UPDATE, 12:38 PM: Hours after being detained at LAX last night, Oscar nominated director Emad Burnat has now spoken out for himself about what happened. “Ours was a very minor example of what my people face every day,” the Palestinian filmmaker says of his and his family’s experience with U.S. Customs officials Tuesday night. Fellow documentarian Michael Moore took to Twitter in protest last night after the director texted him when officials took the filmmaker, his wife and son into a holding area to find out why they were entering the country. Burnat, who is up for an Academy Award this weekend for his co-directing efforts on 5 Broken Cameras, was threatened with being refused entry but eventually allowed into the U.S. after being held for an hour and a half. Read his full statement on what happened here.
Los Angeles, CA – February 20, 2013 - “Last night, on my way from Turkey to Los Angeles, CA, my family and I were held at US immigration for about an hour and questioned about the purpose of my visit to the United States. Immigration officials asked for proof that I was nominated for an Academy Award® for the documentary 5 BROKEN CAMERAS and they told me that if I couldn’t prove the reason for my visit, my wife Soraya, my son Gibreel and I would be sent back to Turkey on the same day. After 40 minutes of questions and answers, Gibreel asked me why we were still waiting in that small room. I simply told him the truth: ‘Maybe we’ll have to go back.’ I could see his heart sink. Although this was an unpleasant experience, this is a daily occurrence for Palestinians, every single day, throughout he West Bank. There are more than 500 Israeli checkpoints, roadblocks, and other barriers to movement across our land, and not a single one of us has been spared the experience that my family and I experienced yesterday. Ours was a very minor example of what my people face every day.” — Emad Burnat, Co-Director of 5 BROKEN CAMERAS
PREVIOUSLY, 10:01 PM: Michael Moore took on U.S. Customs last night and helped get a fellow filmmaker into the country for Sunday’s Oscars. The Academy Award winning documentarian went on a Twitter tirade late Tuesday as Oscar nominated director Emad Burnat was detained along with his family by officials when he arrived at LAX from Turkey. “This all just happened tonight, a few hours ago. He was certain they were going to deport him. But not if I had anything to do about it,” Moore wrote. This is not the first time Burnat, the co-director of the Sundance winning doc 5 Broken Cameras, has been in America. This time he was
arriving for this weekend’s Oscar ceremony when customs hauled him, his wife and their 8-year old son in for questioning on why he was in the States. “Although he produced the Oscar invite nominees receive, that wasn’t good enough & he was threatened with being sent back to Palestine,” tweeted Moore, who is a governor on the Academy’s Documentary branch. Burnet had texted Moore soon after being placed in the holding area. “I called Academy officials who called lawyers. I told Emad to give the officers my phone # and to say my name a couple of times,” added Moore last night. “After 1.5 hrs, they decided to release him & his family & told him he could stay in LA for the week & go to the Oscars. Welcome to America,” the Fahrenheit 911 director said. An insider tells me that the Academy had nothing to do with getting Burnat released from customs. “He was out before anyone had a chance to do anything,” they said. For Burnat, the welcome reminded him of home according to Moore. ‘It’s nothing I’m not already used to,’ he told me later. ‘When u live under occupation, with no rights, this is a daily occurrence,’ “ Moore said online Burnat said to him after leaving LAX. Contacted by Deadline, U.S. Customs and Immigration said they had no comment on the incident. A former farmer, Burnat is the first Palestinian ever nominated for an Oscar for a documentary. The movie he and Israeli filmmaker Guy Davidi made details the tension and protests between Palestinians in the West Bank village of Bilin, the Israeli military and a nearby settlement.
Deadline's Dominic Patten - tip him here.


“Although he produced the Oscar invite nominees receive, that wasn’t good enough & he was threatened with being sent back to Palestine,” Palestine? There is no such country. Moore should get his facts straight.
Dude has an invite to the fucking Academy Awards after filming the doc for 5 years and is gonna get deported. Moore did the right thing
Of course Moore did. But, your claim that he was going to be deported is conjecture.
Less Moore, please.
Oh dear, how embarrassing. Hope Emad doesn’t get the impression we Americans are as bigoted as Israelis, or are we?
