Looks like Wednesday’s massive Internet protest against the Hollywood-supported anti-piracy legislation worked. Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid said this morning that “in light of recent events” he’s calling off the planned Tuesday vote for the Protect IP Act — which would give government officials the power to block overseas sites that traffic in pirated content. Shortly afterward, House Judiciary Committee Chairman Lamar Smith said he will ”postpone consideration” of a similar bill — the Stop Online Piracy Act – “until there is wider agreement on a solution.” Both lawmakers claim the issue isn’t dead: Reid says that he’s “optimistic that we can reach a compromise in the coming weeks.” New York Sen. Chuck Schumer tweets: “You’ve been heard. [The Protect IP Act] has been pulled so we can find a better solution.” But the general feeling is that supporters of the legislation will have a hard time getting the bills back on track — and certainly not with the enforcement muscle that Hollywood wants. Here’s Reid’s statement:
“In light of recent events, I have decided to postpone Tuesday’s vote on the PROTECT I.P. Act.
“There is no reason that the legitimate issues raised by many about this bill cannot be resolved. Counterfeiting and piracy cost the American economy billions of dollars and thousands of jobs each year, with the movie industry alone supporting over 2.2 million jobs. We must take action to stop these illegal practices. We live in a country where people rightfully expect to be fairly compensated for a day’s work, whether that person is a miner in the high desert of Nevada, an independent band in New York City, or a union worker on the back lots of a California movie studio.
“I admire the work that Chairman Leahy has put into this bill. I encourage him to continue engaging with all stakeholders to forge a balance between protecting Americans’ intellectual property, and maintaining openness and innovation on the internet. We made good progress through the discussions we’ve held in recent days, and I am optimistic that we can reach a compromise in the coming weeks.”


They may have lost the battle, but they’re ready for the war. They didn’t pay lobbyists millions, donate millions to Congress/Senate/Obama, and bring on that weasel Chris Dodd for nothing. Ironically its now the Republicans who are standing in their way.
How will this probably be resolved? They’ll sneak the heart of the bill into some vital piece of legislation at the last minute, and force the hand of those who couldn’t possibly vote against whatever main legislation the amendment is attached to. Such are the ways of DC.
Agreed, that’s probably exactly what they will do. There is no way they are going to try this outright as they’ve done. They will sneak this in anyway they can.
How much political capital can Chris Dodd still have?
Between Zero and None.
The lines have been drawn, and Hollywood and its leader Chris Dodd are on the wrong side because of their greed for money and power.
Any future legislation will be under a GLOBAL microscope in an election year.
DOA for now.
For a site that prides itself in not being a studio mouthpiece you sure like to mince words on this. The bill isn’t about foreign sites, it gives this government the power to block any site at the very root level, a power that can be used without trial against all kinds of sites, even ones with drops of copyright infringement in a sea of original content like YouTube or Vimeo.
Educating the public didn’t work. Prevention technology hasn’t worked – use international pressure instead of punishing the majority of people who do enjoy watching their content in a legal venue like Netflix, Hulu or broadcaster sites
THE PEOPLE HAVE SPOKEN!
Here is the problem: both smaller bloggers, writers and visual artists want to protect their property from illegal usage and large studios and music production companies want the same thing.
A small press or self published writer, or a photographer or musician, wants to be protected against some file sharing service from publishing their work in entirety. A corporate entity wants to be protected against piracy.
And what Congress wants is to open the door to control the internet, shut down the small blog or review site and control individual web sites. What a quandry.
As usual so much hate for the Hollywood camp, even on industry websites…
There was so much public uproar against PIPA that senators just felt wrong supporting it.
Now with the Megaupload crackdown, senators will hesitate rejecting any similar bill outright, it will look like they support Kim Dotcom and stealing American jobs.
A compromise is definitely possible.
The crackdown on Megaupload only proves that SOPA and PIPA are not needed to catch the pirates. This legislation is BS.
The people want to buy Hollywood’s product, but they need it to be cheap and easy.
The MPAA are fools to buy off congress and create laws to create censorship. When you give congress a chance to trample on our rights they will take it.
The MPAA should encourage the development of global bullet proof paid video on demand solutions.
Remember the days we read about in history class when the people actually had a hand in governing the country? It seems the internet may be bringing that back.
Indeed! I typically dislike hyperbole, but the internet may be the most important platform for accelerating freedom of speech and sparking intellectual curiosity since the printing press. It pisses me off that Congress would even consider squelching that.
As for the entertainment industry, I applaud companies that are moving fast to adapt their business models to the ever-changing internet. Shame on those companies who choose to be dinosaurs and seek a legislative remedy instead of change. That is lazy, and it is bad for America.
Yay, the thieves win! We should all be so proud! When the movie industry is finally totaled like the music industry is, you will finally get what you want. Nothing to see except garbage in 3D. It will be the only reason anyone will go to the theater anymore.
After the DOJ’s takedown of Megaupload (without a trial, and with no due process btw), why exactly do they need another new law like SOPA? They don’t. They proved the people’s point.
LONG LIVE THE “FREE” INTERNET!!!!!!!!!
Harry Reid has a lot of nerve telling us this fight aint over. After the ENTIRE nation went into uproar over this government censorship bill, he is still siding with the corporations that bought him off and planning to sneak it through a back door like Ken is predicting. You guys in Nevada, do us a favor: stop sending Reid to congress!