Here’s one reason why the MPAA and other lobbyists may have felt blindsided last week by the outpouring of protests against the Hollywood supported anti-piracy bills: Young people cared about the subject far, far more than the rest of the population did, according to a weekly measurement by the Pew Research Center for the People & the Press. The researchers found that 23% of people between ages 18 and 29 tracked the news about the debate over the Senate’s Protect IP Act and the House’s Stop Online Piracy Act more than any other story — making it No. 1 for the week for this group. By contrast, just 7% of all adults considered the dispute, which resulted in Wikipedia going dark for a day, to be the week’s biggest news. For them it ranked behind the Italian cruise ship accident, the elections, and the economy.A mere 6% of people between 30 and 49 considered anti-piracy to be the lead story, falling to 2% among people between 50 and 64, and 1% of those 65 and older. Stepping back to look at who followed anti-piracy very closely — as opposed to most closely — Pew found that 20% of Democrats and 19% of independents did so, but only 11% of Republicans were as interested. The bills were shelved last week as lawmakers responded to a flood of protests. Entertainment companies wanted to give the government the power to block overseas sites that traffic in pirated content, saying it would save U.S. jobs. But tech companies and other who objected said the proposals were too broad and could stifle free speech and dampen investment in the Internet.


Just a theory: the bill was overreaching & threatened our browsing & access to the Internet. It’s not that young people want piracy. They just don’t want the lawmakers blocking websites.
You’re right in general. But there is a large percentage of young people that do think they are entitled to pirate things. It’s the generation.
Yep.
“Gimme gimme gimme, need some more. Gimme gimme gimme, don’t ask what for.”
— Black Flag
That song (while great) came out in 1981 and is probably as relevant to Generation Download as Bill Haley & His Comets. But sure, it’s the generation.
It still applies today.
There is a lot of internet activity and organizing going on right now to punish Lamar Smith and Chris Dodd. One is a petition to the White House to investigate bribery charges between MPAA and Congress. The other is to form internet groups to call voters in their districts and inform them of their activities to limit free speech and support even more federal regulation in tech businesses.
These guys have kicked up a sh*t storm. And it is only growing everyday.
Most of the bills that pass through congress are nebulous – it’s hard to see how important they might be until it’s too late. With SOPA and PIPA, it was clear that these bills would immediately impact the one thing you do NOT want to mess with if you want young people on your side – the internet.
As someone who grew up on the net, it is how I interact with the world. It’s hard for many in the 50+ crowd – those who usually get riled up over political issues – to understand just how essential it is to the lives of the young. It would be like trying to censor food, water, air, or verbal communication.
Please don’t make the mistake of thinking that the Internet is essential only to the young. There are many of us who have been online for over twenty years.
You’re absolutely right though that it’s as essential as “food, water, air, or verbal communication.” When my DSL was down, Verizon said it would be two days before service was restored. I said, “That’s like saying to someone it’ll be two days before we can fix your pacemaker.”
Young people just have this entitlement that they should be given whatever they want and don’t really understand the wide-reaching effects of piracy. These are the same people that will be graduating from college and whining that there are no jobs out there for them.
Yeah, there’s no jobs because YOUR generation screwed up! So sick of boomer arrogance.
Age-ist @sshole, I hope you live long enough to reap the rewards of your idiocy.
Yeah, okay. I’m ageist. But Darnell can blast an entire age group for complaining about the job market – a problem that wasn’t even caused by them? Think about that before you toss around words like ‘idiocy’.
Well no offense, but isn’t the generation that raised them partly to blame?
SaveTheInternet.com and FreePress.net are also active watchdogs in this fight, along with the EFF.
I sometimes wonder if there are any folks who pushed for media consolidation 10-15 years ago who are now wishing they’d thought things through a little better.
Most people are against piracy, it’s been shown time and again that when you make something available, price it fairly, and make it simple to acquire, most people will legally purchase that song or that movie or that TV show.
It’s when something’s not available, for whatever variety of reasons, some people will say “Hey, they won’t sell it to me, so why not grab that copy off of Bit Torrent or Pirate Bay?” Which makes the Disney “limited release” game with older animated features, and now whatever WB is doing with the Harry Potter movies a complete mind boggle to me.
There’s a mindset I’ve come across that thinks it’s okay to grab a bootleg copy if the legit version doesn’t exist. In my youth I played fast and loose with that logic, but I always bought the legit copy of something I had the bootleg of once it was finally available (remember the old days when older TV shows weren’t considered as profitable enough to be released on DVD unless they were already in syndication?)
I don’t do that at all anymore, but right now, I know personally I’d be hard-pressed NOT grab a copy of Sinbad’s “Brain Damaged” HBO special or Melissa Etheridge’s MTV Unplugged concert featuring her duet with Bruce Springsteen, if I saw bootleg versions. The fact that they are as old as they are means that bootlegs don’t exist.
I’ve been waiting 15-20 years for those to be available to be purchased, writing letters to MTV and Melissa’s publicity people every year for 5 years at one point, but that one concert has never been on DVD, and neither has the Sinbad show. I’d buy both of them in a heartbeat, happily.
