SUNDAY 3 PM Pacific Time: Above is a celebrity stand-in during Red Carpet rehearsals for the 80th Academy Awards telecast Sunday (photo by Jonathan Alcorn) followed by the real George Clooney arriving on the real Red Carpet. My preview of the Oscars is here. I hear that ABC dramatically lowered expectations about tonight's TV ratings to advertisers. It will be interesting to see the Nielsen's, as the rain-postponed NASCAR Sprint Cup Series - Auto Club 500 race in Fontana is just about to restart at Lap 20 with a total of 300. After that there is another NASCAR race, the Nationwide series - Stater Bros 300, that is 200 laps. Will America tune out NASCAR to watch the Oscars? Meanwhile, a London source tells me that the BBC radio did a call-in show on the Oscars and no one phoned. Even Hollywood interest in the show is at its lowest point in recent memory. This may be the 80th Academy Awards, but they're really the 11th hour Oscars -- because not only were they almost picketed by the writers strike, and put together with only 13 days of major preparations instead of the usual months and months, but also the endless ceremony always seems like it lasts 11 hours.
PREDICTIONS: Two things I can forecast already about the show: George Clooney (who's on Time magazine's cover as "The Last Movie Star") will be fawned over and fussed over, just like he was to an embarrassing degree on the Red Carpet today. Regis Philbin slobbered how everyone wants to be George Clooney and compared him to Cary Grant. Clooney replied that Grant is dead. Sure, George has no prayer of winning an Oscar tonight. But Clooneymania is such a cult now that it's giving Obama-mania a run for its fainting spells. And there'll be a lot of inside jokes about the writers strike and the possible actors strike that no one outside of Burbank and Broadway can comprehend. Meanwhile, the presenters and performers should come with their own personal chyron explanations of who they are, like Miley Cyrus. Yes, many this year are that obscure because the Big Names couldn't get it together in just two weeks to show up inside the Kodak Theatre instead of outside on a picket line. That's just one reason why the show needs a total facelift, not just Botox. But that's another article...
Handicapping this year's Best Motion Picture Of the Year or many other categories is about as tough as picking the Superbowl winner after the big game is already held. Of course, No Country For Old Men will get the Oscar. Of course, Daniel Day Lewis will be named Best Actor In A Leading Role. Of course, Javier Bardem will win Best Actor In A Supporting Role.
But it's probably a 50-50 toss-up between Julie Christie and Marion Cotillard for Best Actress In A Leading Role. The members of the Academy of Motion Picture Arts & Sciences skew geriatric, so in this case the voters probably went for Julie whom many know from years past. They also like the way she's been hanging in there -- not just because she's still finding roles at her age, which is hard because of Hollywood's rampant ageism and sexism, or because she's doing films that actually say something, but also because she survived Warren Beatty.
As for Performance By An Actress In A Supporting Role, always the wild card category, most believe Cate Blanchett will win for playing Bob Dylan since cross-gender stunt casting usually guarantees an Oscar. (Hilary Swank and Linda Hunt can vouch for that.) But Cate won this category fairly recently, and if sentimentality holds, then Ruby Dee can win just like she did at the SAG awards. But a lot of Academy voters like to encourage young actresses, and many liked Gone Baby Gone more than they thought they would so Amy Ryan (hey, 40ish is young to them) could win as well. Personally, I'd like Ruby Dee to grab the gold, but I suspect Cate will.
Finally, I'm going out on a limb and predicting that Paul Thomas Anderson will win Best Director instead of the Coen brothers. My reasoning is: I like Anderson. And no one in Hollywood actually likes the Coen brothers. (Two past examples: Lauren Bacall and Eddie Murphy.) Besides, Oscar voters sometimes like to spread the wealth around. 'Nuff said.
5:50 PM: The show begins inside the Kodak Theatre:
I was told not to expect much in the way of an opening. I was told right. Led by Gil Cates, the Hollywood team that puts on the Academy Awards show tried to shoot the usual montage of the Oscar host, this time Jon Stewart, in situations with various movie stars. "But it proved too hard to write, cast, shoot and edit in 16 days, what with the rest of the show to take care of," an insider confided to me, referring to the sudden and unexpected settlement of the writers strike which meant the Oscars could be held as planned. "The booking alone would have taken 15 days."
Jon Stewart's monologue was better than the last time he hosted the show. Which isn't saying much. At least it was mercifully shorter. Problem is, halfway through this year's stand-up, he must have thought he was doing The Daily Show instead of doing the Academy Awards. It was obvious that the Hollywood audience was nervous, very nervous, when he launched into one political joke after another. The VIPs didn't laugh so much as politely titter. "Uh-oh," many of them clearly were thinking as Stewart ventured into The Danger Zone.
Stewart noted that Hollywood's Iraq War-themed movies in 2007 "did not go as well as hoped. Let's face it. I tell you, if we stay the course and keep these movies in the theaters, even if they have to stay there 100 years... We can not let the audience win." Nervous titters since Stewart was using the same phrase as presumptive GOP candidate John McCain in what amounted to a diss. "Uh-oh," people were thinking.
Stewart then made fun of Hollywood liberals without actually calling them Hollywood liberals. "Have you had a chance to study and pick the Democrat you'll vote for?" he asked the audience. Nervous titters.
About Hillary vs Obama, Jon quipped, more successfully, "Normally, when you see a black man or woman as president, an asteroid is about to hit the Statue of Liberty." But then Stewart may have gone too far by noting that Hussein is Obama's middle name and his last same rhymes with Osama -- as if it were necessary for the Oscars audience of 30+ million people to know that -- and wondering how the last presidential candidate "Gadolf Titler" did in the general election. "Uh-oh."
Best Costume Design
Alexandra Byrne, Elizabeth: The Golden Age (Universal)
Best Animated Feature
Ratatouille (Walt Disney/Pixar), Brad Bird
Best Makeup
Didier Lavergne and Jan Archibald, La Vie En Rose (Picturehouse)
Don't be surprised if George Clooney shows up soon in a late-night infomercial for hair gel. He had so much product in his slicked-down hair that he looked like Alfafa from the Little Rascals.
For crissakes, tonight's winners can't even thank their mother, much less their lawyer, without being cut off by the music. Obviously, Gil Cates is yet another family values-hating Hollywooder. Or maybe he just hates trial attorneys.
Best Visual Effects
Michael Fink, Bill Westenhofer, Ben Morris, Trevor Wood, The Golden Compass (New Line)
Best Art Direction
Art Direction: Dante Ferretti, Set Decoration: Francesca Lo Schiavo, Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber Of Fleet Street (DreamWorks/Paramount)
Best Performance By An Actor In A Supporting Role
Javier Bardem, No Country For Old Men (Paramount Vantage/Miramax)
Javier bounded to the stage in 3 seconds flat."I have to speak quickly here, man" He thanked the Coen brothers "for being crazy enough to think I could do this" and also for making him wear "one of the worst haircuts on my head". Then he launched into Spanish for his mother, which was heartfelt and charming. For non-Spanish speakers, here's a translation: "Mom, this is for you, for your grandparents, for your parents Rafael and Matilde, for the comedians of Spain who, like you, have brought dignity and pride to our profession. This is for Spain and for all of us." (For those who don't know, Bardem hails from a family of actors and filmmakers. Bardem's mother, Pilar, and his late grandfather, Rafael, are both renowned Spanish actors. His uncle, Juan Antonio, is a famed director.
Jeez, free the winners. Let them talk. Let them have time to at least say outrageous stuff. Why the heck does Gil Cates think we watch this god-awful show... For the obit segment?
Here's the segment I was told about: Jon Stewart showing some of the clip packages that purportedly were prepared in case the writers strike had remained in force, but fortunately did not make the cut. Now that I've seen them, they were AWFUL. And if they were supposed to be awful, then they had to be a lot more awful for them to even approach funny. Even Stewart called them "a waste of your time"... This Oscars is starting to get painful.
Oh no, that sensation I recognize so well is starting to come on. That panic. That hopelessness. That this-effing-show-is-going-to-last-a-lifetime feeling.
So, tell me: Is News Corp No. 2 Peter Chernin happy that Fox Sports's NASCAR races are opposite the Academy Awards tonight? I bet his pal Disney/ABC boss Bob Iger isn't...
