The reason, according to today's unexpected announcement (made while I was gone for the afternoon), is because the MPTF's acute care hospital and long term care nursing home are losing $10 million a year. "This shortfall is expected to widen significantly in coming years. The problem is that the vast majority of hospital and LTC patients are covered by government insurance programs whose reimbursement rates have not kept pace with fast-rising operating costs. MPTF has been making up the shortfall by dipping into its investment reserves. Based on current projections, continuing to subsidize the hospital and LTC facility would likely exhaust available reserves within five years." About 100 retirees currently live in the MPTF home in Woodland Hills with what I know to be a waiting list. (Everyone I talk to always says there are not enough MPTF health care facilities, not too many!) Yet the MPTF's press release claims that the closures come because of "declining demand" and that MPTF’s acute-care hospital "for the past few years has rarely been called upon to care for more than ten patients at any one time". It says these closure decisions are the "result of more than three years of study and analysis by MPTF staff and outside experts".
So much for the Motion Picture & Television Fund's promise of "unwavering commitment" to the entertainment industry, and vice versa. This is a huge story with major ramifications for everyone who considered the Motion Picture And Television Fund facilities as their safety net in times of sickness and old age. What else might be closed next? I find it hard to believe that, with all the enormous wealth in the Hollywood, the community couldn't look after its own better than this. “MPTF is initiating these changes because it’s the right thing to do, but the fact is that we have no choice,” Jeffrey Katzenberg, chairman of the MPTF Foundation Board, said in the statement. “Although we are in good shape today, the acute-care hospital and long-term care facility are generating operating deficits that could bankrupt MPTF in a very few years." C'mon, there are fundraisers all the time, including that big-ticket Saturday "Night Before" the Oscars party hosted by Katzenberg himself. For crissakes, the old Motion Picture Relief Fund was founded back in 1921 by Hollywood luminaries Mary Pickford, Charlie Chaplin, Douglas Fairbanks and D.W. Griffith to help people in the entertainment industry who fell on hard times. How can this be happening now? I am really sick about this, just sick.
As a result of the planned phase-outs, the 100 patients currently residing in the long-term care facility on MPTF’s Wasserman campus in Woodland Hills will be "relocated over the course of 2009 to selected nursing homes in and around Los Angeles. Every patient will be evaluated individually and matched to the most appropriate facility in the area for their particular needs and family situation. The first transfers will not begin for at least 60 days, unless a patient specifically requests to be moved sooner." MPTF’s acute-care hospital, begun in the 1940s, will continue to operate until late 2009. Thereafter, acute-care patients will receive their care at hospitals near MPTF’s Woodland Hills campus. The statement said the phase-out of the hospital and LTC unit will not affect the approximately 185 residents of MPTF’s independent- and assisted-living facilities (including the Country House, the Fran & Ray Stark Villas, and the Frances Goldwyn Lodge). MPTF’s six area health centers, which serve some 60,000 industry workers and their families, will be similarly unaffected. The Fund also intends to continue operating its Harry’s Haven memory care facility.
Dr. David Tillman, MPTF's president and chief executive, said the impending closure "reflects some sobering economic realities that are affecting healthcare institutions nationwide." To try to limit the problem of phasing out its hospital and nursing home operations, MPTF said today it will expand its community-based efforts. These efforts include the creation of "teams" to deliver services to retirees at their homes or care facilities. "Our emphasis on community-based care reflects the growing desire of today's active seniors to live as independently as possible for as long as possible," Tillman said. Nice try, guys, to put the best face on a bad situation. Here is the announcement which shamefully tries to sugar-coat things:
MOTION PICTURE & TELEVISION FUND TO PUT NEW EMPHASIS ON COMMUNITY-BASED CARE FOR SENIORS
Declining Demand and Challenging Economic Outlook Force Decision To Phase Out Acute-Care Hospital and Long-Term Care Unit
WOODLAND HILLS, CA – January 14, 2009 – The Motion Picture & Television Fund (MPTF), the entertainment industry’s premier health and social services charity, announced today a major realignment of resources under which the Fund’s acute-care hospital and long-term care (LTC) facility will be phased out in favor of community-based programs aimed at assisting the growing number of seniors who prefer to “age in place”—that is, live safely and independently in their own homes for as long as possible.