So I understand both sides, but it seems like neither side really wants to sit down and talk about better ways to approach the real problem (like, how do those folks get their hands on pristine digital copies before the movies are in theaters in the first place). It won’t be a simple process nor will it be a simple one-step solution, but playing whack-a-mole with domains because you can is not the way to go about it.
Isn’t this the demographic that seems to be going to the movies less and less? Why should they as long as they can steal the same property?
Please– the supposed concern for free speech is really just a smoke screen for protecting theft. Why is this any different than burglary or car jacking? Because it happens to occur on the internet? Why is that somehow sacred domain?
Or could it be that they’re going less and less because movies are getting worse and worse and more and more expensive?
(The same reason a lot of demographics are getting fed up.)
The audience basically has two choices:
1. Spend too much time in traffic. Pay too much to park. Stand for too long in line. Pay too much for concessions. Pay too much for movie that may or may not suck.
2. Stay home. If broke, torrent movie. If not broke, wait until someone finally decides to make movie available through streaming or DVD. Get impatient with system geared towards distributors, not customers. Torrent movie.
Yes, if I were part of NATO, I’d be very, very afraid.
I researched this for a paper I wrote on the subject and was most surprised that some of the sharing has nothing to do with overseas companies trying to make bank off other people’s creative work. It is in many cases fans sharing with other fans.
Hollywood seems most upset about other’s making money off their stuff which I get. But Hollywood also is unwilling, mostly cause they don’t want to bow to the unions, to admit that the web is the future of “programing”. If they would stop stalling and accept that and embrace the world market place instead of trying to squeeze every last dime and nickel they would find a youth market willing to play ball as they have with iTunes and their .99 song structure.
Their first mistake was not setting up a single network wide ‘subscription base’ on something like iTunes or the like. Paying $1.99 or more for a single episode of TV that most people can tivo for ‘free’ seems expensive. Note I put free in quotes because in fact people do pay a subscription to Tivo but you don’t feel it as a one off or monthly payment structure.
Region locking materials is another issue in a Global market place. People in the UK want to chat with people in the US about the latest episode of say Glee. This is why the folks at BBC and BBCA got smart and started releasing Doctor Who’s at the same time. Instead of selling and squeezing tons of money for overseas license set-up a subscription fee from a global market to begin with.
Stop waiting an entire week to upload materials on sites like Hulu for ‘free but commercial attached viewing’ as they are losing the momentum from the folks that want to see when everyone gets it.
Youth want to be able to watch where and when they want — because it’s the environment they have been raised into. They want to be able to talk to friends on viral landscapes like Facebook, Twitter, and Tumblr about those shows AS THE SHOWS AIR! And with contract debates in some local markets with companies like Direct TV the only option is alternative web sharing.
It’s also interesting to note that some shows especially those from overseas distributers have actually found themselves with a US audience through viral means that have led to US pick-ups of those series. The new Syfy Channel show Lost Girl is a perfect example of this.
Maybe they were blindsided because they’re just blind. Hollywood thought just because they spent lots of money to buy politicians, everyone would roll over and do their bidding. It was amazing to see how many and how fast polictical hacks posing as congressmen and senators backpedaled on this issue once the fire against it started.
If I make a digital copy of a Vinyl album that I own (yes…I go back that far) for my own amusement or for my iPod, I am allowed to do this. If I download the same thing from a website, I’m breaking the law. I own the original Led Zeppelin on vinyl, on cassette, on CD. Now the same company would like to sell it to me once again as an MP3…I’m sorry, that won’t happen. The consolidation of giant media companies into giant wannabe power brokers has very little to do with piracy…it’s about control. They would like to go back to the days where distribution was king and you needed them to get your record out or your movie distributed. This is why the Internet scares them so much…it makes them irrelevant. The assumption that everyone who illegally downloads something would be a paying customer is not at all accurate. The people who have the vision to understand that if you don’t rip people off, they will support you as an artist…they are the people who will succeed in the future. It’s time for the giant media companies to make like the dinosaurs that they are, and lie down and become petroleum deposits. For me, it can’t happen too soon.
I don’t think a lot of this is about younger people feeling “entitled” to pirate anything. In general, everything I”ve heard is people reacting to Seems like the general reaction has been to avoid a Skynet or Big Brother type situation.
As someone who is not of the Generation Y, or X, or whatever they call it today, I applaud those who stepped up to stop SOPA and PIPA
Those bills were nothing more than a ruse to shut down the Internet. Staement of Fact
RIAA and MPAA were never really honestly serious about stopping piracy and intellectual theft. Before internet became huge, films and music had been pirated by the Communist Chinese and others around the world. Of course, the only real way to stop the Communist Chinese thievery was to slap huge tariffs on the Comm. Chinese…but the entertainment industry (and their friends in both the GOP and DNC) wanted to push the failed theory of “Free Trade” instead of protecting their product.
And, in this day of high-tech…the entertainment industry still loses billions of $$ per year on piracy from Communist Chinese and other non-first world nations….and still is a bigger cost than your young child sharing a file with his friend.
But, lets shut down the internet.
The ways of distribution for the major studios and ebtertainment companies is over. No amount of political contributions/bribes will save them from the reality
The only thing Chris Dodd should be doing, is appearing before a special prosecutor, along with the rest of the congressional committee, and the heads of Fannie May, and Freddie Mac.