Time Warner couldn’t horse around with the figures it had to disclose in its Q1 earnings release this morning: HBO took a $35M impairment charge for its ill-fated series Luck, about race-track gamblers and starring Dustin Hoffman, which was cancelled in March — midway into production for its second season. The show generated so-so ratings, but execs put the series to sleep following an uproar over news that a third horse had died in the production. Naysayers included People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals, which said that “old, unfit, and drugged horses were forced to race for this series.” The producers said that they “maintained the highest safety standards throughout production, higher in fact than any protocols existing in horseracing anywhere with many fewer incidents than occur in racing or than befall horses normally in barns at night or pastures.”


Milch was the problem. A stubborn old horse saddled with an Emmy too early in his career, who now refuses to write compelling drama, and, instead, chews on scenery like carrot chips.
May I suggest to you, CenturyCity2020 that you stick to CBS dramas, at least that way you’ll suffer less befuddlement during your tv viewing time.
Please, please, please HBO, spend your development money on somebody other than Milch.
He belongs on A&E with all the “Kings” shows, since he so desperately believes he is one.
PFFFF they should of invested at least half of that into more game of thrones episodes per season!
I wish they’d put that money into Game of Thrones. (Not that it’s lacking, but they could use more episodes.)
If they took a $35 million loss because of so-so ratings and an abrupt cancelation for Luck, how exactly did they ever plan to turn a profit with the show? Would above average ratings have translated to than much more revenue?
HBO’s business model isn’t based on ratings, it’s based on subscriptions. They don’t have advertisers, and don’t really care about ratings (see: Bored to Death). It probably has more to do with the fact that they taped the majority of a second season that will probably never air and thus never make them money, or the fact that a single-season show won’t be able to sell that many Blurays and obviously won’t ever get syndicated. I don’t know how much of that is factored in here but the revenue on season 2 is ZERO, regardless of season 1′s ratings.
But you are not horse racing. You are making a movie. Look at how horses were used or how multiple horses played one “character” in Braveheart, War Horse, Seabiscuit, Lonesome Dove, Hidalgo without incident. Three horses? That hints at some bad handling. Animal welfare should be all over them.
If Barry Zito can recover his old form maybe Milch can too.
I agree. Put the money into Games so they can afford some actual battle sequences instead of filling the time with countless sex scenes.
Bingo!
“Naysayers”? Well played.
Good riddance. The show was a bone yard of tired talent (both 2 and 4 legged versions).
It’s a shame horses dropped dead, but it gave HBO the excuse to cancel this dog without offending any of the big names associated with it.
Well stated.
Mmm-hmmm. If Luck had been a ratings hit with strong critical buzz, they’d have found a way to solve the horse issues.
if i had to guess, i’d say the horses weren’t treated great. just a guess…
I liked the show a lot. Amazing actors, a smart look into a world I knew nothing about. It was a slow starter, but one of the more compelling, original dramas I’ve seen. Perhaps its only flaw creatively was overestimating its audience.
It’s only flaw was bad storytelling. Good acting totally wasted.
Thankfully, now that this show is cancelled, horses will never die again.
35 Million!? That could/should have been used for more Deadwood.
EXACTLY! Notice that whenever Milch is mentioned in any article, the word “Deadwood” appears right after. That series ended FAR too early (not to mention its one of those rare shows that gained popularity after it ended).
I wish Milch would get off his high horse (no pun intended), swallow his pride and visit Deadwood again… arguably one of HBO best shows ever.
Come on, people….it’s about more than the horses. When did you ever see someone junk a show because of treatment to animals? It was a chance to bow out gracefully….and they took it.
And yet it still pulled in higher ratings than “Girls.”
No, Girls ratings are not good but they are still almost twice as big as Lucks.
Remember when they sunk 25 mil on just half a season of 12 Miles of Bad Road? They seem to be getting better at this.
Drama is clearly dead at HBO for a while. It’s now about “reward” viewing, which I guess means STD jokes and sex on animal skins. Thank God THE WIRE aired when it did; it wouldn’t stand a chance now that HBO has lost its courage.
“It’s not television! It’s Cinemax, er, I mean HBO!”
How do they explain the $28 million they spent on 12 Miles of Bad Road and then didn’t show it? I was on the crew (and still work on an HBO show) it was the best comedy they have ever done but the idiots that lead my company are dumb S.O.B’s that wanted to prove they didn”t need former president Chris Albrect to show them how it’s done. Apparently they do.
Someone should get a campaign started to get them to air it if it’s so good!