
Better With You star JoAnna Garcia has been tapped as the female lead opposite Justin Kirk in NBC’s new fall comedy series Animal Practice. The office comedy stars Kirk as George, a House-like veterinarian, who loves animals but usually hates their owners (especially the new woman who runs the clinic). Garcia will play that woman, George’s intelligent and beautiful old girlfriend, now engaged to another, who is assigned to run the animal hospital. Garcia replaces Amy Huberman who played the role in the pilot. Co-starring on the series, created by Brian Gatewood and Alessandro Tanaka, are Tyler Labine and Bobby Lee.
Related: ‘Animal Practice’ To Recast Female Lead
Garcia took a winding road to the fall schedule this season. She was originally attached to a multi-camera family comedy project written by Better With You creator Shana Goldberg-Meehan, which sparked a bidding war before landing at ABC with a production commitment but ultimately didn’t go to pilot. Garcia was then quickly cast as the female lead in CBS’ untitled Greg Malins/Greg Berlanti comedy pilot, which came close to a series order but ultimately missed the cut, making WME-repped Garcia available. She was immediately approached for Animal Practice and, after negotiations and a chemistry read with Kirk, was cast in the role.
TV Editor Nellie Andreeva - tip her here.


Hopefully this is good casting.
Good news, I just need Julia Stiles back on my TV now
What a great choice. I was a little disappointed when the CBS pilot didn’t advance. Garcia has charm and beauty to spare.
Funny and great. Loved her since Reba.
She’s a much better choice than Amy Huberman
What’s not to love about JoAnna Garcia?
Couldn’t understand why NBC would dump Amy then use a trailer clip of Amy and Justin and the monkey to promote the series on the official NBC site. Makes absolutely no sense to me. So – the best clip of the pilot as perceived by NBC marketing/PR peeps involves the one cast member that isn’t going forward to the series??
Because the reshoot hasn’t happened yet. The recasting just happened. It’ll be swapped when the pilot is updated.
She is simply a terrible actress. Entitled and untalented. This won wont last either.
JoAnna’s a great gal…congrats!
enough with this girl! Stop trying make fetch happen – it’s not going to. They tout her as the next big thing in TV every season and every season viewers are like – no.
@wannabeontop, George Clooney was the star of a number of failed shows before ER. In fact, one of those failed shows was a comedy called Emergency Room.
Seeing her photo and the show description, all I could think of was the fake TV show trailer at the end of Forgetting Sarah Marshall – “Animal Instincts” I think it was. All they need now is Kristen Bell.