
Here is an anecdote a producer shared with me during the pitch portion of this development season. He’d taken a writer to a network meeting. The writer poured his heart out pitching a show based on his life, but the network executive appeared uninterested, barely paying attention. As they were heading out, the producer mentioned he also had the rights to a book. Upon hearing the title, the executive’s eyes immediately lit up. “I’ll buy that show,” the exec exclaimed before even hearing what the book was about. This has been the case over and over this season, with the networks going hard and heavy after book adaptations and remakes of TV shows and movies, betting on underlying material as well as the familiar or catchy titles that come with it.
Related: Primetime Pilot Panic Pages

In light of the blockbuster success of two series based on books, HBO’s Game Of Thrones and AMC’s The Walking Dead, there are a slew of literary adaptations this season. The book-driven pilots include CBS‘ dramas Backstrom, based on the Backstrom books by Leif G.W. Persson, and Anatomy Of Violence, inspired by the non-fiction book by Adrian Raine; Fox‘s drama Delirium, based on Lauren Oliver’s book trilogy; Fox’s comedy I Suck At Girls, based on Justin Halpern’s book; NBC comedies Girlfriend in a Coma, based on Douglas Coupland’s book, and Undateable, based on the book by Ellen Rakieten & Anne Coyle; NBC drama The Secret Lives Of Husbands and Wives, inspired by Josie Brown’s novel; the CW dramas The Hundred, based on the books by Kass Morgan, and The Selection, based on the book by Keira Cass; Fox comedy To My Future Assistant, based on the blog and upcoming book by Lydia Whitlock; ABC drama The Returned, based on an upcoming novel by Jason Mott; and CBS drama Intelligence, based on on an unpublished book by John Dixon, joined by CBS’ summer series Under The Dome, based on Stephen King’s book.
Related: PILOT SEASON 2013: The Overachievers
In cable, FX’s pilot The Strain is an adaptation of Guillermo del Toro‘s vampire novel trilogy. Additionally, Fox drama pilot Sleepy Hollow, NBC’s Wonderland and ABC’s Venice are contemporary takes on the literary classics by Washington Irving (The Legend Of Sleepy Hollow), Lewis Carroll (Alice’s Adventures In Wonderland) and William Shakespeare (Romeo & Juliet), respectively. NBC’s comedy pilot Assistance is based on Leslye Headland’s play, NBC’s drama pilot The Sixth Gun is based on the Oni Press graphic novel, while ABC drama S.H.I.E.L.D. is based on the squad from both the Marvel comic books and feature films, including last year’s The Avengers.
It has been a strong year for movie adaptations. CBS has the hourlong Beverly Hills Cop and comedy Bad Teacher, while NBC has comedy pilot About A Boy. On the cable/digital side, Bravo’s pilot The Joneses is based on the 2009 movie, while Amazon’s Zombieland too is an adaptation of a 2009 film. Additionally, the 1967 series Ironside is getting a remake by NBC.
Related: PILOT SEASON 2013: Networks Dial Up Volume After Lackluster Season For New Series
When NBC’s The Office and ABC’s Ugly Betty took hold 6-7 years ago, their success spurred an influx of adaptation of foreign series. Now we have another wave of formats on the heels of the success of Showtime’s Homeland, which is based on an Israeli series, and the buzz surrounding Netflix’s House Of Cards, based on a British miniseries. No U.S. version of a foreign series has worked on U.S. broadcast TV since The Office and Ugly Betty. (Adaptations have been more successful on cable, with Homeland and modest hits Being Human on Syfy (based on a British series) and The Killing on AMC (based on a Danish series). But that has not deterred broadcast nets from loading up on pilots based on formats this year. UK series are again the most popular source material, followed by the new U.S. TV industry darling, Israeli formats.
As should be expected from a Brit, ABC’s Paul Lee once again ordered the most pilots based on UK shows: drama Lucky 7 (based on the British series The Syndicate) and comedies Pulling and Spy. Other British series adaptations include CBS pilot Second Sight, Fox comedy Friends And Family (based on Gavin & Stacey), NBC comedy The Gates and the CW drama The Tomorrow People. Israeli formats are represented by ABC comedy Divorce: A Love Story, CBS drama Hostages and CBS’ Julie Rottenberg/Elisa Zuritsky comedy. Additionally, ABC has drama pilot Betrayal, based on a Danish series and Killer Women, based on an Argentine format, while Fox’s hourlong pilot Rake starring Greg Kinnear is based on the Australian series. On the cable side, HBO has comedy pilot Getting On, an adaptation of a British format, and Bravo’s pilot Rita is based on a Danish series.
