
By the beginning of February last year, the broadcast networks had renewed nine scripted series: ABC’s Modern Family, Grey’s Anatomy, Private Practice, Castle, The Middle and Cougar Town, CBS’ The Big Bang Theory (three-year pickup) and NCIS and Fox’s Raising Hope. A month later, the number climbed to 10 with a two-year deal for CBS’ How I Met Your Mother. We’re at the end of February now, and the networks are yet to pick up a single existing scripted series for next season. That is a very unusual pattern as the broadcast networks normally like to reward their top performers with early renewals.
There is no doubt that shows like ABC’s Modern Family and Once Upon A Time, CBS’ 2 Broke Girls and NCIS or Fox’s New Girl will be back next season. And yet, two-and-a-half months before the upfronts, there is not a single scripted series except for those under multi-year deals (Big Bang, How I Met Your Mother, The Simpsons) to have their places on the schedule for next season already secured. The dry spell may finally be broken soon as Fox is nearing a decision on freshman Terra Nova, whose chances for renewal have increased over the past few weeks. As for the biggies, some of the pickups are clouded by uncertainty surrounding the cast, including Grey’s Anatomy (leads Ellen Pompeo and Patrick Dempsey), Two And A Half Men (Ashton Kutcher), and NBC’s The Office (Ed Helms, John Krasinksi). Still, it feels like the networks are just taking their sweet old time making renewals this year. They don’t have to pick up any shows until May, and it’s always easier making decisions after they have seen their pilots. The early orders were done mostly to please studios and showrunners, but they also created problems as the auspices of solid shows that didn’t get the early vote of confidence felt left out. So it’s “no early renewals, no problems” this year.
TV Editor Nellie Andreeva - tip her here.


I think NBC really is weighing pros and cons for shows like ‘Smash’ (which is on a decline), ‘The Firm’ (moved to Saturdays), ‘Harry’s Law’, ‘Are You There Chelsea?’ and ‘Whitney’ – 3 of those 5 will be canceled, if not all 5.
Shows, ‘The Office’, ‘Law & Order: SVU’, ‘The Biggest Loser’, ‘Parenthood’, and ‘Grimm’ have great chance of renewal, they pull higher 18-49 demos than the show’s above. Supposedly, ‘Law & Order: Criminal Intent’ might make a return to NBC for the 2012-2013 TV season we’ll see, Bob Greenblatt said at the TCA he wanted more from the ‘Law & Order’ franchise, it wouldn’t be a bad idea if ‘Law & Order: CI’ was revived, NBC needs all the help it can get.
CBS: We already know ‘NCIS’, ‘Blue Bloods’, ‘Criminal Minds’, and ‘The Mentalist’ are a lock for renewal. ‘A Gifted Man’ is canceled, CBS is going to pick between ‘CSI: Miami’ and ‘CSI: NY’ to renew and cancel the other/order final season, ‘Unforgettable’ likely won’t return.
UNFORGETTABLE is a solid #1 in its time slot.
A New York-based cop show has always done well Tuesdays at 10 pm, going back for decades with NYPD BLUE.
Unforgettable may win its timeslot often, but that doesn’t mean it’s performing well. It’s routinely well below CBS’s other dramas, especially the 10:00pm ones. Last week, for example, The Mentalist had a 2.6, CSI had a 2.9, Hawaii Five-O had a 2.9, and Unforgettable had a 2.0. It only rated higher than the Friday night dramas last week… they could do much better than Unforgettable.
Agreed. “Shark” ran into this problem a few years back – it won its time slot but underperformed compared to other CBS shows. So even though it was consistently top 30-40 it still got canceled.
Are you SERIOUSLY comparing the brilliant NYPD Blue to the garbage that is Unforgettable??? Jeez!!!!
I agree. Had high hopes for “Unforgettable,” but it’s just dreadful….trite and predictable, the worst writing this side of “The Firm.” Poor Poppy. She’s great and deserves a whole lot better than this dreck,
They need new writers. Poppy is great.
If you call aknowledging that they’re both cop shows set in NY to be comparing them….
Otherwise, it looked like a simple statement of fact regarding the premise….
CBS sold Miami to AMC and they said that they’ll do at least two more seasons along with reruns.
I looked for CSI miami last week. I hope to see it somewhere.
Biggest task is going to rest at NBC as they probably want to get rid of all the previous regime’s drivel they call shows like you mentioned above and start cementing their fingerprints with shows under the new regime. NBC desperately needs a solid fall season or there is going to be another major shakeup at this network. The CW seriously has to get their act together as well for next season.