Best Live Action Short Film
Le Mozart des Pickpockets (Premium Films), Philippe Pollet-Villard
Someone tell that fox Philippe Pollet-Villard that I'll help him with his English at midnight.
Oh no, he's baaaack. Jerry Seinfeld (who insulted movie theater owners everywhere last year), this time as a bee because of his Bee Movie. And that segment showing clips of bees in movies was so not funny. Why the hell have we lost our ability to do comedy in this country?
Best Animated Short Film
Peter & The Wolf (BreakThru Films), Suzie Templeton and Hugh Welchman
Best Performance By An Actress In A Supporting Role
Tilda Swinton, Michael Clayton (Warner Bros)
What a SHOCKER! Swinton, petting her Oscar, said, "I have an American agent who is the spitting image of this, the same shaped head and the buttocks. And I'm giving this to him because there's no way I would ever be in America if it weren't for him." The agent is Brian Swardstrom from Endeavor -- wow, what a shout-out! (Even better than Tom Strickler's at the same agency during a previous year's Oscars.) Funny thing, Tilda told a reporter on the Red Carpet earlier that she hadn't prepared an acceptance speech because she was so certain she wasn't going to win. So were we all!
I was thinking today that if the Oscars had been held, say, the first or second week in January, that Michael Clayton would have won hands down. Certainly, every Oscar voter I talked to at that time kept mentioning they liked it best. But then No Country For Old Men fever took hold as the movie they thought they should vote for because it was winning so many other awards (SAG, film critics). But I do think what hurt Michael Clayton is how lousy it opened at the U.S. box office given that it was a major studio pic with major motion picture stars. And then it just never took off. I know the Academy members hate to look out of touch with the taste of the American public. That was before this year when none of the movies except Juno made a dime.
Best Adapted Screenplay
Joel & Ethan Coen, No Country For Old Men (Paramount Vantage/Miramax)
Not only did Joel Coen thank Scott Rudin, but his brother Ethan teared up so sweetly that he couldn't say a thing. Nice moment. Joel Coen said the Oscar was "entirely attributable to how selective we are. We've only ever adapted Homer and Cormac McCarthy."
So, finally, there's Miley Cyrus, the presenter nobody over the age of 13 has ever heard of...
Wow, that chick from West Wing, Kristin Chenoweth, has an amazing set of pipes. (Sorry, I don't do Broadway or I would have known this...)
Wow, but Jon Stewart's ability to ad-lib tonight is non-existent. I could give him a pass by saying he's rusty from having sat out during the writers strike, but Jon went to work during the entire writers strike. So he just is sucking tonight, that's all. I can't even say the ad-libs written for him are really bad, because it looks like he's just standing there uncomfortably searching for a few words to say. Ugh.
Best Sounding Editing
Karen Baker Landers and Per Hallberg, The Bourne Ultimatum (Universal)
Boy, these two are going to be really embarrassed tomorrow when they relive how they forgot everyone's names tonight. But, hey, unless you've won an Oscar, you can't know the nervousness they feel.
Best Sound Mixing
Scott Milan, David Parker and Kirk Francis, The Bourne Ultimatum (Universal)
Gosh, I don't remember the Best Actress award coming this early in the show...
Best Performance By An Actress In A Leading Role
Marion Cotillard, La Vie En Rose(Picturehouse)
Here's hoping Lionsgate keeps making more Oscar-worthy films than torture porn movies even though the studio lost out tonight. Expectedly, Julie was the epitome of a class act and looked really surprised but also really happy for Marion, who was truly gobsmacked. "It is true there are some angels in this city," she finally got out. Hey, girl, you're one of them. What a great great win, so richly deserved. I rarely gush, but I loved her performance and the movie. I just figured that her foreignness and her freshness would lose to Christie since, usually but not always, this award goes to a seasoned veteran well known to Academy voters.
Thank god, it's Jack. In great eyeglasses, too. Too cool the way he does that "hahaha" in the middle of his speech. Reminds you of every movie you've ever seen him in.
It's so obvious that Gil Cates really expected to put on an actor-less and writer-less and director-less Oscars due to the strike because there are way more film clips than normal tonight. But the problem is that the show just doesn't seem alive. And the clips are too short -- often just one scene or face -- to really make you yearn for more. (And go out and rent buy the DVDs, as the Hollywood CEOs would dearly like you to do...)
Best Film Editing
Christopher Rouse, The Bourne Ultimatum (Universal)
Nice that his father won an Oscar, too.
The other day, I was wondering why The Bourne Ultimatum wasn't nominated for Best Picture. (Sorry, I was too busy reporting on the writers strike to really analyze the Oscar nods when they were announced.) I mean, it was a great film, and The Bourne Identity and The Bourne Supremacy were satisfying, too. And obviously, the public loved all three. As I said, just a thought. Then again, I also thought Into The Wild deserved a Best Picture nod. Clearly, I'm out of step with the Oscar voters. Or is it the other way around?
C'mon, AMPAS, there's no reason to wait until someone deserving like production designer Robert F. Boyle is 97 years old to give him an honorary Oscar. Though he said, trenchantly, "That's the good part of getting old. I don't recommend the other."
Best Foreign Language Film Of The Year
The Counterfeiters - Austria
This is the first Academy Award and 2nd nomination for Austria. Mentioning Hollywood legends like Billy Wilder who were Austrian, the winner made a good point noting that "most of them had to leave my country because of the Nazis so it makes sense that the first Oscar to win is about the Nazi crimes."
THAT was the big John Travolta dance segment I heard about on Friday? A trained poodle could have done that. In fact, I'm sure one did at the Westminster Dog Show. What the hell happened to John Travolta's career? (Answer, William Morris...)
Best Achievement In Music Written For Motion Pictures (Original Song)
"Falling Slowly", Once (Fox Searchlight), music and lyric by Glen Hansard and Marketa Irglova
OK, we get it already. You made the film for $100K. That's what Peter Rice spends on lunch at the Fox commissary. That is, if he ate lunch at the Fox commissary occasionally and not always at The Grill.
Nice moment when they brought out the "Falling Slowly" chick to give her time to make an acceptance speech. But why her when everyone else was cut off? Call from Peter Rice to Peter Chernin to Bob Iger to Gil Cates? Nah, probably just Jon Stewart wanting to look like a nice guy.
Best Achievement In Cinematography
Robert Elswit, There Will Be Blood (Paramount Vantage/Miramax)
I don't recall ever seeing agents in the obits segment before. After all, agents still can't vote in the Academy Awards...
I'm starting to get deja vu that I've seen this ceremony before. Oh yeah, it was this year's Golden Globes where people simply read off the names and there wasn't any show. Is this really the effect that AMPAS was going for this year? Hell of a way to celebrate the 80th Oscars by keeping the spoken words and the skits and everything else enjoyable to a mimimum. Was Gil Cates trying to get back at the Writers Guild?
Best Achievement In Music Written For Motion Pictures (Original Score)
Dario Marianelli, Atonement (Focus Features)
Stewart notes that Tom Hanks was not nominated tonight, "So, if you ask me, he has no place being here." That's it? That's the best line anyone could come up with?
Tom Hanks who's on the Academy's Board of Governors, showed America (and the GOP) that Hollywood does, too, care about the troops. Even if one of the Best Documentary Short Subject films champions gays (who aren't supposed to serve in the U.S. military). The troops actually presented the Oscar for:
Best Documentary Short Subject
Freeheld (A Lieutenant Films Production), Cynthia Wade and Vanessa Roth
Ooh, tears. Oops, the film about gays won. There goes the brownie points AMPAS was trying to win with the Republicans. This is what happens when Hollywood stoops to pander.
Best Documentary Feature
Taxi To The Dark Side (THINKFilm), (An X-Ray Production), Alex Gibney and Eva Orner
An anti-military film wins (if you're a Republican) or a truthful film about the military wins (if you're a Democrat). Rush Limbaugh, look on the bright side: the Academy voters could have given another Oscar to Michael Moore.
Best Original Screenplay
Diablo Cody, Juno (Fox Searchlight)
"This is for the writers," Cody said holding aloft her Oscar. "Most of all I want to thank my family for loving me exactly the way I am." Not cloying. But she could have been a bit more profound, however. She is, after all, a writer.
