Ray Richmond contributes to Deadline’s TV coverage.
Three days after being announced as a new co-host on CBS This Morning, former CBS News chief White House correspondent Norah O’Donnell joined her fellow hosts Charlie Rose and Gayle King along with her CBS News bosses on a TCA panel to promote the news division. O’Donnell replaces Erica Hill. It was made clear that the timing of the shakeup isn’t coincidental and comes as the Presidential election enters the homestretch. “It really is about Norah and her abilities,” said CBS News chairman Jeff Fager. “We just feel like in terms of where we’re going, and with Norah’s experience in reporting and where we’re going with our broadcast, that she’s just such a perfect fit. Especially going into the election, coming right out of the
White House, she just adds so much. And Erica’s been a great pro for us. She helped launch this program. We hope she stays. We just think this is a better fit.” For her part, O’Donnell said that she was “thrilled” to be on the broadcast. “It’s an exciting time,” she added. “Two hours of live television. There’s nothing else like it. I think we’re now 100 days out from the election so we’ve got two conventions coming up, three Presidential debates, one Vice Presidential debate, so I’m excited to join them on politics and do what I do best. Also some new stuff. I made the decision this week.”
A bit awkwardly, it was only last week that O’Donnell had said of her guest stint on CBS This Morning “I told Erica Hill, who is letting me fill in for her, that I promised not to leave too many crumbs on her keyboard.” Reminded of this fact today, O’Donnell didn’t miss a beat. “Erica is fabulous, a total pro”, she said. “I’m a huge fan of hers, and I hope she stays with CBS.”
Fager was also asked during the session how CBS News has managed to avoid some of the embarrassing mistakes that have plagued its network competitors lately. “I’m not going to say we’re not going to make mistakes. We will make mistakes,” he insisted. “But we have instilled in our entire organization attention to accuracy and fairness. First is not as important, period. We don’t operate that way. I can’t speak
for the other organizations, all I can say is that I think it comes from real discipline and a real sense of what matters to our news organization which is original reporting and helping people better understand the story … I think there’s a risk in some ways that people take their eyes off the ball.” Added CBS News president David Rhodes: “The most important thing to us is to be accurate.” With regard to finding a replacement for the late Andy Rooney on 60 Minutes, Rhodes said he’s in no hurry, well aware of the pitfalls that would befall any replacement having to follow a legend. “We don’t have anyone in mind for that position,” he said. When asked if Jon Stewart might be a good choice, he replied, “If you have an inkling that Jon Stewart wants to do it, I’d be happy to talk to him.”
It was announced earlier in the session that the trial expansion of CBS’ Face The Nation to a full hour is permanent. The Sunday magazine show had been expanded from a half-hour to an hour in the spring for a 20-week trial. “Thanks to the support of viewers that have made it the Number 1 show on the stations that carried the expanded show, we’re able to announce that the broadcast is going to stay an hour into the fall,” Rhodes said, although not every CBS affiliate carries the expanded version. Separately the network also announced Anthony Mason is a new regular co-host with Rebecca Jarvis on the Saturday edition of CBS This Morning.


CBS is beginning to replace NBC as my network of choice when it comes to news. This Morning replaced Today awhile ago. Now I’m starting to prefer Face the Nation to Meet the Press. I’m still watching NBC Nightly News, and I like Brian Williams, but I’m not entirely pleased with all of their coverage. CBS’s new brand of news is far more intelligent and less pandering than NBC or ABC. If they keep doing what they’re doing and don’t submit to the temptation to pander to what they think viewers want, they just might start getting some more attention.
Completely agree with everything Dustin said. Also – I liked Erica yet I noticed Charlie and Norah made a great team when they worked together last week. Not crazy about Gayle – in my most humble opinion, she often seems like she’s winging everything, and it comes off as kind of sloppy??
GMA’s too fluffy but Today was the worst. And since the Ann Curry debacle, I would never watch that show again anyway.
I am having a huge problem with Gayle King. She appears to be in over her head. It’s too bad. Her silly comments are most tomes perdictable.Well, maybe because it’s just going to be silly.
I agree
Oh my what a mistake with Gayle King! I agree with other comments about her. Gayle King is out of her league, she comes across so unprepared almost saying “what am I doing here” Sorry Gayle you must go!
The reason for all this is that the people running the show at CBS are the same ones who were at Coca Cola and behind the failed plan to drop classic Coke. The CBS morning show is where good news people go to die.
Just Need to bring Eric Hill back. Nora does not bring much to the viewer.she does not connect . Don’t like her. Erica was good reporter and warm. You made a huge mistake when you brought Charlie and Gayle now you went worse and fired Erica. I don’t see you moving out of third place.
I couldn’t agree with this more! Think before you act!
Don’t need Norah’s interrogation technique on a morning news show.
Bring Erica back and try to salvage the show from Gayle’s ineptness. Erica’s interviewing skills far exceed Norah and Gayle. Multiple mistakes are not going to correct a bad problem.
