Universal Studios says Global Asylum stole their Battleship, but today the mockbuster producers claimed the studio’s copyright lawsuit over American Battleship is just a scapegoat smokescreen – but they “appreciate the publicity.”
“The Global Asylum has promoted the feature film American Battleship for nearly a year while Universal raised no concerns,” said Global Asylum today. “The timing of Universal’s recently filed lawsuit coincides with mixed reviews of its big-budget film, Battleship — the first movie based on a board game since Clue. Looking for a scapegoat, or more publicity, for its pending box-office disaster, the executives at Universal filed this lawsuit in fear of a repeat of the box office flop, John Carter of Mars. The Universal action is wholly without merit and we will vigorously defend their claims in Court. Nonetheless, we appreciate the publicity.”
Universal’s 54-page copyright infringement and false advertising suit (read it here) filed April 20 comes just weeks before the studio’s $100 million blockbuster Battleship hits North American theaters on May 18. The movie has already proved a big hit overseas since opening earlier this month. “This action,” the suit says, “arises out of Global Asylum’s knowing and willful violation of Universal’s rights with respect to Universal’s highly anticipated motion picture Battleship, and Global Asylum’s blatant infringement and unfair completion in advertising and promotion for sale, in the United states and in Europe, a straight-to-DVD knock-off that features substantially similar artwork, packaging, release dates, and film trailers as Universal’s motion picture.” According to Amazon and other online retailers, American Battleship is scheduled to be released May 22.
Universal wants the court to stop all stateside distribution of American Battleship with an injunction and all American Battleship DVDs, posters, trailers and everything else seemingly related to the movie destroyed. The studio also seeks compensatory damages that could range into the millions. The studio, which says it has spent over $30 million promoting Battleship, licenses Battleship from gamemaker Hasbro based on their “well-known naval combat board game of the same name.”
The suit, filed in U.S. District Court, follows on the heels of a UK court injunction that Universal successfully sough to halt Global Asylum’s American Battleship distributors on that side of the Atlantic. ”
American Battleship is nothing new for Global Asylum. For years the straight-to-DVD company has been the producers of such titles as Paranormal Entity, Titanic II, 2012: Ice Age and 2011’s Battle Of Los Angeles – which was not Columbia’s Battle: Los Angeles, though both did involve fighting off alien invasions. The mockbuster makers recently signed a one-year, 10-title first-look agreement with Staz/Anchor Bay Entertainment UK.
Universal had no comment on the lawsuit. The studio is represented by Andrew J. Thomas of downtown LA’s Jenner & Block LLP
Deadline's Dominic Patten - tip him here.


These Global Asylum idiot are parasites. The quicker the studios sue them out of business the better. It’s not parody when it’s a rip-off — and it’s not just the studios being ripped off, but the people who worked on that movie (especially the creative talent) and the consumers. This is really no different to brand piracy or making a fake Prada bag. And creatively the ‘movies’ they make are only fit for Youtube.
How can Hollywood complain about “rip-offs” when so many studio films are reboots and remakes? Or films where the subject of a greenlit big budget film becomes a hot pitch and similar scripts get greenlit to cash in on the trend? Like Armageddon & Deep Impact? Volcano & Dante’s Peak? Mission To Mars & Red Planet? The 6th Sense & Stir of Echoes? And so on.
The way to distinguish Battleship from American Battleship is easy, one of them stars Mario Van Peebles, the other has Liam Neeson. If people can’t tell the difference between a major studio film just because of a similar title and poster/dvd cover, then that says something about the big budget film. Global Asylum is just the modern Roger Corman studio, and maybe the studios are just Roger Corman with bigger budgets.
“How can Hollywood complain about “rip-offs” when so many studio films are reboots and remakes?”
I don’t know, maybe cause those studios pay for the rights to those properties. That might have something to do with it.
good one
You rip someone off, you get sued. It was only a matter of time.
” Or films where the subject of a greenlit big budget film becomes a hot pitch and similar scripts get greenlit to cash in on the trend? Like Armageddon & Deep Impact? Volcano & Dante’s Peak? Mission To Mars & Red Planet? The 6th Sense & Stir of Echoes? And so on. ”
there is a HUGE difference between studios creating competing products at the same time and some one blatantly ripping of the writers and creators of a project.
also if your going to list all those, why not include Mirror Mirror and ” Snow White and the Huntsman” or the 5 Wizard of Oz Movies coming out in 2013 and 2014
Bob, I think you should familiarize yourself with how studios came about in the first place. Who do you think were the first pirates to not pay patent royalties to Thomas Edison?
The studios get crazy and sue happy if you even film a couple seconds of movie footage yet seem to forget they themselves refused to pay on the infringing rights of Thomas Edison…not that he was any better but he did legally obtain those patents on the technology.
Please correct me if I’m wrong. Get your facts straight before you rush to the defense of companies that do the same type of things in their line of business.
Don’t forget their 2009 hit “Princess of Mars.”
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1531911/
At least they were bold enough to put “Princess” and “Mars” in their title. They also used the tagline “The classic story that inspired James Cameron’s ‘Avatar’.”
Well done, Global Asylum.
Asylum at least knew that the stupid movie needs MARS in the title. (I would have gone with “Warlord of Mars” since Taylor Kitsch is easily mistaken for a princess lol.) Maybe Disney should hire them to do their marketing.
“Maybe Disney should hire them to do their marketing.”
I’m not sure that’s a bad idea. I mean, Asylum does a great job of making crap look appealing. Heck, Asylum’s DVD artwork often looks better than that of the big-budget film its ripping off.