I believe that all humans are prejudiced, it’s how we behave that defines us.
Another example of how America’s border protection is broken. This would be an easy problem to avoid. Is there no office someone can call when entering the country to make arrangements? “Hello, I’m Palestinian and am going to the Oscars. Email me a form to fill out and I will meet with someone when I land.” Easy (though more expensive and creates more red tape). If we take steps to know who is OK to enter the country, we can better identify those who do should not.
He produced an Oscar invitation, which wasn’t good enough. You don’t say? It’s not like LAX sees 100s of Oscar invitations daily. They, of course, had to verify the guy was who he said he was.
He was held for 1 1/2 hours while they confirmed his ID, he wasn’t shipped off to Gitmo.
Moore acting like he, alone, sprung a guy from the clutches of the government is laughable.
And your implying that you would find acceptable and routine being made to wait ninety minutes with your frightened family while your ID was verified is equally laughable.
And you’re implying that the ID the foreign national produced was as easily verified as a California issued Driver’s License or US issued Passport.
You mean like his…passport????? I highly doubt he tried to enter the country his Oscar invite alone and no ID.
Moore might well be a blowhard, but his heart’s in the right place.
Not that you’re not right sd, but I think Moore just sits around hoping something comes up that he can be undignified about so he can spring to action.
Not to pile on, but he did have advance notice about his travel plans?
So he had time to get his paperwork in order?
And really, how much training have the LAX TSA officials had concerning Palestinians? Excuse me, displaced Egyptians and Libyans, since there is no Palestine.
He did get his paperwork in place, it is call a US Visa. He and his family would have been issued a visa after submitting the relevant paperwork (and God knows it is a great deal of paperwork.)
Perhaps you are too provincial to know this, but you cannot get on flight to the US (or anywhere else) without proper paperwork. If he, and his family, did not have a valid US Visa, he would not be allowed on the flight, etc. Having said, having a proper US Visa does not prevent you from being asked questions etc.
And even if there is no Palestinian state (although many countries would say there is, even if the US does not) does not prevent him from being identified as a Palestinian.
Just because a Turkish airline representative takes a look at a visa and says it’s valid doesn’t make it so.
None. TSA is responsible for security when entering the boarding area of an airport and for screening luggage. CBP (Customs and Border Protection) determines who does and does not have valid credentials for entering the country. Say what you will about the latter, they serve a significantly more important purpose than the former, whose only use is getting people off welfare and badgering the traveling public. Stepping off soap box now…
Unfortunately, WE ALL LIVE IN A WORLD where certain religious groups will kill someone for publishing a harmless cartoon, stone a woman to death FOR HER CRIME of being raped and there are governments who send drone aircraft equipped with bombs into other lands. This poor fellow was detained at a customs office. I have been detained. Others have been detained and will be in the future. This is the world we live in.
Agree with you Jeff2000 and agree with you Pete. It IS the world we live in and while we have to protect ourselves, this could have been handled a little better. I can only imagine the bumbling idiots that were the TSA agents handling this situation. Embarrassing all around.
He was detained 90 minutes?
Hell, I’ve waited longer than that at the airport and I’m American.
Disgraceful. How many people remember Vanessa Redgrave’s impassioned speech at the Oscars in 1977 or 1978 when she won for Best Supporting Actress and she spoke out for the rights of Palestinians? The audience was outraged and they booed her off the stage but what she said was right and it was accurate. Here we are 35 years later and the same problems are worse now.
You know, I usually agree with Michael Moore’s views, but wasn’t Fahrenheit 911 all about how much our security used to suck, how terrorists from hostile nations were able to come and go freely to this country because our airport security was sold to the lowest bidder, and because our government agencies were asleep at the wheel. And now because a Palestinian man and his family are detained for 90 mins (average DMV wait) Michael Moore is up in arms about overreaching security at airports?!?
I’m astonished that the Academy doesn’t have people on the payroll whose job it is to ensure shit like this doesn’t happen. Now they look like morons along with Customs (who we all expect to be morons).
