It would be a huge upset if the preternaturally gifted 16-year-old wins Season 11 of American Idol on Wednesday. Online odds-makers unanimously consider the Dave Matthews-influenced Phillip Phillips to be the favorite — which would make him the fifth consecutive white guy with a guitar to take the prize. Ireland’s Intrade gives Phillips a 78% chance of winning. At Curacao-based Pinnacle, a $1 bet on Phillips would pay $1.262, while one on Sanchez would pay $4.22 if she wins. Antigua’s Intertops says $1 should pay $1.40 on Phillips and $2.75 on Sanchez. And at Bodava, based in the Mohawk Territory of Kahnawake, Canada, a $13 bet on Phillips would net you a $4 profit if he wins while $2 on Sanchez would pay $5. What to do? As far as I’m concerned, nothing. Despite the show’s hype about the democratic nature of its “nationwide vote,” we know little about who casts ballots and how accurately their votes are counted. Frank Luntz isn’t out there conducting focus groups. Still, if you’re foolish enough to bet on the outcome, why not be bold? Perhaps NBC’s The Voice this year lured away some of the viewers pre-disposed to support a good looking guy. Maybe Sanchez will win the lion’s share of people who supported gospel-influenced singer Joshua Ledet, voted off last week. If you haven’t guessed it yet, I’ll admit that Idol is a guilty pleasure — and that I admire Sanchez’s musical intelligence, vocal control, versatility, and nerve. I’d like to see her shake things up. The show’s producers, and record label, probably should as well just to make the cheesy proceedings a little less predictable. As the New York Lottery says, hey, you never know.


A finale between a girl who yells every song and a guy who can barely sing in key. 70,000 people audition and this is what it comes down to. Amazing. 13 year old girls really need to be banned from voting.
yells? r u watching the same show? u need to consult your audiologist asap!
Jessica does scream her songs; she shouldn’t have been saved. Skylar is and was much better than Jessica. I hope she doesn’t win.
never liked Skylar, who can only sings country music, so limited!!!!, im glad she was voted off so early…
IF SKYLAR WAS LIMITED ? THEN THEN WHAT DO YOU CALL VERY SONG SOUNDING LIKE WHITNEY??? COME ON?? VOCAL GYMNASTICS… HOLDING A NOTE FOR 45 SECONDS GETS OLD. ELISE HAD THE MOST ORIG. VOICE. WHITNEY HAS BEEN DONE BY EVERYONE UNTIL IT’S OLD. JESS HAS ONE RANGE AND HAS BEEN DOING THE SAME OLD TIRED RUNS FOR SO LONG IT WILL BE HARD FOR HER TO MAKE THE TRANSITION TO ANYTHING. Skylar was takingrock and R&B to country.. That takes talent and she and Elise both know how to work a stage. That is huge in the business. “Whole Lotta Love” was the best stage performance ever on AI. Unreal..It was like being at the concert. Smoking Hot! Elise is Anne Wilson, Adele, Jan J., and Stevie N. all rolled into one.
I like the top 11 idol. Why it’s only 11 because i don’t like Skylar. Her voice isn’t good at all.
SCREAMS! and Skylar should have never been voted off. Oh wait…Jessica was.
Just another misinformed commenter. Get a life and I totally agree with you, Jenna.
You think Jessica screamed and Skylar was better because she doesn’t? I think we watched different shows. Skylar, as powerful a vocalist as she is, can’t hold a candle to Jessica vocal wise. Skylar is a one-trick pony that screams her way through country rock songs. Jessica is a vocal gymnast capable of singing any style or genre. Wow, get a clue.
Amen thanks Richard.. I believe it was all a racial issue! Duh Phillips was a white blue eyed guy. Of course!
Again.,America has shown their true taste when it comes to song, music and artistry. It is completely boring, old fashion, like a sophomore parade and unstopable amateur white singing guy like Phillip Phillips. Come on uncle Sam, you must move on and look for someone who is really best like Jessica Sanchez!!. And please, Stop mentioning the stinky name Skylar for god sake! She is the most nasal singer I have ever heard in my entire life. It will be better if she will join to an amateur wrestling show somewhere else…..
