The Walt Disney Company has called Stan Lee Media’s multibillion-dollar lawsuit “flawed beyond cure.” In a motion to dismiss (read it here) filed last week, the company mocks SLMI’s legal claims that it actually owns rights to all the Marvel characters created by Stan Lee. “There is no conceivable basis on which Plaintiff can state a viable copyright claim against TWDC in this Court, or for that matter, any other,” the Disney motion says. “In sum, against the backdrop of Plaintiff’s six prior unsuccessful litigations on this topic, express judicial displeasure with Plaintiff clogging the courts with a repeated invocation of rights it does not possess, and the fact that TWDC conducts no business activities other than those of a holding company, this lawsuit is completely frivolous and should be dismissed,” Disney added. SLMI wants the profits from the $5.5 billion it says that Disney made from Marvel superhero movies and merchandise based on characters created by Lee, who no longer has anything to do with the company. The November 30 motion to dismiss, like the initial suit by SLMI in October, was filed in Colorado.
SLMI claimed that Lee signed over rights to characters like Iron Man, the Hulk, the Fantastic Four, the X-Men, Spider-Man and many more that he created or would create to its corporate predecessor in October 1998. Because Marvel never bought rights to those characters, Disney never got to own them when it bought Marvel for $4 billion in 2009. Disney is represented by James Quinn, R. Bruce Rich and Randi W. Singer of New York’s Weil Gotshal & Manges and Frederick J. Baumann and Holly Ludwig of Denver firm Rothgerber Johnson & Lyons.
Deadline's Dominic Patten - tip him here.


“…the fact that TWDC conducts no business activities other than those of a holding company…”
Disney holds all the strings, holds all the cash, holds all the cards, holds all the keys to the kingdom–they’re just a holding company.
Stan Lee is the cousin-in-law of Marvel co-founder Martin Goodman and he was not just part of but the *head of* the editorial staff — the *managerial* staff — of Marvel (then called Timely) for virtually his entire career.
Not to oversimplify this, but because Stan Lee was a salaried editorial employee, the chief editorial officer of Marvel, virtually everything he ever did for Marvel was by definition 110% work-for-hire. So why these lawsuits over the work he did for Marvel aren’t laughed out of court via summary judgment on the day they’re filed is beyond me. Because he was never in any position to own even one iota of a percentage of any of the characters he co-created.
Actually, Goodman was Stan’s 2nd Cousin, by his mother.
Here go again. The company that Stan Lee don’t own anymore.Disney/Marvel comics got a hit movies and the wolf is coming after the money. We the fan will be paid the cost. I see another long lawsuit where no one will win.
I’m guessing Mr. Lee doesn’t have much standing here but it is remarkable that the business lords over these properties so righteously when it wasn’t so long ago that it openly hated them. All the execs getting rich off these things acting like they have more to do with them existing than Lee is laughable, even if Lee is ultimately wrong with his claim. Watching some MBA chastise Lee for simply being “work for hire” when talking about Marvel’s lifeblood doesn’t jive with reality either. I guess Lee is going to end up in line with the many artists he collaborated with or similarly claimed credit from by the end. As a fan I love the movies but as a reader from way back it sure feels bittersweet sometimes.
Again, Stan Lee no longer is involved in Stan Lee media – that’s an article in itself!
Marvel continues to pay Stan 1 million dollars a year. I’m not saying he shouldn’t get more, but it is doubtful he has a legal leg to stand on in this lawsuit.
It is stagering to think, however, that if he wrote his tomes today, J.K. Rawlings would be borrowing money from Stan. He is to this day, the most popular, and probably read, writer ever on the planet. At last count, his 1960′s Spiderman comics have been translated into over 35 languages.
“At last count…” by who? He’s popular, but this kind of bogus circulation claim reeks of self-promotion. And, FWIW, J.K. Rowling is a she, not a he. So, all in all, “Ron” remains ignorant and uninformed.