It’s not like he’s Joe Schmoe from Bumfuckistan. Even I’ve seen his movie, and I hardly ever watch those furrin movies ha ha.
Christ, I’ve been detained entering Canada when trying to work on a film, and I’m as white as snow. No one died, he was detained while they verified who he was. Moore lives to be outraged and bash America. Lighten up, Francis. I’ve waited longer at the doctor’s office. Maybe I should have screamed “I know Michael Moore!”
Sam: thank you for making me laugh with your incredibly funny (and insightful) post. Cheers.
Judging by the recent headlines, it seems like the American population is the most violent population in any developed country. There have been shooting sprees left and right. What does the country do? They instead come close to deporting true artists and filmmakers just because of the region of the world they come from. It is really shameful that this still is going on. Does not matter if he is Palestinian or Jamaican, this country is just in a state of shambles and shows no signs of reversing that direction.
I’ve never been nominated for an Oscar, or any award actually. But like Emad, I’m a filmmaker and not an American citizen. I’m Canadian, white, and have no criminal background (I’ve never even gotten a speeding ticket). Yet when I try to enter the United States, I experience a lot of the same hostility that Emad experienced.
I know the United States has its problems with its Southern Border, and with no help from Middle East radicals, your guards definitely should be up. But all in all, perfectly peaceful and law-abiding people who just want to visit or work in the United States and pay their fare share, still get treated like criminals by your immigration officials. I’ve dealt with American Immigration Lawyers who work in the entertainment industry, and I’ve heard a lot of horror stories by how even well-known non-American artists are treated in the same fashion.
I also had the opportunity to meet a Homeland Security officer at a dinner function a few years ago, and he told me that the INS has just as much power as the CIA. If they don’t want you in the United States, or think that you’re a possible threat, you will disappear.
As a filmmaker who has multiple projects set-up at different studios and production companies, and I do 95% of my business with LA people, I still cannot live in the U.S. for more than six months (that is the maximum a Canadian can stay in the United States without a 2-5 year Visa). I even with my lawyer, agent and business deals that I have, I still get harassed every single time by customs agents.
The facts are there, the U.S. Immigration and Border Security needs to be reformed. It’s too harsh on the innocent.
Michael Moore did a great favor and brought attention to what was goin on like he always does. We need 1000 more of him.
Just another example of bad apples spoiling it for everyone else. One might understand the delay better (about an hour according to the director’s published quote) by considering that the flight arrived from Turkey, which is currently experiencing waves of refugees and unknown persons coming into their country from other nearby countries, especially Syria. Many of those countries have harbored terrorists and, in fact, Turkey has recently seen an unusual increase in violence from terrorism. This is the price law-abiding people pay because of those few who seek to kill innocent people — and it’s the same reason so many Palestinians have to endure checkpoints in Israel….the madness of the few. Forget the righteous indignation. Better safe than sorry.
This all sounds very familiar….
Emad comes from a region that not only supports but sponsers terrorism. U.S customs would not be doing their job if they did not check him out. He was there for an hour and a half – my commute to work is longer than that each day…people need to get a grip – this is not news. Moore just likes to be in the spotlight but next time I get stopped for a speeding ticket I will tell the cop I know Michael Moore…haha
Somehow I doubt that dropping Michael Moore’s name when being detained by federal law enforcement officials is going to help matters much…
Speaking of Michael Moore this is some of what he said at the 2003 Oscars and will forever be remembered as a man who spoke the truth to millions of people even above the boos.
“We live in a time where we have a man sending us to war for fictitious reasons… Shame on you Mr. Bush.”
Aw, poor puppy.
He’s lucky he was only detained for an hour and a half.
Palesetinian terrorists don’t need no fucking paperwork!
Is NOBODY going to say it? Knowing the possible problems, why was there no representative from the Academy waiting for him at the airport? He would have been more or less waved through security, with an official present. That was rude and uncaring of the Academy. Who paid for his ticket, one wonders? My experience says that they probably arranged for his ticket, and he paid for his family – just guessing. The Academy has connections with the local INS temporary visitor’s visa office. This should not have happened! I hope they are apologizing to him for their oversight.
Publicity stunt.