Did you notice how the laughter was nervous when Helen Mirren dissed the studio heads? (Rather, the writers dissed the studio heads. Although Mirren could have asked them to write something else and didn't. Kudos for your courage, Helen.)
Best Performance By An Actor In A Leading Role
Daniel Day-Lewis, There Will Be Blood (Paramount Vantage/Miramax)
"That's the closest I'll ever come to getting a knighthood," said Daniel, thanking the Academy for "whacking me with the handsomest bludgeon in town". (By the way, I love the double earring look...) Nicely worded, even uber-literate, acceptance speech by him, especially this about his brand new Oscar: "...thinking this sprang like a golden sapling out of the fertile head of Paul Thomas Anderson". Humbleness becomes Day-Lewis.
Quick, someone tell Gil Cates that THE WRITERS STRIKE IS OVER! Enough with the clips substituting for live stuff. He killed the 80th Oscars by doing this.
On the other hand, this is the shortest Academy Awards broadcast in recent years ever. So I should be grateful for small favors, right?
Best Achievement In Directing
Joel & Ethan Coen, No Country For Old Men (Paramount vantage/Miramax)
Ethan Coen was charming when he said: "I don't have a lot to add to what I said earlier. Thank you." Good one. So Joel speechified for them both: "Ethan and I have been making stories with movie cameras since we were kids," noting how in the late 60s, they took a Super-8 camera to the airport and did a movie about Henry Kissinger's shuttle diplomacy. "Honestly, what we do now doesn't feel that much different from what we did then. We're very grateful to all of you for letting us continue to play in our corner of the sandbox."
Instead of its voters nominating American Gangster, AMPAS sent out Denzel Washington to announce Best Picture. Not enough of a sop, guys.
Best Motion Picture Of the Year
No Country For Old Men (Paramount Vantage/Miramax), A Scott Rudin/Mike Zoss Production. Producers Scott Rudin, Ethan Coen, Joel Coen.
Good for Scott Rudin for thanking Cormac Mccarthy (and nice camerawork, ABC, for panning to him in the audience) Even better, Rudin's shout-out to Sidney Pollack and decision to dedicate the Oscar to him. (It's not just that Scott works with Pollack's production company Mirage Enterprises. It's also that Pollack hasn't been well.)
It's over. This wasn't an Oscars. This was a slightly longer version of the Golden Globes announcement. And I hope we've seen the last of Jon Stewart as host.
Going to eat dinner then weave in some of tonight's photos and maybe more stuff.




It’s ironic that it will be the least watched show while the film nominees are the best group I’ve seen in a long time.
We are all at the NASCAR race right now… There are stars everywhere here in Fontana, CA…!!!
Bone Lee
Gary Busey made the whole pre-red carpet worth it.
I want to see him with Ryan Seacrest on WWWrestling.
Man, when Clooney gets into a role, he really gets into a role big time! Impressive.
I cannot even bring myself to watch this anymore. Today’s actors (if you can call them that)leave so much to be desired. I have been watching TCM’s Oscar movies from Feb 1 goes through beginning of March. These so called actors could not wipe the shoes of the actors from the 40’s, 50’s and 60’s. No one is even in the same league as individuals like Bogart, Bergman, and on and on. Those movies have plots minus the blood, gore, blantant sex and foul language. They are just as timeless today and they were when they were made. Give me Casablanca any day of the week over any movie out now. They can’t even do the remakes well. Very Sad.
I’m with you Nikki! P.T. Anderson for director would make my night.
What’s with the Clooney fest?
The guy’s getting old, too old to have a young girlfriend without looking creepy. He needs a teeth whitening, and his surgeon did not do a good job on his facelift stitching
My Predictions: (and these are both upsets)
Best actor will go to George Clooney and he will rant about the Pharmaceutical industry in his speech.
Then, best actress will go to Ellen Page and she will school Clooney on how to make an acceptance speech.
I think I would go lesbian for Marion Cotillard.
All of the stars are here in Fontana at the NASCAR race.
I just saw David Spade!!!… no wait minute, it was just a Chihuahua…
Bone Lee
I don’t think you’d want Ellen Page making an acceptance speech of this magnitude. If you’ve read any interviews with her, she’s a real flake.
Is she a lesbian?
Nobody likes Lauren Bacall? Why?
Can’t get enough desire to watch the largest parade of hypocrites. They all tell “middle” America how to run their lives (use mass transit, turn lights off, buy earth friendly products) but no one in that audience does this themselves. I echo the sentiments expressed that there are really no more movie stars. All the best from The Motor City.
I hope the stars don’t get political! They are all so arrogant! I wish everyone would just ignore them and quit watching their movies! They are all mostly horrible and lack quality!
Jon Stewart was terrific in his opening.
Re: The rant by “cc”…
What does cc stand for “crypt curmudgeon”? Jesus, wake up and smell the calendar. Complaining about these new kids today is as old and tiresome as…well.. you seem to be. Every generation thinks that theirs was the best when they look at it through the filter of time and distant memories. The actors you hold up as the true stars performed in an era where stilted and stiff acting was the style, in cookie cutter scripts and pc to the point of boredom. Not all, but since you want to stereotype today’s movies and stars I thought I’d throw it back atcha, Grumpy. Art changes with time and today’s actors, movies, and style of presentation will no doubt be held up as better than what will take their place 50 years from now. One thing is for sure, I won’t follow your lead of trashing the now and living in the past.
Jenny
I actually thought Stewart was pretty funny. The Statute of Liberty joke was hilarious. True…but hilarious.
The lesbian comment above is gold.
I am so glad that you are blogging the event. This way I can get the highlights without having to watch the whole boring event. Your tops Nikki!
I can’t believe Jack Fisk lost.
Nikki, The NASCAR race has been postponed until the rain stops. It will be interesting to see if NASCAR fans stay with The Simpsons on Fox, or change to Law And Order C.I Marathon on NBC – The Oscars?
The show is boring, and all the self congratulation is getting old.
What a ray of sunshine you are Nikki. Cynical much?
Nikki, those montages were intentional jokes–they were never intended to be a serious part of the show and they were SUPPOSED to be awful. The writers purposefully picked ridiculous “themes” to show what “could have been” if the strike had continued.
I don’t get why people keep complaining that the Oscars are too “self-congratulatory.” It’s an AWARDS SHOW, people! By definition it’s self-congratulatory. Jeez…
It’s the Auto Club 500, not 550. And as JimmyZ noted, it’s been postponed.
I will be staying with The Simpsons and “watching” the Oscars via your blog, Nikki. Keep up the cynicism and snarkiness. And stay healthy for chrissakes.
Feelin’ you,
Stan Renaldi
“Jeez, free the winners. Let them talk. Let them have time to at least say outrageous stuff. Why the heck does Gil Cates think we watch this god-awful show… For the obit segment?”
“Oh no, that sensation I recognize so well is starting to come on. That panic. That hopelessness. That this-effing-show-is-going-to-last-a-lifetime feeling.”
Well there is 2 contradictory statements in the same post. You cant have it both ways either cut the amount of time for the speeches or it will go all night. You cant have it both ways. Plus what did their mothers have to do with their award? Aside from birth most peoples mothers (or fathers (with the exeption of the acting clans)) have little to do with their sucess.
Nikki, Michael Clayton only cost $25 million to make and has grossed $50 million in the U.S. alone. It’ll be big on DVD. It’s a success and will be very profitable.
ths show is painful to watch. on every level, it’s an outdated fossil! bravo, tilda swindon……and javier bardem. zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz…………
Sid Ganis’ mini-documentary on the process of the Oscars would be better suited for Discovery Channel’s “How it Works” ? Only 1 hour and 10 Minutes left. The Self-Congratulation Continues…..
This is the first oscarcast that I’ve missed since the big Star Wars one in 1978. The self-congratulatory circle jerk of a bunch of leftist morons does not interest me, and the awards have gone so far off the rails that nobody cares who wins what anymore. Winning Best Picture used to mean something.
Is it really possible for no American to win any of the acting gongs?? That’s gotta be a first. In fact, I just can’t see Hollywood doing it…. they’ll want to give SOMETHING to an American actor. I’m sensing an upset with Clooney or Depp winning Best Actor.
