
Fox is resurrecting controversial reality series Someone’s Gotta Go. In 2009, the network drew protests when it filmed a pilot for the project, in which small companies struggling amid the recession let their employees decide who should be laid off. The Endemol USA-produced project did not go to series, but now it is — with some tweaks.
The series, which is nearing a four-episode order, won’t feature companies that have economic difficulties but dysfunctional ones whose employees still will be empowered to vote on who will terminated. In another twist to the original premise, the employees will have the opportunity to let someone go but they don’t have to. Thus the change in the title of the series to Does Someone Have To Go? Endemol USA is again producing.
Fox is in the process of scheduling the four-episode series, whose original incarnation Fox’s head of alternative programming Mike Darnell described as “Survivor meets The Office.” In the first go-around, the show’s premise drew criticism for being insensitive to the millions who have lost their jobs in recession-related layoffs.
TV Editor Nellie Andreeva - tip her here.


This is a rather sad commentary on the state of television. Between this awful idea of a show, the hoarders and honey boo boo, we are inching closer and closer to throwing real prisoners into the arena to fight tigers and lions. Sadly, I’m sure that would get better ratings than American Idol.
I got a better idea, throw Fox execs into a tank of hungry sharks. Ratings through the roof. The only trouble would be, no suspense,, everyone would root for the sharks.
Yeah, how much longer before The Hunger Games is real?
I totally agree, couldn’t of said it …wait, what? Prisoners battling lions and tigers? AWESOME. Darnell and the rest of the 4h floor will love this. Thanks! (I hope your not WGA)
How right you are, Michael J. While the world goes merrily along whistling in the dark, our venues of entertainment keep edging closer and closer to snuff movies and gladiator games in Madison Square Garden. Sad and scary indeed.
If you work at a company and your boss asks if you’d be interested in participating in this show, what exactly are you supposed to say? The mere suggestion brings pain and insecurity.
What an awful promise for a TV show. Its a window into the adversity of sadness in such a perverted way.
This sounds horrible. No more ideas in TVLand.
Like it’s not humiliating enough to be fired, so some dumb ass has the idea to make that fucking terrible experience into a show. Hope that you don’t meet God, cuz it ain’t gonna be pretty…
Fox is not seriously considering this?!?!? More train wreck TV. It would be nice to see some more scripted TV rather than more exploitative reality TV.
Sick
Still pretty disgusting. Did Mitt Romney dream this up?
The one they should let go is Mike Darnell and anyone else involved in launching this tin eared mess.
Sick, sad, world
It’s not just that Darnell is out of ideas, it’s Endemol’s inability to realize cohesion. A four episode order for a reality show? FAIL.
Please someone bring back Roman Sea Battles
In this economy… Fail.
Not since a cable channel famous for style green-lighted a “Homeless Makeovers” series — and then chickened out and red-lighted it — has such a corrosive idea for a TV show gone this far. What’s next, “Terminal Diagnosis” in which we watch medical patients get bad news from their doctors?
Fox could just throw some Christians in a ring with lions.
That would draw a crowd too.
Hum does the state of the world especially television remind us of something, thinks a moment, ya it does, I think it was called Sodom and Gomorrah, nah I must be messed up.
This is so bad on so many levels, so I think the person or persons who came up with this bad idea be voted out of his job by those who work with the genius pool that thought this up, oh now that idea I like.
It’s funny…was just watching a mockumentary movie today from 2007 with Eva Mendez about a game show where people play Russian Roulette and the survivors get 5 million dollars. They show clips of their life story before they pull the trigger.
I imagine this will be somewhat the same, except being a despicable and much more disgusting production, not being fiction. Stay classy, Fox.
“In another twist to the original premise, the employees will have the opportunity to let someone go but they don’t have to.”
So what’s at stake?
Absolutely disgusting. What kind of person do you have to be to greenlight / invent / work on this crap?
Fox should lead by example and set the first episode at their own network. Nothing more dysfunctional than a former market leader in a downward spiral.
Perhaps they could figure out who is responsible for Terra Nova, Alcatraz, Touch, Mob Doctor, X Factor, Breaking In, The Finder, I Hate My Teenage Daughter and this POS.
Sounds like the goings on at NBC and HBO, only they’re not filming it.
This is the same network that green-lighted Married by America and The Swan. Tacky is assumed when dealing with FOX programming.
I’d love to say this idea surprises me……………but it kinda doesn’t.
There is NO bottom to the sewer that Reality TV will descend through for an attempt at a show. None at all.
Having worked at two highly dysfunctional companies, one a small biz and one a giant media conglomerate, there is usu. no mystery as to the source of the dysfunction. Sometimes, yeah, it is a bad business model. As often as not though it is a person or group of people who are sinking the ship. And the thing is, everyone else knows who the deadwood is.
As unwelcome as the truth may be, the truth is that some people do deserve to be fired, because they are non-contributors, or they are sub-par performers, or they are stink-stirrers and morale killers, or they are backstabbing dishonest weasels. No business can afford to carry more than a very small percentage of these types, and jettisoning them from the payroll is a necessity for the health of the business and therefore one of the primary duties of the business owner/manager.
Where the line should be drawn (but isn’t) is making a public spectacle out of this unwelcome truth. There is so much fear, anger, humiliation, pain and bitterness surrounding the loss of a job (not to mention the difficult act of looking someone in the face and telling them that they are being let go), that it’s just better to not go there, period, for exploitation purposes (the suspense/competition aspect of a reality show, as opposed to a serious documentary).
Yes, the deadwood people need to be fired. But there’s no need to do the equivalent of a frat hazing by putting the entire thing on camera & broadcasting it to the entire country.
This is the worst, most horrible, insensitive, disgusting, idea for a television show I have ever heard. Whoever dreamed this up should be drummed out of the business.
oh…. my… gosh… This is it.. this is the show.
Our office was just in a frenzy because our boss was pushing us to sign a contract for a TV show produced by Endemol for the Fox Network called, “Office Life”. We weren’t allowed to know the premise of the show at all, other than we will be presented with tasks by the network to perform on national television (we weren’t allowed to know what the tasks were). They kept referring to it as a “social experiment,” to see how we interact with each other regarding the tasks we were given. Our office is incredibly dysfunctional… the reason they even reached out to us is because on of our own clients nominated us through her media people.
But so many of us didn’t feel good about it. Our office is so small that if a few people didn’t sign the contract then they couldn’t use us. That’s exactly what happened… I’m floored right now. This HAS to be the show.
They film in December and it airs in March. I will be watching out for promotions because I am certain I’m right about this….