Ray Richmond is contributing to Deadline’s TCA coverage.
Reality TV megaproducer Mark Burnett may have caused a few eyes to widen this morning during a TCA panel promoting the new midseason CBS business competition series The Job (premiering February 8th) when he said at the outset of the discussion that the series “proves a kinder approach on television does work.” This, from the man who helped to pioneer the reality competition genre with the cutthroat Survivor, which launches its astonishing 26th cycle this year. “No one’s ripped down” in The Job, Burnett went on. “America doesn’t want to see people ripped down.” The Job gives candidates from around the country a chance to win positions at top companies. Hosted by Lisa Ling, each episode features a handful of candidates who endure several rounds of elimination challenges before a panel of executives while competing for their dream job. After the panel, Burnett was asked to elaborate on his “kinder, gentler” declaration and he maintained that the bigger point he was trying to make was that shows designed to make people look foolish — as American Idol helped turn into an art form — are simply no longer in vogue and helps explain the big
success of programs like The Voice and Shark Tank. “I just don’t think that watching public humiliation is cool (anymore),” Burnett stressed. “In the past it worked very well, but there’s a wave of change. Humiliating people seems spiteful. And I think The Voice proved by being the Number 1 music show in America that you don’t have to do that. You can make good TV without that. The Job is great TV without making anybody look bad.” He also disagreed that Survivor is at its core a nasty show, despite its backstabbing and scheming alliances. “The whole premise is is that you get a million dollars if people want to give it to you. So if you screw people over relentlessly, you won’t get the million.”
Related: ‘Golden Boy’s Theo James, Chi McBride On CBS Show’s Evolution
Burnett also discussed his history with his fellow exec producer on The Job, Michael Davies, who produced Who Wants to Be a Millionaire? and famously rejected Survivor before it was picked up by CBS while he was in charge of ABC’s alternative programming. “Michael thought that only one million-dollar prize would work on television,” he said. “But we’ve stayed friends.” After the panel, he also addressed how he’s managed to remain on top as a reality producer since hitting the big time in 2000 with Survivor. Basically, he said, he’d good at figuring out how to work with good, smart people rather than fools. Burnett works to avoid the ignorant and the dangerous “because they don’t know what they don’t know. And when given the gift of primetime television, you have to treat every hour like it’s a hundred-million-dollar movie. When you (partner) with people who know what they’re doing, there’s a higher likelihood of success.” He also figures that’s why producers like he and Davies keep getting hired over and over. “Networks are nervous,” he emphasized, “and like to get insurance policies.” Burnett briefly addressed his own favorite shows as well. They include Dancing with the Stars, Extreme Makeover, Homeland, Game of Thrones, Big Bang Theory and How I Met Your Mother.


“I just don’t think that watching public humiliation is cool (anymore),” Burnett stressed. “In the past it worked very well, but there’s a wave of change. Humiliating people seems spiteful.”
TWO.THUMBS.WAY.UP.
over and out.
Can’t imagine why CbS approved Lisa Ling and didn’t go after Ty Pennington. He would have been perfect for this show. Lisa is not aspirational or warm.
Dear Mark,
Humiliating people on national tv – which could destroy their lives and cost major embarassment and consequences was never cool — even if it did make you a multi millionaire
Thats what people hate about Hollywood – everythings about the almighty dollar and you can step on as many people, lie, c heat and steal to do that.
I worked on a major national TV show and was just totally shocked at what executives did, their lies, their lack of respect for anyone under them – it was a huge change from my corporate world experience
This show is just plain stupid based on the concept alone and the timeslot it’s on won’t help it either. Gone after 2 episodes like “3″ was a year ago.
I can’t even watch survivor it’s so disgusting to watch humans acting like animals, endorsing the worst vile traits centuries of socialization have tried to remove from society. Made into a game show. Perverts.
It’s a game. Do you feel the same way about baseball or football? In those sports, each team tries to deceive the other through a variety of means: playbooks, trick plays, misdirection, etc.
A baseball catcher will signal to the pitcher what to throw, concealing this information from the opposing players. A quarterback will call plays and try to confuse the other team. A third base coach will use hand signals to let a player what to swing at. These and other sports have ENCOURAGED deception for a long, LONG time. To say that socialization has tried to remove these traits for centuries is patently absurd.
Survivor is no different than these sports in the way players attempt to deceive their opponents in order to win. Elevating Survivor to some different, slimy social level is ludicrous and naive.
Thank you Mr Burnett!! I feel that wave. Working in TV you also get the sense crew is tired of making shows in which people are nasty to each other. Postive shows can do well. The public loves hope. Extreme home makeover anyone?!?
To wicked: you mean naive as in chasing a ball back and forth.
One of the definitions of bullying is humiliation; the shark tank suckers venturists in when the intention is to exploit them for the sharks own benefit. No benefit no deal. No one cares about that slime ethics. Bullying.