Nikki, there’s no ad-libbing
That’s written.
Probably by some of the people that commented right here.
Rats! No Oscar for Kevin O’Connell again. That makes 20 noms – no win!
Perhaps in a few years, if ABC continues to have rights to the Oscars, we will see it on ABC Family.
or perhaps CBS will bid on the Oscars so we can have them right after Jackass on MTV in the future.
Gil Cates trying to bring Old Hollywood and New Hollywood together is like nails on a chalkboard.
BTW Jenny, If you go to the Motion Picture Retirement Home in Woodland Hills, you won’t see a life size picture of Seth Rogan, or Will Ferrell yet and it is doubtful whether you will see them 50 years from now either. The actors of today have very little staying power with the changes in media and technology of today.
Fox is counterprogamming right now with “Are You Smarter than a 5th Grader” here on the West Coast. It WILL be interesting to see the overnight ratings.
drip…drip…drip…
i’m thrilled they got it right with marion cotillard. thrilled!!!!! these muscal numbers have been horrid, crossing fingers for Glen H and his partner.
such arrogance. The idea that the Oscars are better with them, than without them was the funniest thing I have heard so far.
oh and we all know it was an ‘in your face’ bit “can’t”. It’s sad, but normal that they have to be so petulant. The idea that we can’t get along without the WGA is laughable.
It was their fault the awards show almost didn’t have writers, and up until now, nobody missed them. Oh wait, we still don’t. Matter of fact, please go back on strike.
bull, it’s not the media; it’s the “actors” that are the problem. Stop making excuses for weak talent.
Hollywood CEOs don’t want you to rent DVDs, they want you to buy them. . . in Blu-ray
Huh? You sound like you think they are voting in real time. It’s too late, the votes are in, there is not “mo” for anyone to get.
Well it looks like David Letterman will no longer be considered the worst host of the Oscars cause tonight John Stewart has earned that dishonor.
Anyone else notice in the montage of best actress winners, all the winners since the early ’60s EXCEPT both wins by Sally Field. That was just weird, why’d they leave her out?
Mark, it’s both the quality of actors AND the advances in the delivery of home media content. Would you agree that DVD’s will be the last hard goods for movies, giving way to a downloading society?
I can watch clips on Youtube, download a program from Amazon for My Sandisk Sansa, download a movie or video podcast on my iPod. or I can buy or rent a DVD, or go to my local multiplex to experience a motion picture. Each one of these delivery methods will have their own “stars”
Wearing a flash drive on your wrist that holds movies/program content is the newest media delivery method. check out http://blog.wired.com/music/2007/03/distributing_fi.html
BTW these actors should really take a look at how they look in High Definition. Really.
Nikki Love the blog
YAY “Falling Slowly” won for best song!!
Yay, even though they stacked the deck with 3 bad songs from that insipid movie enchanted one of the other movies won.
“Well it looks like David Letterman will no longer be considered the worst host of the Oscars cause tonight John Stewart has earned that dishonor.
Comment by rst02 — February 24, 2008 @ 7:36 pm”
Puleeze nothing is or ever will be worse than “Uma Oprah, Oprah Uma”
Hollywood blows. As do the Oscars. Here’s hoping both disappear in a giant fireball of flame.
Sincerely yours,
Flyover Country, otherwise known as the UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
Well thanks for nothing Academy members. No point in hanging around to watch this non-event now that our Cate has missed out. And to what? A cheese eacting surrender monkey and a shiela that looks like she is actually the virgin queen’s cadaver.
WHy the snark for Jon Stewart bringing Marika back out to say her thanks? I think it was a nice nod to the fact that they’ve been going haywire with the play-off music tonight. It should be a discretionary thing.
Nikki, I am not sure who Bone Lee Tadpole is or if he/she is really at the NASCAR race or being sarcastic (I suspect the latter). But I can tell you on TV the only celeb they showed at the race (before it was red-flagged for rain again) was Tom Cruise and his son Connor. They were sitting in Jimmie Johnson’s pit box and the NASCAR announcers joked around and called him Cole Trickle (Days of Thunder). He may be back in LA and sneaking into the Oscars now for all I know.
NASCAR has pretty much tried and failed to get celebrities to come to the Fontana races for the past few years, so they’ve given up somewhat. Which made it surprising to see Cruise there.
This is the first year I haven’t watched or recorded the Oscars in my adulthood, and it wasn’t because of the NASCAR race. Last year I recorded it (I do that some years), but this year I didn’t care to do that. So interest is definitely gone.(My favorite movie was indeed The Bourne Supremacy; glad to see they won some tech awards.)
I have set the DVR for all the fashion reviews tomorrow, and I watched Barbara Walters because Vanessa Williams/Wilhemina from Ugly Betty was on it (I love her!) but that was it Oscar-wise.
Thank you for your live blog; I feel properly updated now. And believe it or not, they are STILL trying to run the NASCAR race if they get the track dry. I bet the ratings for the race from 8-9 EST on the East Coast before it started raining again weren’t bad at all.
Here’s hoping that Sid Ganis does the right thing and fires Gil Cates after this ceremony. There are other people that are more deserving of working the show than him. Here are some people that could replace him; Don Mischer, Ric Birch, or even Woody Allen. My pick is Don Mischer because he has does have the Emmy Awards to his name as well as other special events.
I’m glad they brought the czech chick back out from “once”.
With all the cutting off of speeches, they kill their ability to capture moments of spontaneous, joyous blathering that comes with a once-in-a-lifetime win. Then, eventually the only moments that will fill out those montage scenes will be from 30 years ago or before.
Jeez. Maybe he actually is a nice guy. Lighten up on Stewart already. It’s not as easy as it looks.
I agree with the assessment about John Stewart sucking hard, but what I want to know is where was Roy Scheider’s name on the In Memorium montage??
hollywood docs. are a wasteland for comminuist anti-americians SHAME ON YOU TOM HANKS
So your blog has been taken over by some kid living in his mother’s basement, posting drivel under a bunch of names.
karma?
OK, we get it already. You made the film for $100K. That’s what Peter Rice spends on lunch at the Fox commissary. That is, if he ate lunch at the Fox commissary occasionally and not always at The Grill.
Nice moment when they brought out the “Falling Slowly” chick to give her time to make an acceptance speech. But why her when everyone else was cut off? Call from Peter Rice to Peter Chernin to Bob Iger to Gil Cates? Nah, probably just Jon Stewart wanting to look like a nice guy.
Sorry, Nikki, but sometimes your cynicism can be a tad overdone. Glen and Marketa’s performance was amazing, and they are such deserving winners. Don’t rain on their parade! And if had been watching closely, you would’ve noticed that they cut off Marketa early so I was glad they gave her a second chance to speak. And then she gave one of the most uplifting acceptance speeches all night. Well done.
C’mon, Nikke, you just don’t like Jon Stewart, apparently. He is very, very, very funny tonight. The reviews will be good for him tomorrow. You watch. Really, get over it and enjoy him. He is freakin’ funny tonight!
Viggo is an American and his work was as good as any this year. Period.
Is Diablo Cody officially the hottest screenwriting Oscar winner ever?
I was so happy they brought back Marketa Irglova, her speech was the best thing all night.
That’s it for me–the final nail in the coffin for Hollywood’s artistic bankruptcy–Diablo Cody’s win for JUNO. That was a BAD script, resulting in a BAD film, not a good one by any stretch of the imagination, and the fact that other writers voted for it to win makes me think they must have all been on heavy drugs.
This is also the worst thing that could have happened to Ms. Cody, because it will be an even steeper path downhill from here.
“Not cloying. But she could have been a bit more profound, however. She is, after all, a writer.”
Nikki, you are exactly as advertised.
BTW, I think Rush will find plenty to talk about simply due to Jon Stewart’s actions.
What a bunch of cynical, hateful people post here…let me get this straight, instead of just watching the Oscars, you all rush to this blog to try and be bitter about every little thing?
I wanted a live blog about an award show…I got a death march…
mheister: Diablo Cody is a trampy-looking whore who embarrasses the rest of us female writers, quite frankly. What a classless, tacky trollop she’s turned out to be.
NSW-
Bitter,cynical,hateful? You don’t even know any of us!