As part of this realignment, MPTF will be expanding its existing community-based efforts by establishing a network of Community Care Teams that will bring a variety of medical and social services to entertainment industry retirees—whether they live in their own homes, in retirement communities, or in long-term care facilities. At the same time, MPTF will be making plans to modernize and improve its independent- and assisted-living residential facilities.
Driven by the changing needs of the population MPTF serves — as well as an increasingly dire economic outlook — the decision to concentrate on community-based care is the result of more than three years of study and analysis by MPTF staff and outside experts.
“The world is changing and MPTF has been changing with it,” said Frank G. Mancuso, chairman of the MPTF Corporate Board. “For nearly 90 years, we have embodied Hollywood’s unique commitment to taking care of its own. Focusing on a community-based approach will allow us to continue honoring this commitment for another 90 years.”
“Our new emphasis on community-based care reflects the growing desire of today’s active seniors to live as independently as possible for as long as possible,” said David Tillman, M.D., president and CEO of MPTF. “It also reflects some sobering economic realities that are affecting healthcare institutions nationwide. With costs skyrocketing and government reimbursement declining, operating our own acute-care hospital and long-term care facility is draining our resources at an alarming rate. The good news is that by emphasizing a community-based approach to senior care, MPTF will not only be able to stay on a solid financial footing, it will also be able to assist many more retirees than we do now—thousands rather than hundreds.”
“MPTF is initiating these changes because it’s the right thing to do, but the fact is that we have no choice,” added Jeffrey Katzenberg, chairman of the MPTF Foundation Board. “Although we are in good shape today, the acute-care hospital and long-term care facility are generating operating deficits that could bankrupt MPTF in a very few years. The entertainment community depends on MPTF for a wide range of social and medical services—everything from healthcare to emergency financial assistance to childcare and family counseling—and if MPTF doesn’t do something now, pretty soon it won’t be able to do anything.”
“These changes will safeguard MPTF’s ability to continue meeting our community’s medical and social service needs for decades to come,” said Casey Wasserman, chairman of the Wasserman Foundation, one of MPTF’s biggest benefactors. “MPTF’s willingness to confront these challenging issues head on—and its ability to come up with creative solutions—makes it more deserving than ever of our support.” Wasserman emphasized that this view is shared by his grandmother, current MPTF Board Trustee Edie Wasserman, who along with her late husband Lew Wasserman has long been one of the organization’s most passionate and dedicated supporters.
MPTF’s new emphasis on community-based care will build on existing efforts such as its Elder Connection program and Center for Aging, which provide social, financial, and healthcare services for industry seniors who want to remain in their own homes. The centerpiece will be a new network of Community Care Teams, consisting of MPTF doctors, nurses, and social workers who will reach out to Fund-eligible seniors in Southern California, whether they are in their own homes, in retirement communities, or in outside nursing homes, to ensure they are getting the support they need.
As a result of the planned phase-outs, approximately 100 patients currently residing in the long-term care facility on MPTF’s Wasserman campus in Woodland Hills will be relocated over the course of 2009 to selected nursing homes in and around Los Angeles. Every patient will be evaluated individually and matched to the most appropriate facility in the area for their particular needs and family situation. The first transfers will not begin for at least 60 days, unless a patient specifically requests to be moved sooner.
“Closing our long-term care facility does not alter MPTF’s historical commitment to industry veterans and their families,” Dr. Tillman said. “We’ll still be there for our people to make sure they get the care they need and deserve. We will work closely with all our current patients and their families to ensure a safe and successful transition for everyone. Once they are relocated, our Community Care Teams will visit them regularly. We will offer the same service to all Fund-eligible patients who might need long-term care in the future.”
MPTF’s acute-care hospital, which for the past few years has rarely been called upon to care for more than ten patients at any one time, will continue to operate until late 2009. Thereafter, acute-care patients will receive their care at hospitals near MPTF’s Woodland Hills campus.