There are also several new series based on foreign formats launching in the next several months: ABC’s drama Red Widow, based on a Dutch series; comedy Family Tools, based on a British format, and soap Mistresses, also a British series adaptation; Lifetime dramedy Devious Maids, based on a Mexican series; AMC’s Low Winter Sun, based on a UK miniseries; as well as recently picked up FX drama The Bridge, based on a Danish/Swedish series.
TV Editor Nellie Andreeva - tip her here.


Our TV culture is one of fast followers. Shame on us clones trump originality!
DUCK SEASON!
RABBIT SEASON!
Elmer Fudd season!
The most striking thing about this year’s pilot sason is that the premises are even duller and harder to tell apart than last year’s. And look what happened with the ratings. When audiences can’t tell one show from another, they tune out. Reading this story, it’s just ine big grey boring mess. S.H.I.E.L.D. stands out, that’s about it.
And that’s gonna be on ABC… which instantly makes it a pass.
I’m gonna be desperate enough to check it out anyway. What else is there gonna be to watch? maybe Netflix can make a few more shows…
And that’s why NBC is in 5th place
time to start writing novels and comic books instead of spec scripts!
That’s exactly what I thought. It’s either that or going to cable.
Any news on pilot Getting On directed by Miguel Arteta adspated by Mark V Olsen from original work of Jo Brand?
And yet Chuck Lorre and company just write a spec and it’s more than likely going to be a hit. Funny how that works.
The adaptions are bought because you have to justify the jobs of development execs I suppose. Much easier to give notes based off of existing property, because you can speak to whether or not the writer nailed the structure and tone of what you’re going for. Spec comes from the writer’s mind solely.
Pilot season is really dumb process.
A lot of folks on this should be ashamed…
Just awful.
So much for TV being the new frontier for creating storytelling…
And Fox should be embarrassed they are trying to be the CW.
It’s true, much better to be pitching even a piece of shit book than an original idea. Shows you how little confidence TV execs have in their own opinions. So many cowards in so-called creative fields.
Sure, GoT and TWD have been very successful, but the uncomfortable paradox for the broadcast networks execs is that neither of those shows would have been successful had they been produced for broadcast television.
Several months back I was sitting in a cafe and got to chatting w/a woman who was clearly frustrated as she worked on her computer. I finally had to ask her what was so annoying, and she said, “A client of mine had a pitch meeting with ABC today, and we were told they’d move ahead if we can say the project is an adaptation of something…you know, because if it’s an original concept nobody wants it.”
So she was combing news sites, magazine sites — like Wired or whatever — and Amazon looking for subject-matter SIMILAR to her client’s project just so they can buy the rights to that article (or short story or what-have-you) then present the project as an adaptation of it.
“Baaaaaa” said the sheep.
So according to the paradigm there is no CSI, Grey’s Anatomy, LOST, Sopranos, Breaking Bad, The Good Wife, Mad Men, The Mentalist, NCIS or The Following. Just wanted to make sure. Cause those shows suck and no one watches them.
@Give me a break: you’re correct, there are hundreds of examples of hit original shows.It seems this trend has carried over from the risk-averse feature world,possibly in association with corporate “brand” thinking coming into play. (see what former Coca Cola exec-turned- TNT head Steve Koonin says in the earlier article about the HRTS Luncheon today) A word that seemed to dominate this year’s selling season was “noisy” as in, “it’s not noisy enough.”This trend is also, as other posters have said, a way for exex to cover their asses. Depressing.
Sounds like “Battleship” the TV series is on its way.
Original content is what great TV is all about. Now they’re going to sink TV like movies have been sunk.
Why don’t the development teams at the networks know how to develop?
Good write up Nellie – as always, very informative.
As with any trend, there is risk with the networks and their development teams/executives all the chasing ‘the new shiny object.’ No trend, especially on television, lasts for very long. If they/networks are lucky, they’ll catch this latest book adaptation trend as it arcs near its peak, and a couple of pilots will turn out to be hits. But that may be all – maybe 10% success ratio – for now.
The downside risk – the networks overshoot [as they often do] and bury the broadcast television viewer with an avalanche of product that is all too similar. If that product fails, it will fail across the board, hitting all the broadcast networks and producing another [yet another] failed television season in which few if any new series succeed. A couple of back-to-back-to-back years of that, and you have what we see today – broadcast television with declining viewership – DVR or not.
I guess there is one bright spot to this possible scenario – there will be a lot of job openings in those network executive offices come 2014. I think CBS is fine – but NBC, ABC, FOX and CW – there could be some serious change in the leadership of those four networks in the coming year or two.