You are condeming us for the same thing you appear to be doing.
I kinda like the addition of being able to comment-it’s better than a live real-time chat.
I am a happy person, I just didn’t like the Oscar Broadcast. And now its over.
I cant believe they still alow Moore’s clearly fabricated movies to be called Documentaries. At least he didnt win.
What, you don’t post comments anymore post strike if they come seemingly come from “non Hollywood people”?
Get real Nikki. Non-Hollywood people MADE your blog during the strike. We made not have given you a shoutout on Letterman, but we gave you the hits and linked your entries elsewhere that resulted in your media presence.
If you ignore those of us who clicked on your page every day and have kept coming back, we will forget you exist and you will go right back to being a blip on the radar screen that only a few diehards clicked on before the strike. I’m not going to patronize the site of anyone who would ignore my (rare and only actually) comment because I’m not an insider. Good luck with that.
So go ahead and ignore us and see how that works out for ya, say, a month from now – if it hasn’t sent your hits spiraling already.
Diablo Cody is the biggest name-changing phony on the planet. That whole “nerd” angle is just schtick and not very convincing schtick at that. She’s a talented writer who was doing well at an ad agency and was pretty enough to be a stripper. And the first 15 minutes of Juno was excruciatingly bad….honest to blog!
Nikki,
Is this some type of ploy to increase your street cred?. It seems that you are just being cynical to be cynical. I thought the Oscars were very classy with such little time to prepare. What did you want them to do? You hate the studio heads, the writers, the presenters, the actors. Who do you like?
Funny that the moment that excited Nikki most was the mention of an agent.
And why do you know where Peter Rice eats lunch?
I agree Bourne should’ve been nominated for Best Picture. It won 3 Oscars (including editing), but wasn’t good enough to be considered for the big awards. Of course not. We wouldn’t want to admit that there are great movies that aren’t straight up dramas or dramadies.
“Instead of its voters nominating American Gangster, AMPAS sent out Denzel Washington to announce Best Picture. Not enough of a sop, guys.”
Training Day was enough of a gift to Denzel to last him a while. He needs to do a couple more quality films like Gangster before they give him another one to make up for that POS.
Eva Longoria got ripped off when she didn’t win for Over Her Dead Body. Oh wait, it’s not the Razzies yet!
Miley Cyrus is one of the best-known performers in the world today, her TV show Hannah Montana pulls boffo ratings, her 3-D movie did more business in 700 theaters than the competition playing in 3000+ theaters and her musical concert tours always sell out. Perhaps you hate her for whatever reason but calling her obscure is more than a bit of a stretch.
Nikki, I don’t get why you’re so hard on Jon Stewart. He was better than Ellen DeGeneres, Whoopi Goldberg, David Letterman, Chris Rock, and last few years of Billy Crystal.
He’s not better than Steve Martin… but who is?
Walk The Line- “Best Known Performer in the World Today”? Granted Miley Cyrus’s concerts sold out, and her Cable program is highly rated, and yes, her 3-D movie did well. So why was she on the Oscars? Maybe because she is a Disney Property, and Disney owns ABC which broadcasts the Oscars. Then again, it may be part of her contract. Let’s see a year from now how the tween phenom is doing before we elevate her to Icon status.
Thought that Jon Stewart did a pretty great job. Not sure what Nikke’s hard-on for negativity towards him is for. Oh well.
Did one of the winners thank his lover? That was cute. Some homo action. I wasn’t looking at the screen when he won, so for a second I thought it was Travolta.
I don’t know what the hell you’re talking about. Jon Stewart was really funny tonight. All his ad-libs were funny, and it was great when he brought back out Marketa Irglova.
And what could be better than Diablo Cody thanking her parents for always loving her for exactly who she was, and she finished her speech in tears?
I don’t know, you seem incredibly cynical and judgemental about this whole thing. In the grand scheme of things, it’s just a dumb awards show. Why take it so seriously?
I thought that Jon Stewart was absolutley hilarious, but I guess that’s just me.
And Jesus, enough with this petty, cruel-spirited Diablo Cody hate. I’m SO sorry a quirky movie about teenagers spoiled your year.
@walk the line: ashlee simpson’s debut record went 3X platinum, doesn’t mean she should perform at the grammy’s. miley cyrus like most of the disney bots (i.e. high school musical kids, hilary duff, etc.) is viciously untalented. it’s a shame how low the bar is set on tween talent. she can’t sing a lick and with the steamy pictures of her leaking on the net, i dare say that we won’t be seeing much of her five years from now.
What do you have against Jon Stewart? I thought he was absolutely fabulous, he did a wonderful job. And he’s an AMAZING ad libber, a really nice human guy, and he is forty times funnier than you will ever be. Jon Stewart is the best person on earth, and just try to find someone funnier/more human/kinder than he is that is also a comedian. Wow, just got hard there. Nikki, you aren’t funny, you’re stupid and cynical, and you obviously wouldn’t know funny if it danced naked in front of you wearing Dobby’s tea cozy.
Can’t Take it Anymore – What have you got against trampy-looking whores and classless, tacky trollops anyway???
Okay, I saw her speak at a screening of Juno with Jason Reitman. She had on the retro hip guy’s hat and all, but what Quentin Tarantino is to movie geekdom, Diablo is to the self-conscious retro fashionistas into the modern primitive thing. They’re not really anarchists, they’re not really rebellious, except perhaps to an artificial construct that even middle America has long abandoned. They just need a common “alternative” construct to channel their lockstep non-conformity. She’s found a niche where she feels safe. And she wears it well. What’s not to like?
Besides, the writing on Juno was fantastic. I think a lot of hipster women writers (you know who you are, you are Tina Fey by way of Dita Von Teese weaned on Erica Jong) are just kicking themselves for not writing the way they talk to each other every day.
Nikki, I’m not sure why, but even your preshow headlines told us you were going to lay a lot of hate on. Guess it’s more interesting than not being hopeful.
Stewart had some hilarious lines. He wasn’t perfect, but it’s not an easy gig. B+
But it’s not all love from me. Diablo Cody obviously saved an outfit from her stripping days.
Molly Cyrus is one of the biggest stars in the world right now, you’re kind of making yourself look like a grandma.
Maybe the show would be more interesting if they gave out awards to the people who came in 2nd and third. Like, 2nd gets you a set of steak knives, and third, a free auditing session at the nearest Scientology center. (not one of the celebrity ones though)
Nikki,
Are you still on medication? I thought Jon Stewart did well and was overall funny. There were a few rough spots, but I considered him one of the more positive elements throughout a very mundane show (after 80 years, we get endless film bites from Hollywood’s finest?).
As for the criticism of Diablo Cody, she was obviously overwhelmed by the award, so give her a break and “don’t be hatin’.”
As always Nikki, you are the best!
Nikki, I know you’re bitter that the writers decided to go back to work and your site is getting fewer hits now, but lay off Stewart: He was really funny tonight. Not perfect, but very good, certainly the best host since Billy Crystal. Get over it. So what he did his show during the strike. I’m sure all his writers are cool. And he kept his staff employed. Chill out. You may have the actors going on strike soon, and you can take up your number of hits then.
Am I the only one who’s puzzled by people who say they never watch movies or hate Hollywood show up and comment on the DHD Oscar thread? Very odd. Do these folks go to concerts of bands they hate and eat their least favorite foods for dinner every night as well? Any guidance you care to provide, rjhill, is appreciated.
Its funny, Nikki clearly hated both Stewart performances, I actually liked him a lot the first time but thought he was flat tonight. But as 40yearoldsitzer mentioned, he’s still better than a lot of the alternatives (its a tough gig). Plus, Nikki, you hit him too hard, and I’m going to blame you when next year its Ryan Seacrest.
Wow, were you watching the same telecast I was watching. The audience didn’t look nervous at all during Stewart’s jokes. People were really laughing and seemed to be enjoying him. Honestly, he didn’t suck at all. Maybe you had already formed an opinion before the show started. I usually like your blog but you’re a strange and angry person.
I am utterly giddy with joy over the win for Best Actress being awarded to the very deserving Marion Cotillard who so magnificently transformed herself into Edith Piaf for La Vie En Rose. Kudos to the Academy voters for getting this one right!