The phase-out of the hospital and LTC unit will not affect the approximately 185 residents of MPTF’s independent- and assisted-living facilities (including the Country House, the Fran & Ray Stark Villas, and the Frances Goldwyn Lodge). MPTF’s six area health centers, which serve some 60,000 industry workers and their families, will be similarly unaffected. The Fund also intends to continue operating its Harry’s Haven memory care facility.
As a result of the hospital and LTC facility phase-outs, some 290 jobs will be eliminated over the course of the year. This represents roughly a third of all MPTF’s hourly workers and a third of its managerial staff. MPTF will provide out-placement counseling and host job fairs in an effort to help all the displaced workers find new employment.
The hospital and long-term care facility currently generate an operating deficit of $10 million a year. This shortfall is expected to widen significantly in coming years. The problem is that the vast majority of hospital and LTC patients are covered by government insurance programs whose reimbursement rates have not kept pace with fast-rising operating costs.
MPTF has been making up the shortfall by dipping into its investment reserves. Based on current projections, continuing to subsidize the hospital and LTC facility would likely exhaust available reserves within five years.
The non-profit Motion Picture & Television Fund, headquartered in Woodland Hills, was founded in 1921 to provide relief for those in the film industry who had fallen on hard times. Today, 88 years later, MPTF is a major service provider supporting the health and well being of the entertainment community. Healthcare, childcare, retirement living and social/charitable services are offered with compassion and respect for the dignity of the whole person. Care is offered through six outpatient health centers, charitable financial assistance and community outreach programs, a full-scale retirement community. and a children’s day care center.


If Hollywood ever made any attempts to try and look a little less heartless, they’re futile now.
It’s absurd Nikki, I agree.
that’s so unbelievably sad. Nice way to pay tribute to many hard working folks who have spent many, many years devoting themselves to the film/entertainment biz…
That’s awful news.
But a sad symptom of Hollywood’s increasing inability to handle money. I mean show-biz creates lots of insanely wealthy people, billions of dollars flow through the industry every year, but no one seems to have the money to maintain their own health care/retirement safety net.
No one in any position of power in Hollywood seems remotely capable of thinking beyond their immediate wants and what their next fat check can bring them. They seem to think that the big money, fancy cars, and paparazzi buzzing around them like flies around the carcass of a buffalo will last forever. They can’t seem to think that they are one bad accident, or career or financial disaster from needing the services of the hospital and the nursing home themselves.
It’s like the moment anyone has any success in Hollywood, from the boardroom, to the soundstage, they immediately mentally regress to two years old, and lose the ability to think about the future.
I agree. is hollywood that selfish to where all these actors make million of films and they cant even keep a facility & hospital open for the elderly in the business? thats bad! I hope they read these comments. these families have to fight real hard to keep the place open. all hollywodd worries about is the money that goes into there pockets. thats it.
This is a grotesque step by MPTF. Seniors who are able to stay in their own homes with the help of occasional visits are already doing so; the ones at the hospital and nursing home are those with no alternatives. And these are the very people who are least able to bear such changes in their lives. The health impact will be devastating.
Also, the timing is more than suspicious. Isn’t health care about to change, as a top priority of the new administration in Washington? MPTF can’t raise enough dollars to wait and see how those changes shake out? I don’t believe that for a minute.
Somebody needs to step in and change this — there are other ways of surviving the recession, other than pushing out the very people who are least able to bear such treatment.
Shame – shame – shame !!!
You put it correctly Nikki, with all the wealth around, some of it should be given back by those that have become very wealthy in the entertainment business. However, a 10 million deficit for 100 patients works out to about $100,000. per patient. That seems very inefficient to me — is that amount possible?.
Bear Stearns, AIG, Citicorp, Lehman Bros., Wachovia, Washington Mutual, etc. — money-losing banks all gone.
RKO, Carolco, Republic, Artisan, Weintraub, etc. —money-losing studios all gone.
Why, exactly, does the demise of a money-losing hospital surprise anyone?
Katzenberg was a major benefactor of the MP&TV Fund. He recently divulged that he lost upwards of $20 million in the Madoff scandal adding that it “would severely impact his philanthropy.” A few days later, this gets announced. Coincidence? I think not…
many of our biggest stars are generous, altuistic people
who help folks in need all over the world.
perhaps some of them will be moved enough by this development
to pitch in and help us take tare of our people right here at home.
