Sen Ron Wyden (D-Ore.) and Rep. Darell Issa (R-Cal.) were preaching to the choir today when they vowed at the 2012 International CES that they’ll try to blunt the Hollywood supported effort to give the government the power to block websites that traffic in pirated content. “Our hope is we can slow down this effort to pass two ill-advised pieces of legislation” Wyden said referring to the House’s Stop Online Piracy Act and a similar bill in the Senate called the Protect IP Act. Consumer electronics and tech companies have opposed the bills, saying that they could be used to block legitimate Web sites and stifle free speech. Issa added that “we’re up against people who have a history of resisting technological innovation.” He says that at a January 18 hearing he’ll bang the drum for his Online Enforcement and Protection of Digital Trade Act (OPEN) which gives the International Trade Commission more authority to regulate piracy allegations. ”You’re going to hear venture capitalists talk about the real impact (on Internet investment) if Congress gets something wrong,” Issa said. Speaking of Hollywood he said that “if there were no SOPA they’d embrace this (OPEN) as a great idea.” He added that SOPA is “too flawed to be fixed.”

Does anyone realize that the ITC is slow to act (18 months), requires you to travel to and commmit time in Washington, DC, is way too expensive because you have to lawyer up with specialized international trade lawyers (and this is really a problem for small content owners and individuals), and actually (under OPEN) has fewer remedies than available under current law? It doesn’t and won’t work! Oh, wait, perhaps that’s the intent.
He’s right. SOPA and PIPA have honorable goals but will do an incredible amount of damage to the fastest growing avenue of entertainment distribution. Obviously all of us content creators need to continue to find a way to curb piracy, but it cannot be at the expense of online freedom.
Dear Nuge,
They’re thieves – stealing a book from the library or illegally downloading – you’re a thief.
I hope someone steals from their parents someday and they’ll see how it feels.
They’re the ‘I Don’t Give a Crap’ Generation – sad.
Hey, here’s a thought. Why don’t you actually read the full bills proposed? If you believe in these types of things you need to take your ass to a different country or form a new country with your own GOD DAMN BILL OF RIGHTS. We DO NOT support anything that violates the Bill Of Rights here!!! We DO NOT support Fascism here!!!! People like you give me little hope for the future generations of this country!
OPEN is a joke b/c the ITC’s participation dooms it. What a horrible idea. Take legitimate enforcement and hand it over to an indifferent international body, rather than entrust basic law enforcement to the Department of Justice.
Issa insults everyone that works in the entertainment business with this b.s.
If you’d like to see the internet become Cable TV, allow this to pass. I can hardly wait till most fan sites for entertainment, electronics, etc are taken down because the owners of the IP don’t like the discussions held…not for piracy or content theft.
Anyone who has left the USA knows that copyrights don’t get much past the border. Go to any street bazaar in Mexico, etc and every program or bit of software is available for $5.
The possible political implications of this legislation are far worse than any theft of IP.
Ha I see Lamar Smith, the author of the SOPA bill himself is a copyright violator, per a number of websites today. Under SOPA, he would be silenced and his site taken down.
Sopa is not written to protect ip – sopa gives the justice dept free rein to shut down the Internet if someone claims there’s a copyright violation. No court hearings, no judges, no jury, no due process – u really think that’s the best solution. That be like a store claiming something is missing so lets seal off ten city blocks and chop off the hands of anyone inside the cordoned area … Anyone for sopa or protect ip might as well move to Belarus with their we law that u mst keep track of every website u visit.
I can’t believe I’m saying this about congressmen, but GOOD ON THEM! It’s nice to see somebody realizing that the right to privacy is equally important to the right of property. Idiot legislation like this opens the door to 1984-style crap.
And for what? I work in this industry, and much as I’d like to cover my eyes and shut my ears, I accept that p2p sharing is a genie that can’t be put back in the bottle. Lawsuits and legislation are an expensive waste of time. Maybe if the powers-that-be had focused a little less on hanging on to a disappearing economy and a little more on cracking the new one, this discussion would be irrelevant by now.