I loved the eloquence (as always) of Daniel Day Lewis’ speech… I guess that it can’t hurt being married to Rebecca Miller (daughter of Arthur Miller).
It was a bit of a surprise (but then there is usually at least one) to see Tilda Swinton win for Best Supporting Actress beating out the favored Cate Blanchett, Amy Ryan and even Ruby Dee. I am sorry to say but Saoirse Ronan wasn’t on my radar, but she’s young and still has a lot of chances ahead of her.
Most of the other categories were givens and no real surprises came about.
I too thought that we could have done without all that “wasted” space of showing so many clips throughout the show (I thought that was Plan B in case the writers strike hadn’t ended). Jon Stewart had a few moments during the broadcast that weren’t boring, but the majority of the show… sorry Jon, it was fast forward time on my DVR.
Thank you to Nikki for keeping us up to date on the “action” and thanks for always providing us with the latest updates.
did Jon Stewart send a bunch of his writers here to defend him?
give me a break – anyone with ears can tell he is not doing a good job – he’s just going through the motions
we don’t need him to compliment the stars, as he keeps on doing
he’s supposed to entertain – and to say he is better than those past hosts is truly insane
i don’t know Jon, but even if i did, i would have no problem telling him that he needs to move on
quite frankly, i think Colbert might have been a much better choice
*cough* excuse me? You can’t be serious?
Are you really so shallow as to be sucked in by that blatant bit of showmanship? Pathetic and hackneyed USE of our brave men and women; NONE OF WHOM HOLLWOOD GIVES A D**N ABOUT. Offensive. Almost as offensive as the Doc winner. My father told me to make this film. oh bullcrap.
So glad I only saw bits and pieces. Made me realize why I don’t go to the movies anymore.
Yeah, pretty dry stuff. not nearly enough mean jokes from Stewart but on the plus side – under 3 1/2 hours, which meant I could watch the HD broadcast of The Wire without depending on my erratic DVR.
More Oscars like this and they might as well relegate this thing to the CMT Cable Network along with the Miss America Pageant. Stick a fork in Nicole Kidmann’s Botox-petrified forehead — it’s done.
If the Oscars prove anything, they prove how lucky we all are to have the writers back from their three month strike, right? I mean, what would this show have been without the WGA writers crafting all the material spoken by John Stewart and the presenters?
I don’t know the answer to that question.
What was the show like WITH the WGA writers back on the job?
I have the answer to that one.
Here’s one of the introductions of a presenter, not from John Stewart but from the booming omniscient off-screen announcer’s voice: “Our next presenter, the always fabulous Jessica Alba.” Huh? The “always fabulous”? That’s what the no-longer-striking writers came up with? Why not mention some movie she’s been in or will be in? Like, “And now, star of the upcoming movie Blankety Blank, Jessica Alba.” Nope, not the returning WGA writers! They went with “the always fabulous.” Maybe they originally wrote, “And now, some hot babe named Jessica Alba” and that was rejected by Ms. Alba’s people, but a compromise was arrived at and “the always fabulous” was chosen. Of course, since the writers just got back from strike they were pressed for time and right before air all they had was the incomplete intro of “the always fabu-.” They had to bring in extra writers to finish up the intro.
For the record, there was another intro of similar quality and depth for a male star. The same off-screen announcer voice intoned: “Please welcome the talented and handsome Patrick Dempsey.” Just in case you hadn’t noticed, ladies, this guy is “handsome,” so please pay extra-close attention!
Awards being given to actors, many of whom we’ve never seen or heard of before, some of whom we may have seen but didn’t particularly like, appearing in movies that we either never saw, had no intention of seeing, didn’t want to see or did see and loathed.
Yeah, lets build a show around that!
Finally, how did they ever choose the Academy Award for best song out of those five songs? Remember any of them? I think there should be an envelope that gets opened and it says, “Sorry. No winner this time. All the songs suck. Better luck next year.”
Diablo is no Tina Fey.
She fell a– backwards into Oscar gold and managed to incur the wrath of the entire planet at the same time… what a feat.
As for her fashion sense? It reminds me of a “Time Warp” Transylvanian… including the notorious “uncoventional conventionalists” line uttered by (the great) Tim Curry himself.
JUNO had a MOW plot and quirky dialog. Diablo is a funny writer, foah shouah, but no women talk like that and no teen girls talk like that. Cynicism can only take you so far… before it becomes… tired.
JON STEWART ROCKED!!!!!!!! He was effing hilarious! Especially the Vanity Fair party not inviting writers joke. He was totally funny!!!!!!!!!
I thought Jon Stewart did a great job, especially given how little time he had to prepare (and the fact that he has to incorporate Bruce Vallanch jokes into his monologue, sadly.)
What I don’t get is why they no longer do a major award right up front (best supporting actor or actress) as after the monologue that first half hour of well deserved but not well known categories is dull as can be. Mix it up.
And I also really don’t see why the short films — whether animated, live action, or documentary — are included in the telecast at all. They are great achievements, I suppose (although many TV pilots are better– especially many that are quirkier and don’t get picked up) but as almost NO ONE in the viewing audience has seen them why not give them out at an earlier separate show? That would cut a good twenty minutes from the broadcast and not force viewers to see people thank people for a movie they could not have seen even if they were avid film-goers (yes, some could see it at special screenings in L.A. this past week, but that’s hardly a majority of the supposed billion people watching.)
And the decision to include montages of past-winners was especially confusing given all they did was make the current winners’ speeches look dull by comparison (with few exceptions, its hard to top the best moments from 80 years.) I understand having had those prepared in case the WGA strike was still going but keeping them in made no sense.
Ah well. I’m sure I’ll watch next year regardless.
Oh, and I for one liked “Juno” a lot, and don’t blame Diablo for being over-exposed. Once the studio PR machine starts, its incredibly hard to get off. None of that over-exposure takes away from it having some of the best lines of dialogue of the year (”Knocked Up” did as well, but came out too early in the year I suppose. And poor, hilarious “Rocket Science” got completely overlooked.) Yes, the first fifteen minutes of “Juno” were painful, but as Andy Samberg said on SNL last night about that exact issue, “Don’t worry, it gets better.”
“Stewart sparkles as Oscars host”
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/entertainment/7262281.stm
“I hope the stars don’t get political! They are all so arrogant! I wish everyone would just ignore them and quit watching their movies! They are all mostly horrible and lack quality!
Comment by Vvicki — February 24, 2008 @ 5:42 pm”
Wow Vvickie, your point is practically illiterate and very unfocused.
Also very arrogant.
How ironic.
Do you hate the movies because the stars express their political opinions or because of quality? Please explain your answers, spelling counts.
One thing seems clear…you’re posting here because you’re a star-mongering celebrity whore who’s talking out of both sides of her mouth.
Tom –
They introduced Alba as ‘the always FANTASTIC…’ — a reference to the Fantastic Four franchise. Pay attention.
Stewart was a better host than Nikki gives him credit for, but still lacklustre.
Cody and Cottilard = teh hotness!!!
Actually, didn’t the announcer say the “always FANTASTIC” Jessica Alba? That would, of course, be a plug of the only two somewhat successful films (other than Sin City) that she has been in.
The Oscars were ok. Not great. Ok.
Whover the asshole is that wrote about ellen page is really messed up, Ellen Page is NOT in any way flakey. She is an amazing actress, and in all the interveiws I have heard her in she is right on topic she adresses some issues and overall she is almost as good at interviewing as she is at acting. (And as I said she is an incredible actress). Oh by the way greg if that is your name Ellen Page is not a lesbien, where ever you got that gay idea is beyond me. It was very upsetting to me to see that you left such a rude and iggnorant message about this incredible young actress, and i hope you never comment on something, again, that you obviously know nothing about. Also to Gene I don’t know what kind of kids you listen to but my friends and i could totally relate to the film after we saw it.
-Why dont people get Juno, its one of the most amazing films ever.
Poor Brad Renfro. He didn’t even get an obit clip.
Actually, Jon Stewart was really solid all night long. Lots of great jokes, mostly very smooth transitions. “Gadolf Titler” killed in the room I was watching in. No palpable sense of the nervousness you describe from the audience coming through the tv screen. That sounds like you were looking for something that wasn’t there. I honestly don’t know what people expect from the Oscar host. If we continue to be this snarky and unfairly dicky about it, nobody good will ever do it, ’cause it’s kind of a no-win situation.