Whatever help NBC needs is not more Law and Order — period.
That said, I agree with you on canceling those other 5. I suppose Smash might get picked up… But not if something doesn’t happen to reverse its rapid descent.
There are only a handful of “solid” performers.
Even MODERN FAMILY is not a consistent time slot winner, against reality programming.
Networks want to fall in love with more pilots, yet that system is clearly broken when more midseason shows survive than September launches.
The fence-sitting is troublesome, but if you’re a showrunner, that’s what TUMS are for.
You are right that they seem to be taking their sweet time renewing certain shows-as compared to last year. I think Modern Family is a wonderful,smart series-which of course is coming back. The problem is for the other solid shows we like,but,have not been renewed yet. IMO: We all know the majority of the solid shows such as Castle will be back,but,these networks seem to love having us-the fans-squirm. It seems they love having us on a leash! In some ways Nellie(based on the track record of network treatment of its’ fans) I’m truly not surprised. These are the same group who year after year:air a new episode of our shows,then a repeat ,then a new episode,then a repeat-they also are killing many of our favorite programs with what seems to be their favorite word:FINALES-as in: fall finales,winter finales,midseason finales,-IF THERE IS A HIATUS TO BE FOUND-THESE NETWORKS WILL FIND IT! Nellie,my main point being: I’m not surprised at all:typical network behavior( as of late). Memo to networks:”We’re the fans”! Just tell us if our favorite program is coming back!?Will ya!? Thank you.
It makes it a little harder for the casts of bubble shows to go take pilots in “second position”, but maybe this will open up the idea of casting new faces. Of course, it would be really nice if the “new faces” came from the U.S. – but I won’t get up on my soapbox.
Curious to see what will happen to SMASH if its numbers continue to plummet. It’s super-expensive and u have to wonder if they just pull the plug and turn the page or keep trying to do something to justify all the money and hype behind it. My guess is the latter, but if they don’t get a bump in the next few episodes it’d be smarter to kill it off and look for a hit elsewhere.
Yeah, Smash is a big old question mark. It’s critically acclaimed, so they could renew to 1) save face and 2) hope for awards recognition. But the ratings likely won’t justify a renewal, regardless of how good the show is, based on its declining trend.
I’d sure like to meet the critic that acclaimed this piece of tripe.
Agreed re SMASH. NBC doesn’t have any really solid performers at 10 PM, so I’d look for them to try and trim the budget, but it needs higher ratings. Sad, the production quality is so much higher than Glee, it has actors that can act, but it’s not as big in the ratings.
Really hope NBC either abandons their Wednesday comedy block or tries with new pilots. Whitney and Chelsea need a quicker death. They’re painful to watch. Both comediennes, such as they are, should try cable.
Actually, The CW should wait for the pilots until making a desision. Mainly because only TVD, SPN and maybe TSC are safe right now while the other shows may crash in a matter of weeks.
The only reason the CW wouldn’t be sure they were renewing TVD is if they themselves weren’t sure there was even going to be a CW next season. If that were the case, I would suggest that NBC pick up Vampire Diaries to try and get with the 18-34 demo.
I can’t think that it helps the CW that TVD keeps disappearing for weeks at a time.
What about Person of Interest? That’s the only primetime show I really like and it’s picking up major steam on CBS.
Person of Interest isn’t one of the pet shows the media goes gaga over so they don’t like to talk about it as much.
I like person of interest a lot. I hope it continues.
Community – for the love of god please – one more season of community?
You all are forgetting about PERSON OF INTEREST, the biggest new hit show of the season. That is certain for renewal.
Please Amun-Ra let Pan Am get renewed.
I wish this could be the case and yes, their ratings were up for the season finale, but let’s not hold our breath though as a) this show was expensive to produce, b) the storylines and acting was so haphazrad it was hard to follow and if c) GCB does well starting next month, there won’t be a place to put Pan Am in the primetime schedule and with other actors already taking roles on newer series, it’s a longshot this show returns in the fall.
Sony is trying to decide what to do with Pan Am. It tanked here in the States but is very popular in Europe. Unfortunately ad revenue in Europe is crap.
Unforgettable is pretty much a shoe-in to get renewed. CBS owns it so they don’t have to share the revenue.