She may sing anything even the phone book but it will always come out sounding like a tired version of Whitney. Take a look at the Queen stuff Jessica did. Then look at “I Want It All” by Elise. MY GOD. And Elise was voted off??? It’s all for show don’t you know.
I thought Phillip Phillips was wonderful! He sings his way which is what an artist is supposed to do! The last night I was so ready for it to be over! I have never in my life heard so much screaming and ugly freaking looks on singers’ faces! Wow! It is nice to see such a humble guy that has such a passion and love for music win! Congratulations Phillip Phillips!
It would be a huge upset if the preternaturally “gifted” 16-year-old wins season 11 of American Idol on Wednesday.
“GIFTED”? Really? Just awful. These are folks who cannot sing. Period. If either of these fools went into a room and Alicia Keys was sitting at a piano and was auditioning neither would be in the ballpark. What we have here is the best of the worst. That’s it. That’s why there are been no artists ever found on American Idol. Not one Bruce, Barbra, Mariah, and on. No real artists. Only idols. An Idol is a cute kid who cannot sing ie; Justin Bieber.
Thanks a lot.
you are deaf or just musically dumb. if you said they can’t sing while everybody said yes there is surely something wrong with you
who is this art creature? what a moron! obviously somebody who just wants to stir up trouble. you wandered into the wrong tv show. this is american idol, not jerry springer show where cognitively-challenged people like you belong. jessica and philip can sing alright, certainly better than you i’m sure! oh, you, too lethargic–better clean up your ears. you don’t know what good music is! i’ll go more for jessica but philip is alright.
Joshua and Jessica are the best singers… I don’t know what Phillips it’s doing there….
Philip is there because the majority of fans voted for him. Most creative artist on the American Idol show EVER! Older fans are voting for him as well…Joshua and Jessica are screamers and how much of that can you listen to at a concert. REALLY? Can you really listen to Joshua’s screatching and screaming for two hours one song here and there he is awesome…Jessica, like watching a teen at a high school promo special sing incredibly…can’t see her doing extremely well in the music industry with her limited ability to the real world…creepy to hear a 16 year old sing older people’s song, besides she was voted off already if it was not for the judges would not even be in the final top 2…back to home school homework instead, until she graduates high school…Jordin Sparks looked a lot older than her age when she won not like a little kid who looks like she belongs in middle school …Glee will love her…
Phillip is there because of the majority tone deaf fans including teen bopper girls voted for him. What? Originality? isnt he a copycat of Dave Matthews Band? Sad to say that Josh was voted off and he is supposed to be in the finals with Jessica. Both have awesome vocals as compared Phillip with a limited vocal range. If Phillip wins, im sure he will follow the same fate of Lee Dewyze.
“Most creative artist on American Idol show EVER!” Really???? Have you watched the show before? David Cook, Blake Lewis, Kris Allen, Adam Lambert, Bo Bice and Crystal Bowersox are rolling over in their music career graves.
at least Jessica goes to school and doing great even when she is on American Idol, unlike other people out there who cant even barely read and grasp simple lessons in school…though, Phillip is OK, but i would still go for Colton who is greater than Phillip…
I agree 100,
It has long been presumed that Philip Phillips would win because he has never been in the bottom 3 and although I’m happy that he made it into the finals (although I much would have preferred colton), I have to say my sentimental favorite and powerhouse singer and therefore winner of American Idol should be Jessica Sanchez. Even singers like Adam Lambert and Kris Allen and Jennifer Hudson have agreed that Jessica should win. Does the best singer win? Not always, but it should, isn’t that what a singing competition is supposed to be about?
