Luke Y. Thompson contributes to Deadline’s coverage of Comic-Con. This year’s event runs July 12-15.
Over the years, we’ve seen Comic-Con evolve from showing presentations not just for comic-book movies and sci-fi, but also horror, action, and fantasy. It’s gotten to the point where you can’t rule anything out – but the studios probably should, because not everything plays. Lionsgate last year had a free screening of The Devil’s Double that very few attended – it was a good movie, but superhero fans don’t necessarily want their escapism ruined by a hard-R movie about Uday Hussein trying to brutally murder one of his own body doubles.
Related: Quentin Tarantino, ‘Iron Man 3′, ‘The Hobbit’, ‘Pacific Rim’ Juice Comic-Con Saturday
On the opposite end of the spectrum, comedies are also a risky bet: Focus Features shelled out the big bucks four years ago for Hamlet 2, with “sexy Jesuses” roaming the convention floor and an open-bar rooftop party with premium liquor. But once you got past the Jesus sight gag, there was nothing else to grab interest. Tenacious D performed live to a standing-room only crowd in Hall H to support their movie, which flopped hard. Pineapple Express didn’t even fill Hall H. There were walkouts on that one. (The Twilight Saga is unique, bringing its own massive fanbase. Frankly, I’d love to see what would happen if Tyler Perry decided to come to Con one year. Maybe we’ll see, if the Alex Cross franchise takes off.)
Related: ‘Elysium’ Brings Jodie Foster To Comic-Con As Movies Rub Elbows With TV Series
On the other hand, you have the “we’ll try anything” low-budget movies that just want any exposure at all, whether it’s relevant or not. Last year’s Bellflower had a tenuous connection at best to genre fare – characters in the movie are obsessed with Mad Max – but the cars and cast came down anyway, and awareness was arguably increased. This year, the apocalypse comedy It’s A Disaster fits that slot. As yet undistributed, it stars Julia Stiles and David Cross, and may simply be looking for any kind of recognition that might help it sell.
The WTF movie that stands out this year to me, perhaps surprisingly to some, is Jackie Chan’s CZ12, a movie that seems primarily for the international market, with no U.S. Distribution and Kenny G of all people in a costarring role. The panel will do well simply because Chan is beloved; the movie is irrelevant. Straight, non-sci-fi action is also a hard sell. Expendables 2 gets by because it has the ’80s nostalgia cast to sell it.
Related: Arnold Coming To Comic-Con; Does This Make Schwarzenegger Officially Back?
Total Recall isn’t quite a WTF choice on paper. It only makes this category because it had such a large presence last year (trailers, animatics, full cast, actual cop car and robot props on display) that we don’t need to see anything else before seeing the movie, which is a remake to begin with. This is risking overkill, but it piggybacks a panel with the more-anticipated Looper and Elysium.
Sony’s After Earth is likewise the right material for Comic-Con, but a very unusual presentation, in an upstairs room with no stars attending. The director, M. Night Shyamalan, would be risking boos in this crowd for his much-derided recent track record that includes The Last Airbender (poor adaptation of acclaimed cartoon), The Happening (killer wind!), and Lady in the Water (where even to begin?). Had Will Smith come, though, it’d be a major player by default.
Still, Open Road’s End of Watch may be the most poorly chosen for a panel. Jake Gyllenhaal and Michael Pena in a South Central L.A. cop drama from David Ayer, writer of Training Day. It may well be fine for what it is, but people want escapism at this show, and a brutally realistic look at the mean streets of anywhere doesn’t fit the bill.
Surprisingly, no broad, ill-suited mainstream comedies have been positioned. Maybe the studios are learning.


If Alex Cross takes off?? HAHAHAHAHAHAHA Have you seen the trailer? It looks AWFUL!! Perry needs to stick to cross-dressing fat suit movies. He’s a terrible actor.
But Matthew Fox looks like an incredibly realistic insane psycho… but yeah the movie looks awful.
1. “Pineapple Express didn’t even fill Hall H. There were walkouts on that one”,yes, look how that movie turned out and is fondly remembered.
2. “Maybe we’ll see, if the Alex Cross franchise takes off”, or it takes off anyway.
3. Maybe, the surprise is that CZ12,is actually not irrelevant, if the audience gives it a chance.
4. No such thing is overkill, regarding Total Recall, if it adds a little extra to the box office then fine. It’s fair to say you can be excited for all three movies (Looper and Elysium).
5. Why would M. Night Shyamalan, risk boos, all the audience should care about is the present and After Earth might be received well.
6. End of Watch, no people want decent movies end off. So, if it’s brutally realistic then fine, it does fit the bill – called having choices.
Hopefully, people are more open-minded to see all, hence they go to Comic-Con in the first place.
Do you even know what Comic Con’s original premise even is? It’s not supposed to be a film festival, it’s supposed to be a comic book convention. For whatever reason Hollywood started catering to the nerds and have been killed in past years. Cowboys and Aliens anyone?
A “festival” took Hollywood money and jumped on the promo wagon?
Shocked.