AGREE!
I miss Erica Hill. Charlie is analytical, Gayle provides fluff, Erica provided warmth. Norah makes a great contribution to the news, but Erica provided a nice balance which is noticeably lacking now.
Agree. I have always watched CBS Morning Show but after bringing on O’Donnell that is not the case any longer.
Look at Erica’s bio. The best at everything she did/does. She’s so smart and cool the she never gets intimidated or looses her cool in any on air conversation.
I loved reading where it’s mentioned that they hope Erica Hill doesn’t leave CBS. What a farce. They get Norah to replace Erica for one week then all of a sudden, Erica is being replaced by Norah. Too bad CBS made such a bad decision. I think Erica is a great newswoman. I followed her on CNN with Anderson Cooper and then on CBS. Well I know what network I won’t be watching in the morning. Dirty, dirty trick. Wherever Erica ends up going, I only hope she is much more appreciated and gets the recognition she deserves. The problems CBS is having with their poor ratings isn’t or wasn’t the fault of Erica Hill. Too bad the powers that be can’t see that.
Couldn’t agree more. Erica Hill is a professional who deserves far better treatment and recognition. To remove her like that is beyond disgusting. I do not plan to watch CBS’ This Morning (or CBS evening news for that matter) again. This reflects awful judgement. I find Gayle King to be awful in her role. Charlie Rose is an old pro but he has become ‘ubiquitous’ on tv lately, between CBS, PBS and Bloomberg. Far too overexposed. Erica was the star of the group in my opinion, not to mention ‘senior’ member in terms of time spent on that program. If anyone deserved being ‘bumped’ it was Gayle King. I wish Erica Hill only the best.
I no longer watch Today because of the dynamics of Charlie, Erica, and Gayle.
Yes, Gay king wings it, but I like her enthusiasm, excitement, and even her interruptions that Erica was able to rein her in. I miss Erica Hill!
It Just is not the same!
Where in the world is Charlie Rose? Me thinks I smell a rat…his sensibility and professionalism are sorely being missed. Does anyone else think there is more to his absence than is being disclosed?
KEK
I completely agree. I have, however, already switched to CBS Evening News. I prefer hard news to fluff.
Another bad personnel decision. A good reporter does not always make a good anchor (see John King et al.). Norah O’Donnell is annoying in large doses. They can tweak this show all they want but it will remain deeply in third place.
Rebecca Jarvis is steel. Nora/ Charley the one to watch.
Easily number one if they drop a few ads.
Tim – right in. John King is awful as host. Reporter, he was cool.
Is Wolf Blitzee real?
This is tragedy. I really think CBS is making some bad decisions with their hosting decisions. You first get rid of an entire entertaining group, who made the new entertainging to look at and you bring in a new group of hosts with a new set for the faithful viewers to get used to and now, the ONE face that was familiar adn perfect, Erica Hill is gone. I think I will be moving to NBC, it’ clear that CBS is not listening to their veiwers
NBC is crap in the AM. Who knew Al Roker was a journalist..pffft.
I agree this is tragedy , time to switch to NBC! I loved watching Eric Hill, hope to see her on NBC!
I agree with Connie. I think Erica Hill was doing a great job and very professional in her interviewing abilities. I rate her as much better than Norah O’Donnell or Gayle King. I was tired of the NBC “dog and pony” show and after feeling comfortable with the new CBS This Morning format you go and screw up a good thing.
I love the CBS morning show. Charlie and Gail are a perfect fit. I tried of the Today show and Good morning america gave me syrup poisoning with those the constant smiling, And like the Today show those annoying Teen and Pre-teen singers. Speaking of annoying, that blond on that show, and I dont mean the closet weather man,really annoyed me, now they gave her a new show.Go figure…
Erica Hill and Charlie Rose were perfect way to start the day. O’Donnel is jarring with her loud laugh, and with no gravitas. Gayle King is almost too much as it is. Without Erica Hill poor Charlie Rose, surrounded by two women who belong on daytime talk show.
Second byjohnson’s comments!
ABC, CBS, NBC… all of their network news broadcasts are biased and suck.
Zoraida Sambolin and Anderson Cooper on CNN and Fox News programs (not their commentary shows) offer accurate, balanced reporting.
Erica Hill and Jeff Glor were perfect together, but someone started dressing Erica to make her look frumpy. Charlie Roooose is too impressed with himself. Who cares about Gayle King? I’ll stick with our local news and start my day earlier than by watching the network. Nora O’Donnell is just too much!!!
I’m pleased with the choice of Norah O’Donnell for the morning show. She has such a natural cadence to her voice, whereas Erica Hill had a predictable and annoying cadence. I am troubled by the pairing of Gayle King and her not so clever comments such as the repeating of phrases (like Oprah)with the consummate reporter Charlie Rose. I will keep watching the program, though, as Norah and Charlie are so professional. I fast-forward to keep from getting annoyed with Gayle King.