What was that movie which inspired Spielberg as a child, with the famous train crash sequence? The widow of the guy who made that lives up there in that community.
They may not all be famous, but they were the ones who made Hollywood. Shame this town doesn’t have the resources to take care of them now.
After so many years of helping those in need, this is really depressing and sad. I really hope that someone will come to the rescue.
there are some in our industry that we in the rest make look good and they make huge amounts of money!… they will never need help!… there was a time when the STARS in our town understood this and made sure those were taken care of in their time of need…. how time have changed!
“GREED IS A BAD THING”
PMS
what a bunch of BS! Well what can you expect when the board is run by people like Jeffery Katzenberg, people so out of touch with reality the don’t recognize it anymore. They’re getting rid of the long term care patients and the hospital, so that the fund can survive? Thats the only reason for them to exist! The patients are the human beings, the ones that need help and saving- not the Fund. The MPTF is not a person it does not exist for itself, only to serve. Why not just do away with the whole thing! Wow I strongly suggest that anyone that gives a crap, or ever thought that they might need a “soft place to fall” when they’re time in this biz is done get everyone they know sending protest emails right away.
um, jeffery katzenberg is a moron. put someone in there that would know how to handle funds and keep the place open. if the places closes I think that shows had bad hollywood is on selfishness. all they think about is what goes into there pockets and what kind of bills can they run up on rodeo drive and who is getting arrest for what fight or what drug now. they need to take care of the elderly. my dad has demenia and if I knew that his facility was closing becasue of greed, I would be raising hell. hollywood has money, they just done want to spend it on this place and that is so sad.
Among the many things I find thoroughly shocking about this is the concept that our hospital is “losing” money – as opposed to costing us money.
Duh!!
Heaven help anyone who used to work in the biz who gets Alzheimers or a dementia type illness and doesn’t have the money to pay for private care. Because if the person who develops Alzheimers lives to the middle or the end stage of the disease ‘community based care’ simply will not do. Middle stage AD patients wander, they get agitated, sometimes they even get aggressive. They end up needing to live in a locked facility and seen to by extremely caring and specially trained people, people who know how to deal with AD behaviors. And end stage AD patients forget how to swallow (and finally to breathe) and have to be hospitalized to receive proper care.
With the aging of baby-boomers it is projected that 1 out of 8 Americans over 65 will have AD or a similar type illness. And ~60% of Americans over 65 will need long term care at some point in their lives. Dumping them back onto Medicare & Medicaid is not the answer. Losing even only 100 beds in one nursing home is exactly the wrong thing to have happen as the first baby-boomers are 2 years away from reaching 65.
If I remember correctly, there is a street named after Steven Spielberg which runs through the property in Woodland Hills.
Didn’t Jodie Foster just give a big ol donation to them recently?
Named something after her too, I think.
Keep us updated on this Nikki. It’s such a shame that this is happening.
I suggest anyone who gives a crap about this get everyone they know to start bombarding the MPTF with outraged emails. What a bunch of Bullshit! These patients and there are about 160 of them have signed over their entire pensions in exchange for the peace of mind, knowing that they would be taken care of when they could’nt do it for themseves anymore. Not so that they could be shuffled off to some strange place when they could speak for themselves! The MPTF is for them. They are the human beings, not some cancer to be cut out to save an otherwise healthy Fund!
I suggest anyone who gives a crap about this get everyone they know to start bombarding the MPTF with outraged emails. What a bunch of Bullshit! These patients and there are about 160 of them have signed over their entire pensions in exchange for the peace of mind knowing that they would be taken care of when they could’nt do it for themseves anymore. Not so that they could be shuffled off to some strange place when they could speak for themselves! The MPTF is for them. They are the human beings, not some cancer to be cut out to save an otherwise healthy Fund!
This is a shonda. Where were the stories about the imminent doom? I was always under the impression that this institution was supported — and generously by the community — with fundraising activities like The Night Before Party. Even in the worst of economic times, I find it hard to believe that anyone will let this important part of our industry just shutter.
Losing a whopping $10 Million a year? Wow, with how many A-listers making $20-25 Million OR MORE per PICTURE? How ever can we afford to lose $10 Million a year?
