Less than a month after scoring a major legal victory in the Superman copyright case, Warner Bros today sought to finish off the suit by the heirs of co-creator Jerry Siegel. “After nearly a decade of litigation, the Siegel Superman and Siegel Superboy cases can now come to an end,” said the motion for summary judgment (read it here) filed Thursday. The studio wants the federal court to assert the January 10 ruling of the Ninth Circuit Court
of Appeals that essentially gave Warner Bros full rights to the superhero character and the freedom to move forward with its Superman big screen reboot Man of Steel and other related properties without the threat of further legal action by the creators’ heirs and estates. The ruling last month overturned a 2008 ruling that Laura Siegel Larson and the estate of Joanne Siegel still controlled the lucrative rights to Superman and his younger self Superboy because a binding agreement was never reached by the parties. “In short, these cases are over. Any attempt by Larson to resuscitate them is futile,” the studio and its DC Comics subsidiary said in today’s filing by lawyers Daniel Petrocelli, Matthew Kline and Cassandra Seto. “In both the Superman and Superboy cases, DC’s Fourth Counterclaim seeks a declaration that Larson transferred her Superman and Superboy copyrights to DC pursuant to a 2001 settlement agreement, and that the parties are bound by the terms of that agreement,” it added. “The Ninth Circuit requested that this Court resolve these questions on remand, and the Court can and should do so now, and bring these two long-running cases to an end.” Defendants WB and DC Comics have requested a hearing on the motion for March 11, the same day several other matters in the Man of Steel legal saga are to be addressed by the court.
Related: Lawyer For Superman Heirs Want DC Comics Suit Dismissed
Deadline's Dominic Patten - tip him here.


I’m a comic book artist and I’ve created comics for other publishers knowing full well that THEY owned those characters, not me. That was the deal that the Superman creators made back in the 1930′s. Over the years they and their families have been paid additional sums of money several times. I know DC/Warner is a big company with lots of money, but how many times will they be dragged into court in an attempt to extort more cash for these families? Its over. DC owns Superman and the original creators have passed on. Please show some dignity and stop the endless lawsuits. Your ancestors created something and got paid for it – why should you be paid for stuff they did 70 years ago?
The case history is actually far more complicated than your comment suggests, SS. Copyright law has changed many times since the original agreement, and the rights of ownership have been extended time and time again. Thank Disney for leading that charge to keep Mickey out of public domain. As soon as 1928-related timelines lapse you’ll see Mickey Mouse up for grabs. I think the current copyright is something like life of the creator plus 90 years. Rights actually reverted to the creators back when Jerry and Joe signed their first deal.
Instead of calling for the families to back off, why not insist that the multi-billion dollar cash cow that WB continues to milk kick a taste back to the heirs?
it’s not the heirs who really get the money in these cases. they get some of it. most of the money goes to the lawyer (working on contingency) who is the masterminding the assault on Warners and other deep pocketed copyright holders.
However, even if after the end of the day DC wins, they still have to abide by the 2001 agrement with The Siegels – and they are ready to cut them a check for ALL monies due from then to now,and beyond.
Millions of Dollars – which unfornatily,who knows how much will go to the laywers on both sides.