Less than two months before The Expendables 2 comes out, Sylvester Stallone today scored an action hero legal victory. Judge Jed Rakoff rejected Marcus Webb’s claims that The Expendables was his original idea and Sly stole it. Webb sued Stallone, the retro action flick’s co-author David Callaham, Millennium Films, Nu Image Films and Lionsgate in late October 2011. In his initial suit, Webb said he circulated a script several years ago among studios about “elite highly trained mercenaries” recruited to defeat a dictator. Webb alleged that the screenplay for The Expendables is “strikingly similar and in some places identical” to his The Cordoba Caper. Webb claimed that Stallone, who directed, co-wrote and starred in The Expendables, and his team must have seen his script because they were so alike. The Rocky star’s lawyers said that was unlikely especially being that one was an action movie and Webb’s was more of a caper flick. The lawyers also pointed out that Callaham had already written several drafts of what was to become 2010’s The Expendables before Webb’s script was even out there. The judge, who said a more formal order would be forthcoming, obviously agreed. The Expendables 2 comes out on August 17, 2012.
Deadline's Dominic Patten - tip him here.


Ha why would anyone want to claim they came up with the idea for that shit film?
Because it made millions and millions and millions of dollars and they want to eat the pie without baking it?
We will never know the truth but someone stealing someone else’s idea nah that never happens in hollywood
“A gang of mercenaries are recruited take down an evil ruler”
In order for Person A to “steal an original idea” from Person B, it is imperative that Person B actually HAVE an original idea to begin with. The above mentioned plot line hardly qualifies.
brilliant post!
DOGS OF WAR, THE WILD BUNCH, THREE AMIGOS… A logline is a very elastic thing.
Is stealing something worthless still stealing?
Both scripts seem to be rubbish and copied from countless other scripts of the same kind that were also copied from copies.
It’s all way too xeroxed to care.
And Stallone’s movie is being used as punishment in super-maxes.
Dear Marcus,
Thank you for making it that much harder for newbies to get their scripts in the hands of executives and agents. Just b/c you wrote a story about mercenaries taking on a dictator doesn’t mean everybody who writes about mercenaries and dictators owes you royalties for the rest of your life. No more so than if I write about rebels taking on an evil empire in a distant galaxy. George Lucas doesn’t own that.
What he does own is “storm-troopers” and “jedis” and “lightsabers” and “x-wing fighters”.
I’m willing to bet your script had little in common other than general concept. On top of that you failed to provide any proof that your script was in the hands of any producer or writer involved with Sly’s project.
But thank you for wasting everyone’s time. We newbies appreciate you giving more ammo to the I-can’t-read-your-script-for-legal-reasons crowd.
“First, cradle the balls. Now, grip the shaft…”
That’s from ‘Pool for Dummies’, right?
Expendables ROCKED. Can’t wait til part duece!
Although I agree with most that was said in the talkback I must admit Stallone is notorious for stealing ideas. You can Google the real writer of Rocky… and how he got paid to never speak of the lawsuit he has against Stallone for stealing his Rocky script. That was signed, sealed and settled out of court. If Stallone had any real class Avi Lerner wouldn’t be his only game in town.