In today’s day and age where “Internet Postings” matter, you can’t blame them for jumping on board. (The Studios.)
I used to live in San Diego, and in the late 1970s to early 1980s would go to Comic Con every year hoping for some information on up-coming movies, and there was basically nothing. Comic Con was never sold out back then so it was easy to get in. I don’t know when the big change occurred and it became a mecca for Hollywood, but ‘tvcon’ is right in that it was designs for comic book fans.
Hall H two years ago. During the session where they played trailers. The trailer for “Devil” comes on. As soon as M. Night’s name comes on the screen a majority of the crowd starts booing (very loud.)
This happened. I was there.
1. So what was the point of bringing Pineaple Express to ComiCon if it did fine at the box office without generating interest at ComiCon? It’s not about whether the movie is fondly remembered by some. It’s whether there’s a point in employing ComiCon as a part of its marketing strategy.
5. It’s not your place to tell people what they should or should not care about. A lot of people who attend Comicon are fans of Avatar: The Last Airbender and would jump at an opportunity to let Shyamalan know what they think about his big screen adaptation.
@mjrules, Have you ever gone to Comic Con or even know what it was (originally) designed for? “Why would M. Night Shyamalan, risk boos, all the audience should care about is the present and After Earth might be received well.” Huh? These fans are there for the new stuff and do not forget when you have desecrated a beloved story. And the rest of your list makes it sound like you may be confusing this comic book/genre projects/vid games/etc extravaganza with Cannes. Yes fans of all types, shapes and sizes want decent movies. However a police melodrama is a stretch for Comic Con.
Umm, THE HAPPENING is about killer plants, not killer wind, thankyouverymuch. Killer plants is much stupider/funnier.
When watching THE HAPPENING, I just like to pretend it’s Dirk Diggler in his first legitimate movie. It makes it way more fun to watch.
Will someone in Hollywood make everyone read this article before planning next years con? The rule of thumb should just because you could doesn’t mean that you should.
Luke is wrong he could not be more wrong he is obviously very very wrong. Don’t you know that anything that is shown at Comic Con is an instant blockbuster megahit franchise? Everything benefits from Comic Con. It doesn’t matter what it is if we show it at Comic Con we automatically get all the fan boys and everybody else. The Con is a license to print money. Endless streams of money as far as the eye can see. The more we spend on hype the more we make.
This is what we genuinely believe and we don’t want a know it all like you trying to change our minds. Stop rocking the boat. Your job is to help us hype every single movie or TV show we decide to show off at the Con. Do your job and we’ll let you live. Kapische?
“It doesn’t matter what it is if we show it at Comic Con we automatically get all the fan boys and everybody else. The Con is a license to print money. Endless streams of money as far as the eye can see.”
*whispers* Punisher War Zone?
Ha ha ha!!!
“Why would M. Night Shyamalan, risk boos, all the audience should care about is the present…”
tvcon is right…do you even know of what you’re writing? The folks who attend Comic Con typically have long memories. There are fans who still haven’t forgiven writers for plot twists and characterizations done 30 years ago. I know people who passionately debate storylines that were done before they were even born…and this is not atypical.
“Avatar: The Last Airbender” was a beloved animated television series turned into a much-hated movie that fans will tell you ruined nearly everything about the original premise. (The white-washing of the characters by casting white actors, as bad and insulting as it was, was just the tip of the iceberg.) If Shyamalan were to show up to Comic Con so soon after that movie, he wouldn’t just risk being booed. He’d risk being tarred and feathered.
The thing about the whole comic book community (fans, publishers, vendors, etc.) is that it’s filled with smart, fickle people. Sure, you got the socially-defective bunch, but we can see through the b.s., especially when there’s the Internet. Tvcon’s right about Comic-Con shouldn’t be a film festival, but it’s more like a high school reunion. Hollywood’s the hot girl that sees the comic book industry isn’t the spaz in the past, but a money (albeit not a lot of people read comic books when I first started) and idea-loaded jock. Sometimes, the girl “gets” the spaz. Other times….why the hell “Glee” at the Con some years ago? Why is there an “Alex Cross” panel at the upcoming one?
+1. Love the highschool reunion analogy.
Glee has a panel at Comic-Con this year too.
Talk about a WTF moment, it’s a bunch of people finding out that Castle did not even get an invite this year. They actually HAVE a comic book tie in on the show. There was an entire episode about it last year. Then tangential things like the zombie episode and guest stars from Firefly and Star Trek: Deep Space Nine (also new regular Penny Johnson Jerald)–there’s more the enough to justify a Castle panel. It’s always been pretty fun because that cast is a funny group. Nathan Fillion alone fills a room. Lots of people were pretty po’d because it felt like they waited til the last minute to tell everybody. At least he’s going to be on other panels.
ABC wanted to promote some of its newer stuff they said. Now we don’t get a hint about the season 5 opener after the pretty intense season 4 finale. The networks are just trying to use the slots to promote shows in general, not shows that fit Comic Con. The Glee panel shouldn’t be happening, and I watch the show.