Why all the Jon Stewart hate? Does he owe you money or something? Jeez. From every indication he’s a genuinely funny, nice, and decent guy. Do you generally find that sort of person off-putting?
I think he did a fantastic job, considering he had all of, what, a week and a half to prepare? I can understand not liking someone, but you seem to have a lot of preconceived notions about him that simply aren’t the case. Unless of course we’re talking about two different people.
For the record, he was pretty much the only reason I watched. I can also tell you I’m not the only one who felt that way.
What a snore fest — imagine how boring it would’ve been if Gil Cates had more time to prepare. Shudder the thought. Damn those pesky writers for settling the strike and allowing this crap to go on as schedule.
The “best films” of the year and none of them were deserving of the nomination–though you could clearly see how hard they tried to be Oscar worthy.
“Once” won for best song. Hurray! It deserved to get an Indie Spirit Award or recognition by the Golden Globes. A film made for $166K? Just shows how a wonderful film can get made when all that matters is story and not studio politics or interference.
I think there should be a special category for: The People Who Saved Hollywood.
And the Oscar goes to:
Actor: A Certain Group of A-Lists Actors (for their collective work at attempting union bustering)
Director: Gil Cates (for making the boring even more boring)
Writer: Diablo Cody (for being the official spokesperson for the writing community)
There was hardly any applause from the audience when Hanks introduced who was going to present the awards (the troops in Iraq). I think it was a stretch for you to say that “Hollywood does, too, care about the troops”.
I have to agree with a lot of the posts here– your recap is pretty snarky– you seem like you really have an axe to grind, and I wonder why some of these people posting here bother with the academy awards at all; they seem to completely hate them and the film industry as well- go get a hobby and focus on the stuff you do like.
John Stewart was fine- there were some good laughs. And “Falling Slowly’s” win was one of those great upsets. It’s cynical to assume Stewart only had Marketa Irglovia come out again to pretend he is a nice guy. She didn’t just get cut off, they didn’t even let her start.
Nikki, I read you every day. I think your writing, sense of humor, and ability to tell it like it is are fantastic. But this live blog was the MOST cynical and derisive I’ve ever read from you. And frankly, unfounded in most parts. The two I take most issue with are your mocking tone of Glen Hansard and Marketa Irglova. Their’s is truly a wonderful story and should be celebrated, not made fun of. In addition, given all the circumstances you must really have some personal bitterness toward Jon Stewart to pan him as you did. What do you want from him in 8 days? He clearly doesn’t even like doing the show, but was gracious enough to accept it again. You love all the corny song and dance numbers by the host that takes up all the time? He kept it snappy and had some good jokes. Try and get back to being more level-headed this week. Thanks
Stewart was excellent, taking full advantage this time and doing what he does best.
When you have to perform in front of several hundred million, he did it with style pushing the envelope.
When you hide behind a faceless blog, spewing snide comments to a few thousand readers, you do it with… snide comments. I’m surprised you don’t have a best-dressed list.
*whoops – that was a snide comment from a faceless poster. How redundant.*
The reviews are in for Jon Stewart, and they are quite good:
Review: Stewart saves sluggish Oscars
http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20080225/ap_en_ot/oscars_tv_review
Readers peg it: Stewart shines as host
http://www.medialifemagazine.com/artman2/publish/Television_44/Readers_peg_it_Stewart_shines_as_host.asp
In the great words of Nikki Finke: Toldya!
I haven’t laid eyes on the comments yet but I have to say I was nauseated by the constant FAWNING and DROOLING over George Clooney by not only those in attendance but especially by those idiots holding microphones on the red carpet for E! My God, if Jesus Christ came back from the dead, he wouldn’t get half the response Clooney got. I mean, Clooney isn’t even attractive nowadays and he was never much of an actor (too smug). Even without Daniel Day-Lewis, he wouldn’t have won the Oscar.
Perhaps the American actors might want to look at themselves and their general bad acting now that all four acting Oscars this year went to non-Americans. As Marion Cotillard proved, it’s so much easier for the audience to believe you in the role when they don’t know everything there is to know about you thanks to running to the media at every five minutes to give updates on what you had for lunch, what you think of the world in general, and your last bowel movement.
Class. That’s what the non-American acting winners had.
Anyone who thinks Jon Stewart is a step down as an oscar host has a selective memory. Don’t you remember Billy Crystal’s long horrible opening song and dance numbers? Whoopi Goldberg’s constant stream of clunky out-of-date Bruce Villanch jokes?
And let’s not forget the Chris Rock oscars, the worst oscars in recent memory. Not just because he was a terrible choice for a host but also because that was the oscars when they decided to have all the nominees stand on stage as they read the winner. The most awkward four hours anyone has ever seen.
Jon made a few decent jokes, no really painful ones (see Billy and Whoopi) and kept the show moving. I’d say the order of recent hosts from best to worst goes something like 1. Steve Martin 2. Jon Stewart 3. Billy Crystal 4. Ellen Degeneres 5. David Letterman (he had a couple of painful moments that everyone remembers but the rest of the show wasn’t bad) 6. Whoopi Goldberg 7. Chris Rock.
CBS is able to do it every year with the Tonys.
I’m no grandma, and I have only vaguely heard of Miley Cyrus
It was odd for her to present – a clear self-serving plug for Disney
Jon was terribly unfunny and ill at ease. The black President joke is old and has been done by stand-ups for years in various forms. It was sweet to bring the Czech half of the Once team back to speak but I’ll bet that was a command decision in the booth to at least try to inject some youth into the show. Cate Blanchett may have been one of many Dylans but Tilda Swinton IS David Bowie! Diablo, or should I say Brooke Busey, nice self-serving line about your parents loving you “just the way you are”. You’re so wacky and outrageous, like Homer Simpson explaining the mystique of Poochie. You rock, Riot Gurrrrl! (to coin yet another phrase Jon can use on next year’s show, God forbid.) Nice Ming the Merciless hair thing on Travolta and Paul Thomas did not look happy when he lost. Clearly, Xenu had his inter-galactic mind on other things. Probably those souls in the volcanoes with the hydrogen bombs raining down. Robert Boyle, I’m glad you’re alive and I’m glaad you worked on so many good films. But if ever an ad-lib was needed after his long, long, long No Country for Old Men crossed with Away from Her speech, that was the moment. Just fucking do it and after the laughs, apologize a bit. Or not. But God, he had more lines than the first twenty minutes of There Will Be Blood. Please tell Jonah Hill and Seth Rogen that no matter the fame, the money, they will always look as if they are just about to be bar mitzvahed. As for hosts for future Oscars – there are only two choices and the Academy will not go for either – Sarah Silverman or Jimmy Kimmel. Or both. Who wouldn’t watch the couple who did I’m F***ing Matt Damon/Ben Affleck do the Oscars? Failing that, perhaps Steve Carrell. But Jon, love you on TDS but last night you sucked, big time.
Re Jon Stewart…Lighten up there. You seem to forget how bad Dave Letterman, Chris Rock, Whoopi Goldberg, and Ellen Degeneres Did. Billy Crystal and Steve Martin got better reviews, but they are also Academy members and they have more freedom to do as they wish (as well as months to prepare).
And remember, the audience is the biggest bunch of politically correct Nervous Nellies, they never laugh at anything. The TV pubic, however, did laugh, and laugh hard.
Jon Stewart is one of the best hosts Oscar has ever had. I don’t know what show you’re watching, but you seem to be wrong on almost every comment. – The things you find endearing or clever are just lame drivel, while anything entertaining you call pathetic. *** Oh, and not EVERYTHING has to do with the writer’s strike. Get over it, already!
This site suddenly became relevant at the beginning of the strike, when Nikki was actually posting news. Then it became a litany of excuses why she wasn’t posting news. Now, it’s little more than bitter schadenfreude in post after post. Nikki clearly made up her mind in advance that this year’s Oscars were going to suck, and nothing could have happened to convince her otherwise.