It does not matter that he has NEVER been in the bottom 3 it’s all for show first off..Adam Lambert was NEVER in the bottom 3 either guess what he lost! It’s who the producers want to win in the end to be quite frank with you. Adam was the popular winner by vote but because he didn’t have the squeaky clean image that American Idol wanted to portray Kris Allen was chosen. Adam has over 1 million followers and Kris doesn’t even come close that should tell you something. We never see the numbers so producers can do and say whatever they want we will never know. And for the people saying neither can sing. That is all a matter of opinion. I don’t think Steven Tyler can sing but some people would beg to differ with me. You listen to Jessica’s studio versions of the songs she has sung on Idol and your opinion might change. I listened to her studio version of My All from Mariah and it blew me away. Just go to youtube they are all there. And for someone to say Idol has created no stars? WOW Kelly Clarkson, Carrie Underwood, Adam Lambert who was nominated for a Grammy and just went Platinum with his first album, Jennifer Hudson…Grammy and Oscar…Jordin Sparks just finished a movie with Whitney Houston? I think Idol has created stars. Funny how people will just say anything just for the sake of sounding stupid!
uhm… adam lambert has been in the bottom 3 in the top 5 week of season 8.
yeah, Agree!
well, lets just look at the brighter side of AI, Adam Lambert is way better as a runner up, Jennifer Hudson and so on… so Jessican will also do the same justice, at least she is being endorsed by the big stars who believe in her talent, yes she can scream the songs with high pitch but hey she can sing a mellow songs…
These folks cannot sing? Well, you obviously couldn’t spot talent if it was sitting on your lap. Jessica Sanchez blows Alicia Keyes out of the water, and I work in the business. She is going to be a huge star, and get signed, regardless if she wins. Best of the worst? And Idol has created no stars? What about Kelley Clarkson or Carrie Underwood? Yeah, they have no talent. Go back to trolling sites like the drudge report, you bitter fool!
I liked Phillip a lot early on but then he started making every song the same growly DMB-style jam. Jessical is like a singing robot, hitting all the notes without any emotion. If they restricted every number to a single vote you’d see a different result.
Btw, you can’t ‘troll’ the Drudge report, it’s just a news aggregator, but I take your point. Obviously people who go there don’t have ears, or musical opinions.
What do you mean Jessica cannot sing? Are you out of your fucking mind? Of course she can and then you add the fact that she’s 16-years-old. Imagine where she’ll be when she’s in her 20s. Besides, no Asian people ever win and the world needs something different on the music scene domestically. Tired of seeing the same wash & repeat billboard charts.
I agree.
Jessica is fantastic. She is 16 and I dare you to find someone her age that can do what she can vocally. If nourished and developed–the sky is the limit for her. You detractors just sound like crusty curmudgeons.
Whatever you think of her, this gifted tiny girl is living her dream. At 16, she’s getting a shot at her own ‘American dream’-a million $s or two, perhaps?
And that’s a lot more than can be said of those who just watch and envy.
AMEN!!! You can converse and berate Jessica and Phil and each other.
When it came down to stage presence and all around class there was only one. I think Jessica may have given it away with the last song. The thing that I cannot get passed with Phil was how nervous and the constant leg rubbing when he finally performed without his admitted security blanket guitar.
If they had not saved Jessica,within the rules,Idol would not have had a true champion ….. they would not have had to go through Jessica.
Wow. Hello!? Anyone out there that cannot recognize supreme God given talent should shut the F up! Jessica is an absurdly gifted singer. At an incredibly young age she has perfect control, huge dynamic range and voice that only a few out there could ever hope to have.
Wake up!
If she doesn’t win, no biggie. She will become hugely famous and deservedly so
I agree if each phone could only vote once Joshua would be in the Final!!!!!!!!
I’m so sick of the comment that Jessica is boring or robotic — she has shown more of her character and likeability these past few weeks but why does she have to constantly prove herself with a voice as powerful as hers — and I have NEVER heard her scream. She is a phenomenal singer and I can only hope that America gets it right, either way Philip will do just fine — both are guaranteed a record deal now.
GOD A LOT OF HATERS HERE ARENT THERE>>>SAYING JOSH AND JESS CANT SING? They sing better than the people judging them although I quite wouldn’t go as far as Jlo saying Josh is the best singer in 50 years…But those 2 have HUGE potential…esp Jessica but her personality may turn off some people, especially all those jealous girls who think they’re going to marry Philip
I agree with you about JLo’s “best singer in 50 years” bit though to be fair, she might have just exaggerated out of excitement. LOL Also agree with you on Josh, Jess & Philip. Jessica’s problem isnt about her voice/talent but rather the limited demographic of audience she appeals to. Also, not taking anything away from Philip, he’s no doubt got talent but I think what kept him from the bottom 3 were the votes of the female fans who voted for him for his looks rather than his voice/talent.