There’s no question that this closure is tied to the proposed increase to 400 Qualifying Hours in the tentative Hollywood Basic Agreement. The corporate media monopolies have decided to “help” spur the government along towards some form of National Health Care by eliminating thousands of covered participants and their dependents, as well as the elderly, retired and infirm.
As if the outsourcing of our jobs over the last decade wasn’t bad enough…it obviously wasn’t.
I think I’m going to be sick.
Hey maybe instead of giving million to Obama and the democrats the hollywooders should use that money to take care of their own.
We live in a vulgar age.
Looks like their famous slogan, “We take care of our own,” cuts both ways.
So the Hollywood elites have no problem ponying up millions for Obama when he comes to town, but they can’t scrape anything together to take care of their own?
Where’s the benefit concert, the telethon, or just simple fundraising? How much do the gift baskets at the Oscars cost?
Disgusting.
this is very sad… so many former patients are turning in their graves. I know someone who worked on Thelma & Louis whose family enjoyed the benefits of this care. Now does everyone have to drive off the cliff??? There is no trust anymore with anyone.
And people say that Hollywood has no soul…..
I am one of the over 300 employees who will be losing their job. All of us who work there are like a family and treat our patients as a part of that family.Besides kicking people out of their home,many people use the hospital versus other local hospitals because of nursing care they receive from us!This is a very sad day.Please voice protests to people that count.At least let them know how devastating this is for the people who were counting on MPTV.
I am sorry to hear that you will loose your job. you all need to fight to keep this place open. all these biggies that make 20 million a picture, please give me a break. hollywood is going to have a bad rep if something isnt done. all the big money and they cant even take care of there own, thats sad and pathetic. all the big wig stars and huge homes and luxury cars, etc….but they cant even take care of there own and make sure that the place stays open and high quality care, how sad……that just goes to show you that hollywood only cares about the money that goes into there pockets…
Fess up — how many of us have ever personally donated to the MPTF? I can raise my hand (and no, I didn’t attend a fundraiser to do so).
Maybe instead of “flooding” MPTF with emails demanding that “someone” do “something,” what if every one of us donates $100 to keep the facility afloat? I’ve read that there are 200K of us here in LA. Do the math — we could cover the shortfall. If others are able, and want, to give more, blessings/karma to them. But why is it only “their” responsibility, never ours?
To answer a couple of posters, it’s not unimaginable for MPTF to be losing $10M per year: In 2003 we paid $92K/year for longterm care. IF your pension is $2K/month (25 years @2K hours per), and IF your social security is also $2K/month, we’re looking at MPTF having a $7M/year deficit for 160 patients. That $3M difference is ever so suspicious, or maybe: health care costs have increased since 2003, it’s a great facility, their patients’ pensions and social security don’t average $4K/month.
So I’m just saying, don’t assume this closure is directly related to Katzenberg’s investments or the 400 hours issue. Maybe it really is about dollars and cents, level of care, and how much each of us is willing to contribute (aside from words) for a colleague’s care …
Who are the “We” in “We Take Care Of Our Own?”
I’ve heard the SAG Foundation isn’t even sure it can continue helping struggling performers. The need for help is far outstripping contributions. Look into it Nikki… I hope you find out my info is wrong.
For a Board staffed with industry “titans” obsessed with “image” who spend hundreds of millions every year to promote and advertise themselves and this industry, it is incomprehensible that they would spring this on everyone in so callous a manner. Where is the leadership? What did 3 years of “study” address? Did they consider structural changes in the way they operate short of tossing out 100 lost souls? Could they not have decided to phase out the operation by not accepting new patients but caring for those who are at the Fund until their end comes thereby avoiding a “perpetual” 10 million annual “loss”.? (That, of course, begs the issue of “caring for our own”. ) What about a “special appeal” to the industry at large to save these hundred folks? What about examining other areas of the Fund’s operations. Was there one scintilla of humanity factored into what appears to be a callous business decision that any freshman business school major could have made? Don’t let this happen!!!
This is absolutely outrageous! Most people in Hollywood DO NOT make it big. That hospital is their safety net. The end of a line for little people who give it all so the “fat cats” can make the big bucks.
