UPDATE, 5:05 PM: “The (SNL Kagan) report is riddled with inaccuracies and bad information. The venture is on more solid ground with more business momentum than ever before. Last Sunday, OWN was the number one cable network for women and people at 10pm. We remain confident in the future of OWN, and the long-term value we are building,” Discovery Communications spokesman David Leavy emailed to Deadline just now.
PREVIOUS, 3:16 PM: Research and investment firm SNL Kagan is the source authority for the kinds of financial information about cable channels that everyone wants to know, and that most companies don’t want to disclose. So it’s sure to attract a lot of attention with a report today from its respected long-time analyst Derek Baine who says that Discovery may need to take “a significant write-down” in Q1 for its investment in OWN to account for “programming costs for shows that are not working, as well as severance costs for those being laid off.” Last week the joint venture with Oprah Winfrey cancelled Rosie O’Donnell’s talk show and fired about 30 employees. Baine says he “would not be surprised to see Discovery ask Oprah Winfrey‘s Harpo Productions to finance some of the network’s losses going forward. Discovery has already funded well-beyond its $189 million commitment and they may want Harpo Productions to have more skin in the game.” Baine’s estimate of OWN’s $142.9M operating loss this year is up 33.6% from the $107M loss that SNL Kagan figured for OWN in 2011. Discovery reported a $35M loss for its equity investments last year, but that includes The Hub – which Kagan says probably broke even — as well as 3net and channels in Canada and Japan.
Discovery’s on the hook for much more: It has invested $312M in OWN. Yet Baine notes that the channel still has big hurdles to overcome. For example, ”advertisers may tire of playing the waiting game for shows to catch an audience.” In addition, many of Discovery’s deals with pay TV providers begin to expire late this year. ”Its hope for license fees of 20 cents to 25 cents per sub (per month) may now be unrealistic.” And here’s the kicker: ”Without a significant ratings boost by year-end, this could be Oprah Winfrey’s last chapter in the cable network industry.”


I’m sick and tired of hearing about OWN. File it under John Carter and move on…
Discovery, I feel so sorry for you…
I hope youve written in extensive penalties to Harpo for coming up short on this mindless vanity project.
Pull the plug, NOW!
How about Discovery doing the smart and right thing here and shutter this entire network and operations once and for all at the end of May. They’re spending money like lunatics for a network that will never gain any kind of traction and they’re burying themselves even deeper by sinking more money into this failed network. Call it a day and be done with this network and let Oprah fend for herself for once. Wash your hands of it and come up with something better.
I think Oprah specials on Discovery, E or Lifetime would be smarter than an entire Oprah network. Now that Oprah is off the air people have moved on without her. I wonder if she’ll pull a Leno and end up back at 4 pm in syndication.
Is time to pull the plug, it was a monumental failure and the toxic press it has received will keep getting worse and worse.
Oxygen must be breathing a big sigh of relief right now. Even though they had to go downmarket to get any kind of ratings, they are looking back at the time Oprah/Harpo had a small interest in them and are glad that it remained small. The one show she brought to that channel, “After the Show” instead of the show repeats she promised, was an albatross around their neck which did awful for them. It was a canary in the coal mine that Discovery should have used as a signal that an Oprah cable network was a bad idea, but they didn’t listen. Now they have no viewers and still two very angry fanbases from Discovery Home and Health that have seen their replacements, Planet Green and OWN, become miserable failures.
That OWN is trumpeting that it scored a ‘coup’ in acquiring the nuclear bomb of a 2010 summer series/prime time infomercial “Breakthrough with Tony Robbins” is the stupidest programming decision ever since the Spike/Entourage debacle.
The thing with Entourage is that it fits in with Spike’s programming. Meanwhile, OWN is making people change the channel and the sooner that she and Peter Ligerani are shown the door, the sooner Discovery can again thrive.
Too bad Discovery doesn’t have the cojones to admit OWN was a disaster from Day 1 and it’s time to cut their losses.
This OWN was a bad idea from day one. The original programming has been awful. Yes, hard to believe no one wants to watch a ‘master class’ conversation with Jay-Z, but it appears they do not. Short of Oprah going back to a daily talk-show program, I cannot see how OWN survives.
Regardless of what Oprah does in Daytime, OWN will die.
Kill this turkey and do it in some way that’s publicly humbling for Oprah herself–it will help her get back some of her edge ahead of an inevitable return to daytime syndication.
I mean seriously how much money do they have to lose before they come to their senses???
PS: That logo is garbage and I bet Oprah spent MONTHS driving graphic artists nuts on it.
you’re right, that really is a dreadful-looking logo.
When the best OWN could offer up was horrid 2nd string programming featuring The Judds, Shania Twain, Ryan/Tatum O’Neal and the Rosie Show it is hard to feel sorry for them right now. They are circling the drain but they deserve to be. Discovery should adopt a new mantra – quit throwing good money after bad.
“OWN” is called “Our Worst Nightmare” at DCI in Silver Springs. The estimates Kagan came out with would almost be acceptable if that was all there was. Much larger losses will ultimately have to be revealed. This ship is sunk and no one wants to admit it. OWN management is merely playing a shell game taking money from DCI and using it to supplement a Harpo company that was a one trick pony (and a very profitable trick it was).Harpo’s dysfunctional operational style worked because The Oprah WInfrey Show generated so much money it didn’t matter. Using the same clueless leadership and inexperience in running a network gives the results that is now OWN. Make no mistake about it, irrespective of who was CEO or “Interim” CEO Harpo was calling the shots. Now that Harpo’s Co-Presidents are running OWN there is no one to blame but themselves. OWN has become an excuse to keep Chicago alive and Discovery’s efforts to stem the tide is too little and too late.
Wait, what? http://tinyurl.com/79daff5
Also, aren’t women people?
OWN needs to expand beyond being a station for mostly women. That might be part of the problem. She needs to diversify her staff gender wise. Hire the people who have vision and can actually get the job done based on talent first. Make sure they are objective. Men and Women need to be able to watch a TV station and enjoy it. Just bring the proper programming. She can survive if she makes smart drastic changes.
Gee, for women AND PEOPLE?
Did he REALLY say that? Amazing.
They should just go ahead and rename it “Titanic Network” because that ship is sinking, baby.
Soon, real soon, OWN will go to RENT.
It sounds like OWN is going to be NOW Not Working Out : )
Last Sunday, OWN was the number one cable network for women and people at 10pm.
Wow, that’s great! One day at one hour it was number one. How many hours in a week again?
(also to echo the comment above – wtf is with the “women and people” ??)
“Last Sunday, OWN was the number one cable network for women and people at 10pm.”
I got confused and thought I had stumbled across a GOP Presidential candidate’s statement. Besides, that falls under the category of “big deal”, because it was a one-off event. Try capturing that audience every day.
Time for Discovery to pull the plug. If not now, then later in the year when they’re offered 15 cents (or less) per subscriber for cable rights.
Yeah Discovery just shut down this network just put American Chopper and Deadliest Catch reruns instead
And OWN’s lack of success suprises who? Right … that’s what I thought. How many times will this dead horse be beaten?