If Jessica wins, I think it would be the FIRST time someone ‘VOTED OFF’ by viewers (NOT including WILD CARD rounds) went on to win the show. Plus, the producers gave Jessica OR Joshua the so-called Pimp-Spot (Last One to Sing) the last 4 weeks… Seems like this is the most rigged Idol EVER. My vote is for Phillip. Go PHILLIP !!!!
I hate when the judges and producers tell me who I should vote for !!
You are wrong. As someone, me, in the inner circles of the show and music we all laugh alone over dinner. It’s a circus contest not a talent contest. Jimmy knows it. But he will make money and will promote the balls out of it to do his job. They are bad singers. Take it from me. Someone who was in the studio with the likes of real talent like Janis Joplin, Stevie, and Mick. You don’t realize how off base you are. Talent is different then being given a choice of no talent A and no talent B and picking one. Doesn’t mean talent. Again, Jessica is bad. As I sat in a room with two others and Nora Jones, Jessica would be out of place. She is a mimic not an original voice. Dan Ackroyd did a great Nixon. He wasn’t Nixon. And Phillip ain’t Dave Matthews or John Popper. He’s a mimic. That’s what you get. Talent, real talent, is one in a million. Start studying my friend. You don’t get it.
Based on the brilliance of your remarks, you must have gleaned these things while you came in to empty the waste basket.
Classic! My face was split in two the whole time I was reading and re-reading your comment.
no talent? no talent at all? better brush up on your dictionary meaning of “talent”- a capacity for achievement or success. YOU are not the authority in declaring somebody worthless nor do you have the right to go on trampling on somebody’s skills.
They have talents. They have REAL capabilities. They are succeeding on becoming great someday. all the “talented people” you keep referring to started somewhere. Ask those people (Alicia Keys, Norah Jones etc.) if they agree with you.
Jessica, Philip, and Josh are gifted. young and full of potential. and may i dare say, TALENTED.
If Philip Phillips wins, he will follow the same path of Lee Dewyze…Where is he now? Im sur you know what I mean.
I’d say they will be singing at Santa Monica beach just like Chris Allen did. Sorry.
I’m so sorry to disagree but, emotional breadth – the telling of a story in song is most certainly there in the youngest of singers with great or even good talent. Sure, the 6 or 10 year old can display vocal gymnastics but soon after, there needs to be an understanding of what it is you’re singing about. You don’t suddenly realize you’ve connected with your music’s words at age 20! You had to know that from the earlier days. Look at Judy Garland in her teens with ‘Zing Went The Strings’ – look at Michael Jackson with ‘Ben’ – look at Selena or Whitney or Janis or Mathis. They felt the words. They were story-tellers first. Don’t tell me a singer will find that later – it is first or it ain’t there – the rest are not singers, they are mimics.
you understand talent and music. You can make talent. Great talent is in a person. It’s a passion. It’s not mimicking. These are the best mimics, I guess. That’s why I saiid, none of them could walk in a room and sit across from real talent. These kids are good for high school where mimicry is often confused with the real thing. Kelly Clarkson sang the heck put of Respect. She sounded like Aretha. Put her in a room with Aretha and suddenly you realize Kelly should sing at her school dance, not for Americs. The show is silly. Real talent is rare.
Thanks a lot.
Aretha, Kelly Clarkson and Jessica all have talents. If you’ve seen Aretha when she was 16 no doubt you would retract what you said. Aretha becomes a legend because the songs she sings were awesome and written for her if not written by herself. If you would give Jessica a chance like what Aretha had I’m sure she will be a legend too. Just because a singer sings another singer’s song doesn’t makes her or him less talented. Hadn’t it occur to you that given the chance to record all original and amazing songs, all those mimics you called would fare the same or even better than Aretha. Whitney didn’t made me cry when she sang I Will Always love You, but Jessica did. It takes talent for one singer to evoke tears from her audience. Have you seen such passion when Jessica and Kelly sings? Well, like what Brandy said, Jessica make singing like the best thing ever. BTW Kelly’s songs are amazing.
i think what people mean is that in telling a story, experience helps. So storytelling can be learned, not like you would a skill, but because the more you live, the more you understand the meaning behind the songs…
I fully expect when sitting in the audience tonight that it will be Phillip Phillips. Why? The ever present voting of 13 year old girls. If we could only do something about the cartoon name – ah well nice guy he’s gonna go far as will they both.
