone in the 1% as unfun as they are?