Ray Richmond is contributing to Deadline’s TCA coverage.
With the stepping down of creator and original Smash showrunner Theresa Rebeck last April, the question ever since has been how season 2 of the NBC musical drama might differ — if at all — under new showrunner Joshua Safran. A few answers emerged this afternoon during a TCA session promoting the show’s sophomore campaign. Specifically, Safran plans, well, more of the same, just bigger and perhaps a little bit younger. “I had the great luxury to be an audience member through the first season,” he said. “As for changes, well, I don’t think it’s changed that much. The stuff you loved from last year is still there. Maybe
there’s more music and maybe younger in regard to some cast members.” Returning to the show from the first season are Megan Hilty, Katharine McPhee, Debra Messing and Anjelica Huston. But they’re being joined by plenty of new faces, among them Jennifer Hudson (who appears in three of the first four episodes of season 2) as well as cameos from real-life Broadway vets including Bernadette Peters and Liza Minnelli. Safran also confirmed that, in terms of the original music increasing, there will be more than one new original song per episode as well as a greater number of musical sequences. “I kind of wanted to represent the bigger theatrical worldview on the show this season,” Safran added.
Related: ‘Grimm’ Producers Consider What Makes A “Breakout Hit” And The Friday Night Curse: TCA
But Safran was reluctant to bash the show under the previous showrunner administration or really even to offer specifics of what he believes wasn’t working before he arrived. It was left to exec producer Neil Meron to address it — sort of. Referring to tweets about Smash that were less than kind during the first season and whether or not he agreed with them, Meron admitted only that “certain storylines were pinpointed where you could say, yes, they could have been a little bit moire impactful.” He also acknowledged “the show is still in the process of finding itself. It’s a lot of moving parts. It’s all about taking all of the moments that work and leaving it to Josh to keep things consistent in season 2.” Watch the trailer:
NBC Sets Oklahoma Tornado Benefit Concert For May 29


let’s hope they stop letting Angelica Huston embarrass herself and stop listening to Neil Meron. what a moron. he’d be nowhere without Craig
Smash needs better writers.
I am really excited for season 2. I’m a Broadway show/musical theater junkie and “Smash” is exactly everything I hoped it would be. Can’t wait for Jennifer Hudson.
I’m bummed to hear there will be more popular music. I think, for the most part, the show did better with new songs(save for Megan Hilty’s “I’m Going Down”…)…but we’ll see.
Aret they sticking with the tired Katharine McPhee vs Megan Hilty idea? The problem is – there’s no contest. McPhee can sing but lacks the star power to be a Broadway star or heck even a TV show star. Nobody who saw those two auditioning for real would ever pick McPhee over Hilty, who actually IS a real life Broadway star, so no great surprise that she’s obviously better at it.
So the central drama comes off as implausible. Without that core working, nothing else can save the show. They destroyed the show from the start, when they miscast McPhee.
so true re: McPhee. She looks totally ridic as Marilyn. And that Bollywood bit she did? Painful to look at.
As for Safran – he did drive Gossip Girl against the wall. Some of his producer’s previews explained his erroneous assumptions re: what the audience wants/thinks/is concerned about. So why should he of all people now have all the answers? Just because he ruined a show geared toward teens?
Whenever someone talks about guest stars, we are reminded of GLEE and some other shows suffering from guest star-itis (Kristin Chenoweth anyone?).
Going younger, as in GLEE season 1? Yeah, sure, that’s the answer to every problem, right? Because young adults simply can’t manage to get interested in chars that are not their own age, but a few lousy years older. How does Ian Somerhalder pull it off? Or 36 year old Alexander Skarsgard? Hit-Show ARROWS’s lead actor is also already 32 – older than McPhee and the same age as Hilty.
Despite its meandering faults (that adoption-idiocy, for instance) I did like SMASH. Not really looking forward to see Safran’s “great” changes… This show needs a few tweaks, that’s all.
Get some good writers and let them work their magic….
Jeremy Jordan is a musical force of nature. If this season can actually put together some cohesive story lines with people we care about and not engage in too much stunt casting, they might make it to season 3.
We get to see that you can find actors who can really sing. You should watch and learn Mr. Crowe!
Completely agree. Time and time again the director would comment McPhee is better than Megan on the how, and the viewer cNt help but think “you’re insane”. I like McPhee but this storyline just doesn’t jive with her talent level.
Waiddaminute. Christian Borle won’t be back? He’s one of the best things in the show!
WTF?! How is this show still on the air?!
Honestly I have never run into ANYONE on either coast who watches
it.
I love the show and only watch it to hear McPhee sing. Megan has a nice voice, but that is all. As far a acting, none are award winners to me. I do not think Jennifer is going to do anything for the show, could have left her off.
SMASH. I love it. The innocence in McPhee’s charcterization of M.M. makes me smile. It’s sincere even if she’s not a great actress. Hilty played M.M. just a bit over the top too polished and too Broadwayesque. I liked the vulnerability and lack of drama queen I.D. in MCPHEE’s M.M. I watch it, repeat episodes that capture a humanity and genius in handling the press M.M. enjoyed for decades. We cared about her, believed in her. Hilty didn’t bring that sympathy to it, but she had brass balls. first season. Itching for season 2.