I think Phil Phillips made a huge mistake doing Matchbox Twenty’s, “Disease” last week, a number I enjoyed enough to cause me to research the original song. What an epiphany! Phil and Rob Thomas sound “exactly” alike, and that’s an understatement! Here I’d given Phil undeserved kudos all these weeks for being his own man, when at best, he’s just a really good Rob Thomas impersonation. To top that off, his final Bob Segar number was the only time this season we’ve seen the real Phil Phillips stand up, and we can thank Jimmy for that. Although it was “okay”, Phil’s struggle to hit the notes was apparent to even a tin ear. Thank you Jimmy! Sorry Phil. A Rob Thomas impressionist doesn’t deserve the title. Too bad his voice didn’t perfectly match Robert Plant or Roger Waters. Jessica’s a clear winner in my book, no matter how things shake out!
Yes, you really sound unbiased to me.
Frankly, Ms. Sanchez could do with some dental work and Mr. Phillips a clean shave. That said, one artist seems driven by the music whereas the other as means to an end to promote self through music. Nonetheless may the best performance tonight win, and, as it should be, in my view.
Phillips was bottom 3 two weeks ago! In fact bottom two with Hollie! And bottom two again last week! jessica got the highest votes for the last two weeks! Jessica will win coz she is the most popular and most talented! Vote for her AMERICA!
I hope America does not vote for her. Jessica does not deserve to win. She should not have been saved by the judges. She is so stuck on herself.
Of course Janie is one of the jealous little girls who will vote for the no-talented Phillip
Hello! Phillip was last to sing last week! Both finalists are there coz they are the 2 most popular! Joshua voters will go for Jessica coz they know what talent is all about! Put all your money on Jessica. She has been top vote getter the last 7 weeks after being saved! Bet and VOTE for Jessica! Sure Winner!
It is natural for one to wish one’s choice to win but,I believe the best thing for us voters/audience/listeners would be to be honest with ourselves and simply vote for whom you truly believe deserves to win! NO IF’S NO BUT’S ! JUST YOUR HONEST TO GOODNESS CHOICE REGARDLESS OF! Let’s avoid the unnecessary negatives.LOVE,PEACE AND JOY TO ALL!
I for one am rooting for Phiilip. I find that when I watch him perform, he makes me feel something. I can picture myself downloading his song and pay to see him perform. Jessica is a wonderful giril and I agree she sings very well How ever I just find her to be a good singer and not a performer!
And in the end it really won’t matter, I find in most cases the non winners of idol do better than the winners! We can all say Lee Dwyzes who ?, Ruben Studdard who ? Chris Allan who? Taylor Hicks Who?
And on a last note who cares who wins, this world has bigger problems than who is going to be the next American Idol. We should all be lucky that at this moment our biggest dilemma of the day is wondering who will win tonight. We are lucky people folks !!
Have a great day and form Canada where I can’t vote anyway …..GO PHILIP !!!!!
Has anyone thought that Simon Fuller selected the songs in accordance to his preference of a winner?
“I have Nothing” vs “Stand By Me” … really?
I think Phillip got shafted on the first song personally.
Maybe that’s why Phillip howls “Owww” at the end of every line.
Sorry, but since Jessica was almost eliminated, the Philippines have been non-stop in thiur efforts to make sure that Jessica is the American Idol, they have found a way to vote by using Facebook, other means of online voting and even making calls via satelite hook ups from various malls and thousands use and have Magic Jack with several different phone numbers… they estimate over 10 million Filipinos are now voting the maximum times for her… so not sure it is all because of her talent or even if it fair, she went from being the lowest number of vote to being the top vote getters the past 3 weeks…