EXCLUSIVE: Bonnie Eskenazi Of Greenberg Glusker filed the lawsuit this morning accusing Hallmark Hall Of Fame Productions and McGee Street Productions of usurping screenwriter, director, and producer Brad Wigor’s intellectual property rights for a Christmas TV story called The Night Flyer. Sure, a lot of people claim their project was stolen but few attract a pitbull litigator like Eskenazi who, for instance, has repped the estate of JR Tolkien among other clients against this kind of theft. And Wigor is a four-time Daytime Emmy nominee for Children’s Specials. This project in dispute was a family movie about a troubled teenage boy who lives in Los Angeles and meets an angel, then sprouts angelic wings himself, and after a few false starts ultimately uses his power for good during the Christmas season. Read the entire lawsuit here.
“For more than 60 years, defendant Hallmark Hall of Fame Productions has produced an anthology program on American television sponsored by Hallmark Cards, Inc., the well-known greeting card company. Whether due to changing tastes, evolving technology or both, recent years have not been kind to Hallmark,” the lawsuit alleges.
“Faced with declining viewership and languishing interest, Hallmark has become desperate for quality original content. Unfortunately, Hallmark has apparently decided it is more valuable to it to obtain ideas and copyrighted works by theft and deception rather than to develop and pay for truly original programming. In an effort to reverse its ailing fortune for the lowest cost possible, Hallmark and defendant McGee Street Productions Inc fraudulently lured plaintiff Wigor into submitting and developing his original idea into a television movie treatment and partial script for them over a period of months. Then, just weeks before the television movie was green-lit for pre-production, defendants refused to engage Wigor. Instead, defendants simply unilaterally misappropriated Wigor’s Work, using it as a basis for the television movie they planned all along. Even more reprehensibly, and in a devious attempt to cover their unlawful conduct, defendants scrambled to find an obscure literary work with some superficial similarities to Wigor’s Work so that they could pretend the Infringing Project was based on something other than Wigor’s Work. Defendants’ attempted deception is unavailing. It is clear that defendants stole Wigor’s Work for their family television movie without paying him, deliberately infringed his copyrights, and undertook production of Wigor’s movie as if it were their own.”
Related: Tolkien Trust, New Line, & Harper Collins Settle ‘Lord Of The Rings’ Lawsuit
Editor-in-Chief Nikki Finke - tip her here.


Writers are always getting screwed. How many times have writers been asked to do polishes, revisions, edits, etc. without pay but a promise of production, only to see those promises disappear? This has to stop.
Writers need to refuse work until there’s a contract. If every writer adopted this attitude, perhaps the producers would realize they can’t steal and/or get something for nothing.
the Hallmark channel – where you go when no one else will hire you for a D job-
what pressure if must be to behave badly – i guess everyone has a mortgage to pay
teach them a LESSON
@Anonymous: Hallmark Hall of Fame is not the same as The Hallmark Channel. Granted, they’re owned by the same corporate parent (Crown Media) but the HHoF films are made independently and air (now) on ABC; for years they aired on CBS. Also there are different executives in the mix. Don’t know the merits of the claim but it’s not fair to have the Channel in your gunsights– they have nothing to do w/HHoF.
This isn’t The Hallmark Channel. It’s Hallmark Hall of Fame. Two very different buyers.
It’s a well known trick to back your development into a piece of source material you find only after the fact. I can’t tell you how many times I have been instructed to do that when I was an assistant by very established producers. I’m talking about producers and execs who are house hold names in Hollywood. Not naming names, but I am thrilled to see some company is finally getting sued for this practice.
I read Brad’s treatment for this a long time ago…
Was this film ever made?
This reads like the very definition of “frivolous lawsuit”!
Just kidding.
I hope Brad Wigor and his counsel rip Hallmark a new one!
Surprised his agent is letting him do it. Am sure they begged and pleaded for him to not go after a “buyer”. God forbid an agent allow his client to actually stand up for himself and make someone obey the law. Would be interested to know how his agent reacted to this… or if he still has an agent.
Usually the agents advise their writers to lay down and get screwed– take it quietly. They threaten us with “you’ll never work in this town again.”
Crown Media doing something immoral? See my name.
I once sold a spec to a studio. At a key juncture they let me go, deciding to rewrite it for a younger audience. A few years later they released a movie that was a big hit for them. It was very close to my premise, only much younger. In the press, they claimed it was an idea that they had “developed internally. “