Jon Stewart was affable and charming. He’s not fake and doesn’t pretend to be anything he isn’t (he’d probably be the first to agree with those of you who think he sucked). He wasn’t given great material to work with, but you can’t blame him for that, and it certainly doesn’t mean he shouldn’t be given another chance. As the poster above mentioned, try imagining Ryan Seacrest or someone else equally vapid in the hosting spot and you may find Jon Stewart a little more palatable.
Love to see Bardem winning, he comes from a family of actors, it was great seeing him with his mother. Olé Javier…. most of you talking here works around Hollywood, why are you complaining so much???
Ever notice the people that complain the Oscars are always too long are the SAME people who complain when they limit speech time or cut people off?
This means you, Nikki.
Not to mention you complain about the usual live segments not being here this year. What, you want more shadow puppets?
You angry fuckers are never going enjoy this show.
Sparks could fly out of everyone’s ass to music & you’d still find something to bitch about.
Too much. Not enough.
Accept it. Move on.
I don’t know what you’re talking about, Jon Stewart was very good. He was subtle in his delivery (things like the deadpan “that was amazing”) so you may have missed a lot of it…
Also, this oscars wasn’t great, but it was better than several of the previous years. In fact, I think the collection of films here is way stronger than usual, and most people I know have seen at least of the Best Picture nominated films, which is not usually true…
Clearly, the folks who don’t understand critical appraisal are out in force. Saying Jon was a better host than some of the terrible hosts of the past in no way is critical appraisal. Classic case of damning with faint, barely audible, praise. Talk about what he did or did not do in relation to how good or how funny he has been or can be. And knowing that, by every measure, Jon came up lacking last night. And Tom Shales manages to “misremember” ala Roger Clemens that the Coen Bros. did The Big Lebowski when he lists their comedy chops and mentions one movie (granted, it’s a good one, their very own Warner Bros. cartoon comedy-Raising Arizona). Jon, we make up one tenth of one percent of the world’s population. An Atonement/Day of Atonement joke? Next year try an Eid reference. It won’t get laughs either but at least it will be the sound of a billion and a half Muslims not laughing.
Wow, you could not be more wrong on so many counts…This year’s crop of films is great compared to past years and Jon Stewart is very good, obviously above your intelligence level
Nikki,
As usual, you are a wonderful go-to for information about the event, but your actual analysis on the Oscars is quite frustrating.
At times you are dead-on with commentary on the Academy Awards (rent some DVDs, Bee Movie, Mirren), but your supreme bias against Jon Stewart and apparent dislike for the writer-performer duo of “Once” just demonstrates a form of almost childlike rhetoric. Some might call it petty or even downright “bat-shit” crazy.
Having never written on here before, I would like to state that I was right there with you on the writer’s strike, but our perspectives on what constitutes art certainly differ. I can’t begrudge you on the validity of your own opinion, but I only wish you could articulate your reasoning in a way that doesn’t make you sound like Jan Brady.
Overall: I believe you are allergic to irony, I wonder if you really thought “Michael Clayton” was a better movie than “No Country for Old Men,” and am slightly interested/terrified of what your ideal version of the Oscars would look like.
I don’t believe this should be the last time we see Stewart hosting the Oscars–and challenge you to even create a list of three other hosting candidates who could do a better job.
Cheers,
Raf
Jon Stewart rocked as Oscar host.
Why don’t you and Tom Shales go eat it, Nikki!!!
I thought this was the Emmys for all the TV actors on the red carpet.
Why was Heidi Klum there and don’t Hollywood have any Alist celebrities any more. Oh, I forgot Hollywood is too ashamed to vote for Americans so year after year it’s the celebration of European actors.
Who in the eff cares about the Oscars, if the Oscars don’t care about their industry, then why should we give a rat azz.
Jon Stewart was pathetic. And everyone who claims he’s so much better than the Bruce Vilanch-aided Whoopi Goldberg and Ellen DeGeneres need to get a clue and realize that Bruce Vilanch writes the jokes no matter who hosts.
A 20% drop in viewership when Stewart is hosting says it all. If they keep bringing him back, the Oscars will eventually get the same lousy numbers as The Daily Show (about one million).
Quite frankly, the Oscar show would be much better (and shorter) if the host was gotten rid of all together and there was just a stream of Oscar winning movie stars (that everyone in the world will have heard of rather than the likes of Miley Cyrus who’s never done a single real movie – remember the good old days when a presenter had to be worthy of being a presenter?) handing out the awards. Lose the songs being performed (this is the Oscars and not the Grammys) and all the montages save for the obit montage and the show would run a couple of hours and people might watch it again.
Getting the likes of Katherine Heigl and Patrick Dempsey and Miley Cyrus to present Oscars is pathetic. Surely, Katherine and Patrick have done movies but they’re not famous the world over or have done any films that are memorable five minutes after you’ve finished watching them.
Brad Renfro being dissed (not being in the obit montage even though he died a week before Heath Ledger who was included) is shameful. Even more so considering someone decided that anyone gives a shit if some agents or executive nobody’s ever heard of kicked the bucket.
Someone needs to do something about the blathering idiots surrounding the red carpet. No, not the fans in the bleachers. The twits like Regis Philbin and Ryan Seacrest who constantly made me want to take a baseball bat to their faces what with their idiotic comments and gushing over certain no-talents.
Bad ratings? I’m so surprised. Two reasons: First – The nominated films are not main stream entertainment anymore even though more people are watching more movies than ever before! Why? because the movies people are watching now are so fragmented and niche that one award show about a few nominees and a handful of actors is not relevant to them. Secondly – The ratings sucked because the production sucked! John Stewart was dying up there, the writing pathetic, the pacing awkward, the music drab and most of the winners were so self absorbed that they came prepared with absolutely nothing to say!! What a embarrassment to the industry. The show was a complete dog. I mean how many times are they going to seat Jack Nicolson in front of the audience and throw to him just to bail out the host? The show needs to be more about movies than about the people who make them because the people who make them are boring. The Oscars should feature more movies in more genres and awards be given out to the end product only. Leave the stars out of it. I think the show hit its peak with Billy Crystal and it will never be that great again. He knew how to deliver the Oscars! Bring him back and pay him as much as he wants to produce the Awards OR sell the show to cable and let it fade away. It’s not prime time faire. No one cares anymore.
I’m gonna join the hit-back on the Jon Stewart criticism here. He had one joke that outright bombed (and that nearly got him shouted off the stage), but the shift to political jokes halfway in was a good idea – the crowd inside the theater is Hollywood, but some of those watching on television (notably, what very few there were) had to be watching because it was John Stewart, host of the Daily Show. That calls for some amount of Daily Show Certified Political Humor.
I would’ve held back the snark on him actually allowing someone to speak up there, too. Whoever’s time-limiting these speeches needs a new job; I would recommend to him or her the position of American Gladiators ref. Feel free to diss his ad-lib segments – this saved him one, thankfully, and turned out very well.
I think they can cut the show preamble down. I avoided most of that, and wished I could avoid more, like, well, ALL OF IT.. I thought the intro, as much as it covered the many movies of years past, sucked. I do agree with the mock video segments of what might have been with no writers needing to be longer and more painful to get the joke across. I wanted at least one bad dream take with the guy falling off the bed from the rude awakening, not to mention at least *one* clip of Nightmare on Elm Street.
I get the feeling that Helen Mirren didn’t review her lines before seeing what was written. She got really quiet and ashamed around the point where she said “studio head”. So much for the makeup sex. *cough*
MArk,
People are not watching more movies than ever before. Where did your get that stat? In the days before television people would average one or two trips to the movies a week.
lots of omissions on the ‘in memoriam’ segment. I was sad not to see a friend of mine in there, his name was Ronald Shedlo, he produced eight films which got three Oscar nominations in all, but also lots of BAFTAs and two awards in Cannes… well, I guess the Academy got its last chance to overlook him again!
Nikki – wow why did you bother blogging the Oscars when it appears you don’t enjoy watching them. It one thing to be catty -we all can be – but you were down right mean.
Jon Stewart was great. He had some very funny jokes. And the audience laughter I heard did not sound ‘nervous’.
I loved Once and was thrilled that the song won, and Jon called Marketa Irglova back to give her speech.
If you don’t enjoy the Oscars – don’t watch them and don’t waste your time posting about how awful they are.