The original book is in the public domain
That story did inspire Avatar; it’s called John Carter by Burroughs–you know, the Disney movie that flopped. Even Cameron explicitly stated he was going to make a movie in the vein of Burroughs.
Here is story stolen by Americans passed off as original: Battle Royal (Japan) stolen by Hunger Games
Does Carl Weathers play himself in this?
“There’s still plenty meat on that bone.
You take this home, throw it in a pot, add some broth, a potato… baby you got a stew going!” – Carl Weathers playing Carl Weathers
“I think I want my money back.” – Tobias
Everyone will be saying Tobias’ quote after watching both of these Battleship films…
“[I]mitation and refinement through imitation are both necessary to invention itself and the very lifeblood of a competitive economy.” — Bonito Boats, Inc. v. Thunder Craft Boats, Inc., 489 U.S. 141, 146 (1989)
Who rents/buys this crap? Are they ALL fooled into buying it, thinking it’s something else?
I worked for Blockbuster for a couple years during school and I had many people rent these thinking they were the real movie. I believe their war of the worlds movie was a big renter because folks believed it was the Tom Cruise one.
I actually purposely rent these when there is nothing else I want to see. They are always good for a laugh…
Global Asylum exists purely so a mom can see a DVD box and think she’s getting the latest blockbuster that her kid just loves. Global Asylum also means “Regifted Error” or “Yard Sale bin”
I’ve been watching the Asylum films for years. They’re freaking hilarious and a lot of fun. Universal needs to get over themselves. The Asylum films aren’t for anything but a good time. If someone goes to Redbox and rents one of the Asylum films by mistake, they obviously haven’t don’t much research on the movie they want to rent. Who just looks at a picture on a kiosk and pushes a button or buys something without doing research on it anymore? We live in the computer age, people!
But man are these fun to watch on SyFy Network at 11:30 on a Saturday night after you’ve had a few.
Universal is just pissed that they spent so much and now they have to compete with a movie that was made for at most two million bucks. Asylum will always be able to stay afloat they have a smart formula and Universal won’t be able to win this lawsuit. They are wasting their time and money. Would have been much smarter to buy American Battleship so they can show it on Sy Fy channel as a Saturday night movie.
“made for at most two million bucks.”
TWO MILLION BUCKS????
Clearly, you haven’t seen an Asylum film. All those fancy shots are store bought stock. And then it’s about three sets!
The hilarious part of this is they ARE airing American Battleship on Syfy channel as a Saturday night movie.
No, the hilarious part of this is that SyFy – which is airing the movie – is owned by Universal – which is suing them.
That’s Hollywood right there in a nutshell.
Now that’s corporate synergy! Way to help out the home team, SyFy!
Try 250k. And 150 is ABL.
Asylum films are AWESOME! They are very entertaining (and usually more enjoyable than the films they are imitating)
I AM Omega? Awesome.
Transmorphers? AWESOME!
Also, they crank them out and make a profit and have fun doing them. Are you supposed to take them seriously? NO!!!!
I applaud them. This is the entertainment business, not the serious-world-changing business.
Go out and rent a few and calm the f%^& down.
Asylum’s “Paranormal Entity” is an awesome movie, much better than “Paranormal Activity.”
David Rimawi and his Asylum haven’t had an original concept EVER. Just look up his “filmography” on IMDB. Their movies, while blatant ripoffs, are also unintentionally funny – from amateurish “special” effects to absolutely horrendous dialog, to former stars attempting a comeback at any price.
Catch their efforts on late night cable. Cause they’re not worth the price of a rental or download.
David Rimawi is laughing all the way to the bank.
AND, he’s a nice fella. I wish I had thought of what he did.
Plus, they are making several movies a year! That would be pretty sweet to be making something.
Netflix currently streams most of this Global Asylum crap and has the nerve to call it content.
Carl Weathers > Taylor Kitsch
This is like a fight evil vs. evil.
One horrible movie with a total lack of ideas is copied by another company that has even less ideas and moviemaking soul.
Hard to pick a side here.
PS: Garbage movies like “Battleship” are much easier to copy than good movies.
It’s also always the low end audience who is the target of these rip-offs.
So why not make better movies?
My word in God’s ear.
And I hardly dare to think what, after comic books, board games, toys, video games will be made into a movie next.
Will we see “Toilet Paper – The Movie”?
I feel see sick.
Reason: I just watched the trailer for “American Battleship”.
This is “Plan 9 of from outer space” lack of quality.
Astonishing that you can make money with such garbage.
Who the hell watches such junk? The brain dead? Zombies? Mc Donalds overeaters?
Having seen Battleship, I can’t really imagine that American Battleship can seriously be any worse than it.
But I’ve never understood how people confuse these cheapos with the film they are imitating. Does nobody read the covers anymore?
The laugh factor – NBC Universal actually fund Asylum. Really. Through a deal with Syfy, which they own.
Universal doesn’t own Syfy – they are both divisions of Comcast and equal to each other. The cable companies make more money for Comcast than Universal does.
Im very sure that no one can claim the own one word – just because its made to film: battleship or american battleship.. if i wanted to make a movie called: “battleship from mars or BattleshipS that would be my business.. america and other countries was built on copy paste mentality..
would we be able to use the same restrictions on Books??.. nope..
if i caled my book: ” chair” anyone should be able to cal it the same – only destinction should be the cover, and the auther..
just sayin.. copy writs are Bulll!!!!
Just saw American Bat^h^h^^hWarships and it was a hell of a lot more entertaining than Battleship. Go Asylum!