News Corp COO Chase Carey threw down the gauntlet to Idol‘s producers today, telling investors that the show’s ratings are “disappointing” and that the franchise “can and should provide fresh energy.” The show is “a glass half full,” he told the Deutsche Bank Media & Telecom Conference. It’s still big, but grappling with new competitors including NBC’s The Voice and Fox’s The X Factor. But Carey doesn’t seem to think that lets Idol off the hook: News Corp has factored into its financial guidance the fact that “the ratings aren’t where we hoped for them to be.”
For the most part, Carey was characteristically upbeat about News Corp’s prospects, especially in cable networks. He likes the fact that about half of Fox News’ pay TV distribution carriage contracts are due to be renewed in 2012 — an election year. Although he wouldn’t say how much additional revenue he expects to see in those deals, ”there’s a lot of growth left,” he says. He adds that “one of the great things” about the unit is that its costs are “pretty manageable….As we continue to drive popularity, a network like that benefits on all fronts.” He also has high expectations for FX. Although it is a close competitor to NBCUniversal’s USA Network, FX “probably makes half of what (USA) does.” Carey also sees new opportunities for News Corp’s regional sports networks. Time Warner Cable’s recent decision to end its contract impasse with Madison Square Garden — which owns and broadcasts the New York Knicks — “speaks to the value of sports franchises,” he says. Although the high cost of sports rights make them a “double-edged sword,” News Corp’s sports channel in Los Angeles has renewed its deals with the Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim and with the Los Angeles Clippers. As for the Dodgers, ”we’ll see if there’s something that makes sense.”
On other fronts, Carey says that News Corp isn’t looking to unload its newspapers — which many investors see as a growth-challenged distraction. “Our focus is on managing these businesses and improving profitability,” he says. Carey was more enthusiastic about Hulu. ”It’s a truly unique franchise that millions of people go to….A lot of people would chop off their arm to have that kind of place in the digital world.” He says that it must “continue to build on that leadership position.” And Carey hinted that News Corp might increase its effort to repurchase its shares. “We have a woefully undervalued stock,” he said. As the company approaches the end of its fiscal year in June “if things look like they do today, another buyback makes sense.”


You got that right, Chase.
Don’t believe Idol can recapture its audience in any significant quantity. I don’t watch it nearly as much as n the past. I do not think the show can do anything to regain my lost interest, and this may be true for the rest of the lost audience.
Chase, when you snooze, you lose. And, Idol has been slowly going to sleep for the last few years.
I am with you. I lost interest with the judge changes. The fact is they had the right mix – the well meaning music guy (Randy), the sweet, ditsy diva (Paula) and the sardonic but honest anchor (Simon). They still have Randy, they have a diva who is not likable or sweet and they have another guy who is ditsy and often creepy.
You have to like the people you are spending a few hours with week after week and the fact is other than Randy the judges are just not likeable people. The fact that they know the industry is not enough.
What’s the longest running shows on TV? The Simpsons is one, is it getting the ratings it did 4-7 years ago? Mash was on its last leg in its final season, so there’s a built in maturity point with all these shows. The Voice may be the new kid on the block, but the VOICE hasn’t produced a “winner.” It’s all about the judges, they’re the ones making money.
You must remember that AI is an appendage of Simon Fuller’s management company, that’s where he gets a lot of talent from and that’s where he promotes his talent. So if AI goes away, does Fuller’s management company & recording contract go away?
And I don’t know what he means by generate energy? Does he mean, shake up the staff & judges? Does he mean, no more Seacrest? I don’t think any of these people would care because they have so many other ventures.
Damn you, Disco — be cool again!
The “whacky” auditions and Hollywood Week need to be boiled down to 2 weeks, period. Everyone is over the lead up process and the current schedule is ridiculous. The Voice knows it – they do in 5 nights what has taken American Idol 6 weeks to do.
I don’t even bother watching idol until they get their top 24. I suspect next season (?) I won’t bother to watch until they reach their top 12.
Idol suffers from a serious case of overkill and over-saturation. Seriously, who can remember who won the last 2 or 3 seasons? It seems like when one season stops, another is beginning. Make Idol something to look forward to. Have a competition every 2 years or so. Use different celebrity judges each time, make it fresh.
Many years ago they had a concept called the news magazine; when every network decided to put a “news magazine” show on every night guess what happen, they all came tumbling down. This is no different X Factor was supposed to be some great second coming, well it did ok, but just ok.
Too many of one thing is NOT a good thing. FOX had the right formula Idol once a season, now they no sooner finish X Factor and they start Idol a few months later.
How does anyone take that moustache seriously? It’s like a bad Hercule Poirot. Yikes.
News Corp won’t do anything about the newspapers until Rupert Murdoch passes away – he loves them too much. After his death tho, expect to see a biiiiiig divestiture.