UPDATE, 2: 48 PM: Dish Network CEO Joe Clayton weighs in on the award, and twists the knife into CBS. He says that he appreciates International CES’ “decision to stand with the consumer” by granting the “Best of Show” award to the Hopper With Sling DVR. And he adds that he looks forward to “continuing our longstanding relationship with CNET’s editorial staff and hope they are able return to their long tradition of unbiased evaluation and commentary of the industry’s products and services.”
PREVIOUS, 11:20 AM: Here’s yet more embarrassment for CBS from its heavy-handed decision to bar its tech site CNET from giving the Internatonal CES “Best of Show” award to Dish Network’s Hopper With Sling DVR. CBS said the news site’s editors — who designate the CES award winners — couldn’t recognize the Hopper because broadcasters are suing Dish, alleging that the Hopper’s ability to automatically zip past ads on recorded shows violates their copyrights. But today the trade show gave the award to the Hopper anyway, making it a co-winner with the Razer Edge gaming tablet. (CNET editors made that the winner after CBS forced them to take the Hopper off their list.) “The CNET editorial team identified the Hopper Sling as the most innovative product of the show, and we couldn’t agree more,” says Karen Chupka, who’s the Consumer Electronics Association’s SVP for events and conferences. What’s more, the group says it will look for a new partner to replace CNET in running the annual awards. CBS’ corporate policy could “have a negative impact on our brand,” Chupka says.
The trade group has filed an amicus brief supporting Dish in the court battle with broadcasters, “We are shocked that the ‘Tiffany’ network which is known for its high journalistic standards would bar all its reporters from favorably describing classes of technology the network does not like,” CEA chief Gary Shapiro says “The simple fact is making television easier to watch is not against the law. It is simply pro-innovation and pro-consumer.” CNET lost one of its top reporters as a result of CBS’ editorial interferrence. Dish has also used the controversy to promote the Hopper.


Kids are always going to disobey their parents, what are you gonna do? Bravo CNET!
too bad the “HOPPER” can’t jump past cbs,nbc,abc,cnn, msnbc, and the rest of the left wing communist news shows everytime they tell a lie. that might not work;because, if the “HOPPER” did that there wouldn’t have liberal news shows.
I DVR everything I want to watch and skip through the commercials anyways, so CBS is fighting a losing battle.
Everybody I know who still watches network television does the same thing. It feels like “stealing” yet no one but the networks appears to call it that. What will they do about it? They have to make a buck and they do that with advertising. Something’s gotta give!
I too DVR everything but I am not beyond watching a interesting commercials, sometimes twice…
So if we don’t protect televisions broadcast networks in this battle against the hopper you guys are going to end up with banner advertising across your screen… Someone has to pay for this stuff to be produced… I personally think that they should never have allowed ff through commercials it all should protected…
LOL…he…he! I’m guessing that CBS CEO Lester Moonves is about now raising a posse/lynch mob of his beloved ADVERTISERS to storm the Bastille…er. Dish TV/Echostar HQ and behead King Charlie (Ergen)! ;-D
Arriasmom? What planet are you from? Broadcast TV and Les Moonves are as relevant as the Nielsen Ratings system that holds them up. They are done and they know it. They will talk the talk. Walk the walk for their investors but they are like a land line in our homes. Rarely ever used.
You can’t force people to watch adverts and you can’t silence journalists, NO ONE WATCHES ADVERTS any more. Even if Nielsen backed data says otherwise.
Here’s what will happen. Les Moonves will demand advertisers pay for plus seven and Nielsen will claim 99 percent of their 16,000 viewers watch shows with in seven days. Which is bullshit. And Ads exec’s will never play plus seven and like us don’t watch their own ads on TV.
Over the next few months ad revenue will shift out of Networks and into targeted new media to the tune of 48 percent over last year. This is the last year CBS will see major ad revenue. It’s gone.
Dish will win the law suit and Direct TV will merge with Dish. RENTRACK will monitor the second by second behavior of over 50 million viewers and give advertisers real ROI. And then the system will change in favor of the content creators and there will be more than enough cash to go around.
Interesting take, Jake, your prognostication of ratings flight from Nielsen to Rentrack is an intriguing perspective…possibly even for content creators and advertisers, but probably not so much for the major distributors (broadcast networks and their local affiliates)!
I’m thinking this news about CES, the protracted litigation all of the broadcast nets/media congloms are backing regarding “alleged” copyright infringement against Dish/Echostar and the growing use of auto-hoppers and DVRs is putting a major DENT into Moonves’ party spirit planned Super Bowl gala with New England Patriots owner Bob Kraft and the NFL franchise/league domos. This could be nearing an end of era for the Eye Network and the other major broadcast nets — as they can expect further viewer and advertiser migration due to the DVR/Hopper paradigm growing in negative push-back to broadcast.
If things get much worse for the nets (and if they LOSE that copyright infringement suit/injunction against Dish’s Hopper), I’m thinking Moonves might want to pare back his industry-leading $60 million-plus in salary and bonuses (in 2011) — because revenues and ratings decline could soon translate to stock value declines for CBS’s traditional “advertiser-supported” dominated business model. Not good days ahead for the broadcast nets, to put it mildly.
There’s nothing wrong with advertiser supportive content – it’s the amount of commercials and ones with no relevence to me as a consumer.
I’d watch commercials if they were advertsing products I’d be interested in – this is 2013, not 1953 – One size does not fit all.
Freedom of speech is also the right NOT to listen to content not of my interest.
What will the networks say about other commercial skipping services like commercialbreak.com ?
Hello, as much as I hate commercials we need them to pay for our shows. What part of making money do you not understand? Dish needs to obey programming needs. Besides any more people cancel their land based TV services for satellite and say goodbye to more jobs America. Just sayin’