Person Of Interest is very expensive to make but is very popular. Constantly high ratings but they would like a bigger slice of the younger pie. CBS has to split the profits with Bad Robot so they don’t make as much but talk is they are coming back.
thistle n weeds-I agree with you about the CW-who knows if this will continue to be a “network”? I remember when it stopped being the WB,and,they announced it would be called the CW-upon hearing that-first thought in my mind was:CW= Can’t Work. Perhaps I was being a clairvoyant because it seems everything the CW has tried,especially lately,hasn’t worked. How long can this so-called network go on before scrapping everything and trying a new approach? One more thing: considering what a mess of their own Nbc has,and,their struggles:if The Vampire Diaries ever moved to Nbc-would that be a step up or a step down?-I’m not sure. I’m of course being very sarcastic about Nbc,but,you never know-if nbc doesn’t find a winning formula soon- they could find themselves in CW territory themselves before too long.
They have to start branching themselves out to newer audiences and for them to cease with the Ostroff mentality of constantly repeating episodes every single week. Get out of the reality business and focus on scripted programming that can be enjoyed by all audiences, not just focusing on the females. Pedowitz needs to focus on this most important task or this network will be finished by this time next year.
The CW’s big mistake was rebranding. They should have kept The WB brand and absorbed the few UPN shows that targeted the young women they are clearly after. With the possible exception of Gossip Girl and Vampire Diaries, none of The CW new shows since the merger have generated the buzz of The WB’s signature shows like Buffy and Dawson. Even bringing back Sarah Michelle Gellar hasn’t really worked for them. The Tribune stations see that the future isn’t in The CW…they have un-branded all of their CW stations…and they helped launch The WB. It might be time to pack up the tent, syndicate the one or two shows that are working (or sell them to cable), and call it a day.
Hey FOX here’s an idea, cancel American Idol and then renew everything else and still have room for all the new pilots. Why do we still have to watch that crap 3 nights a week?
Because it still makes more money than almost everything on Fox combined….
I HIGHLY doubt Smash will make it past this season… despite its pedigree, the audience just isn’t turning out in the numbers needed to justify it’s VERY high cost (and it’s numbers have dropped double digits every week… a trend which I expect to continue)… i wanted to like this show, but even as a gay man that likes musicals i think it’s atrociously bad… the only reason i’d continue to watch is for Showgirls-esque camp factor.
Please cancel The Office it’s horrible this year it’s so awful it deserves to be put out of its misery. And cancel my stupid spinoff that will be just as dumb.
I can’t stand American Idol myself, but without that cash cow making FOX’s budget, it’s unlikely that Fringe would have made it this many seasons. Sometimes you have to take the trash to get the treasure.
As for the CW, something has to change soon or their will not be a netlet left. The Netflix deal apparently added life to the coffers and allows the CW breathing room. Still, the need whatever pilot launches after VD next season to bring home big numbers. I’m guessing it will be Arrow. Of course, my interest in the CW right now only goes as far as seeing a renewal for Supernatural sooner rather than later.
Here’s an idea… Somebody pick up Firefly again. Fillion is trying to get that back on the air. There is a large fan base and I bet most of them would come back. Ratings might sky rocket (pun intended)
Sorry he is busy on a hit show called Castle
First I lose [H]OUSE, my very favorite show.

Now CBS wants to cancel A GIFTED MAN & CSI:N.Y. Guess what?
They were my next two favorite shows.
I guess this is my lucky year.
I LOVE YOU, HUGH LAURIE!!
That’s notice rang alarms bells we need to combined us together again in may due to the universe our time is began to grow into our own we both see what the thoughts of theses mortals they need love boy and they need inspired to gain some joys of joy we travel in time to gether I know know the movie handcock two immortal but we are the muse of everyone dreams and hopes we will be
togetherness as our two loving partnership and soul become as one once more god have this time to discover in. Us and time to get a justed to the beginning of our new life we linger till its to may I love you my babe
Hollywood is becoming some what of illusion to our eyes smoke and mirrors dreams are like come true but they do Hollywood us we make all the magic things happen all you have to do is pray and hope and grace and believe in yourself in what you can do to make it in Hollywood but there a dark downside to this just happened come
Unforgettable is awesome it is one of the best new shows of the season but was never given a real chance. It is far superior to tons of the junk that runs on cbs and if cbs were smart they would give it time develop and look at how far the show has come. Honestly the show got off to a rocky boring undeveloped start but as the season has progressed starting from around episode 12 13 the plots and the backstory about the characters being revealed and so on has proven to be both fascinating and entertaining. I want to see more.
Save and Support Unforgettable !!!!!
SSU