I could not disagree more with this and other comments. First Gail King is the one and only bright spot on the show. She alone is the only reason I even watch the show for news. Charlie needs to retire at lease from the morning show, he’s a drag to watch every day. Getting rid of Erica Hill was a bad move because Norah Odonnell is going to bring the morning show down over all. In fact I think she is a fake and would be a great fit with FOX news.
I agree with Mary L. completely, Charlie is arrogant & stuffy. Gail king well I dont know how she got this job, must have known someone. They got rid of Erica Hill fhe best one they had. Thats why I now mostly watch Fox.
Erica had to go. Gayle king gushes all over he place. Charlie and Norah will be informative. You
Need to put them together. What is this with this long desk? A
So you need someone to be lighthearted . What about Kelly?
I liked Erica Hill and feel it is somewhat tacky that she was fired shortly after returning from vacation. I also agree her wardrobe may have caused her to be viewed by boss less favorably. Gayle King has to go. She can’t or shouldn’t ride on Oprah’s coat tail at the expense of great reporters such as Erica Hill. Open your eyes CBS!
Was very disappointed to hear that Erica Hill was removed from the morning show. In my opinion she is very professional and allows guests to actually talk unlike Gayle King. CBS, make the right decision- bring Erica back show Gayle the door.
I was sad to see Chris go and now sad to see Erica go. Have you watched the other channels?
I cannot go back there.
I love Charlie Rose, he is respectable and Gayle is fun. I did not like Norahhh. We’ll see
I am disappointed with the loss of Erica Hill, and I do think the CBS emphasis on politics can be a bit much early in the morning. However, I prefer this type of news broadcast over the other morning shows. I will disagree with others who refer to Gayle King as riding Oprah’s coattails…. She was a highly accomplished anchor at a CBS affiliate in CT prior to leaving to work for Oprah, so her resume is extensive and impressive. Her contribution is to lighten up the often politically-heavy news broadcast with some entertainment news and she does an excellent job without having to turn to the sugary antics of other networks.
CBS got it wrong! I enjoyed Erica Hill and Rose-finally a morning news show I could watch except for King and Jarvis. I feel tension between Rose and King. I also like Jeff. Now I’ll jump between stations.
My biggest beef is not only with who hosts the show, but it is with all the changes. I loved the old crew from the 1st show, loved the 2nd crew, then loved the 3rd crew, however, enough is enough! If you want dedicated viewers quit changing the game and players ever 6 months or so. People’s lives are too hetic with change anyway, when I get up in the morning, I like to have my normal, daily routine at least until my key locks the door on the way out.
Bring Erica back! Worse move ever CBS. Erica was a solid force and much needed presence!
Alas the face is no more!
Please bring Erica back. I don’t like Gayle. Erica was good, need to replace Charlie.
Sorry Erica is gone. The one to go should have been Gayle K.
I enjoyed Chris too. Chris ,Erica , and Rebecca would be a great
team
I noticed that there was tention between Erica and Gayle. Felt Gayle was pushing Eric out of the job.
I think CBS has to do what it has to do. Love Gayle King and adore Charlie Rose. It is unfortunate that Erica Hill could not fill the shoes of what is needed to bring up the ratings. On the contrary of my reasoning, after having watched the Today Show for many many years, I now watch CBS news. The Today Show was not loyal to Ann Curry who performed for many many years. “out with the old in with the new” when they replaced her with Samantha Guthrie.
Women should be loyal to each other! Like how CBS presents professionalism and knowledge. Whomever decided to bring Gayle King in must have great business savvy!
CBC This Morning is in a different league than the other morning shows. It’s smart, interesting, and informative. Love the format and glad to do without the rockbands, cooking segments or national weathermen. Longer news segments and solid interviews are worth watching. I watched Today years ago, but tired of its drumbeat of “coming up next”, where the teases took up more time than the actual stories. Switched to ABC when Dianne Sawyer was the star and found GMA to be much more substantive at the time. Then when GMA changed things up after her departure and the show went hyper-active, I found CBS This Morning. Can’t get enough of Charlie Rose and love the dynamic between him and Norah O’Donnell. Gayle balances the triad with her playfulness without being too silly.
I am so disgusted about losing Erica Hill as I found her to be so believable and balanced in her reporting–something I didn’t find on ABC & NBC and certainly not from Charley or Gayle. I had been a fan of hers since her CNN days. Where did she go to? Erica’s replacement does not cut the mustard with me so don’t know what I will do–probably switch to NBC in spite of mess over there. Why did you have to fix something that wasn’t broken?
I agree Gayle K. has to go.I have watched CBS news for 30 years. I don’t won’t to wake up in the morning and see her on the TV much less her tell me the news. I don’t trust her she is not a news anker
Please do something about Gayle King. Is this the price we all have to pay for Oprah going on the David Letterman show?? If so, totally not worth it. Put Gayle on the Talk and leave the news to the professionals.