This is so wrong on so many levels. Now this is something SAG MUST do something about. I would even hope they would shut down the town over this one.
I suspect there is MORE at play here. As soon as they shut down the hospital they will probably sell the acreage for a wonderful price, so these “philanthropists” no longer have to help out the “fund.”
I know what you’re up to Katzenberg and friends. Gawd, you people are so transparent. You’re going to sell it. Save the fund. Put the people into someone else’s facility.
Yeah, right move if you don’t give a damn.
I can only hope this is a tactic to get the community outraged enough to rally in support of the hospital. A big Fund Raiser Is a great idea. It could be televised and bring together our greatest talents. A major campaign could also help pull our community together.
In the early days of the MPTF it was the norm to automatically donate a small percentage of your weekly pay check to the fund. It was those small amounts from grips, editors, prop makers, etc that came in on a regular basis that funded the hospital etc. The practice was all but gone by the mid 1970’s. The leadership of the MPTF dropped the ball and failed to reach out to the new generation of film school educated directors, writers,and support personal. I can only hope and pray your passionate writing will motivate people. I also don’t think name calling and attacks on people who have been very generous in the past is helpful.
My mother is a resident in this fantastic facility and I know she, along with the other residents will be devastated. BUT, please everyone this is a difficult decision for those who run the home. Be kind. It is because of the government not paying their bills on time. Don’t throw these hard working, wonderful people under the bus. Find a way to help.
dude, there is absolutely no reason why they have to shut down a facility because of funding. I dont see nursing homes in my town in florida being shut down due to funds. jeffrey katzenbery needs to be thrown under a bus. with all the big wig money that comes into that town, donations cant help? these stars makes 20 million a pic and cant give some for the place? sorry, no sympathy. our govet is not good, but hollywood SHOULD take care of there own and they arent and its really really sad. they should be imbarrased by this, I know I would be. thnik about it
The MPTF is one of the finest and most dependable organizations we have in Los Angeles, without question. When I heard this, my heart sank, but I was not willing to cast blame on anything but the economy. This hits close to home for it is our community, and we have always felt that our sense of “community” in the entertainment industry is more intimate than many other businesses. True enough. But just as other businesses rise and fall with the vagaries of the economy, so does ours. Our views of ourselves can sometimes be quite insular. Both a blessing and a curse. A blessing because we treasure a sense of belonging; a curse, because forget we live in the larger world.
I firmly believe that help will surface within the industry, but that help is subject to the sea change in our economy which does not play favorites. Like dread diseases, it is mindless and it doesn’t discriminate. Everyone gets hit. Sometimes it takes a car crash to draw spectators to the scene. This is a car crash.
I have a problem with the postings I see conveniently blaming the intentions and motivations of “names” in the business. In fact, I have a problem with “blame.” It’s sophomoric and an easy out for not looking at complexity. Well, we are now involved in complexity with a capital “-plex-”
It’s right to be troubled and alarmed that such a thing could happen in an industry so dedicated to taking care of one’s own, but it’s pointless and self-serving to make uninformed charges.
My hope is that our fellow actors, producers, our union members of every stripe will be charged with the challenge to step forward in personal ways. After all, we are finally, FINALLY, with this new administration, entering a time when “service” and “caring” become honorable traits; praiseworthy and laudable, not something relegated to the Boy Scouts. I feel it’s possible that these principles will become meaningful in tangible ways. After all, we are all finally, in a really truly SAME boat.
Let’s just see what happens. C
I worked on a documentary at the home 10 or more years ago. One of the residents we met was the woman that got half a grapefruit shoved in her face by James Cagney. The Country Home itself is the nicest such facility I’ve ever seen, but unless it’s expanded there’ll be no room for the baby boomers.
There’s a couple of things missing in the press release. One is: how much assets did the fund lose in the panic, and is that the cause for all this? Our health fund lost 20%, but how they got off that light is beyond me. Also, they seemed to dance around the subject of whether they would pull the financial plug on existing patients who are evicted.
Other doctors and other hospitals take Medicare. What’s the fund’s problem with it? And if the U.S. can’t scrape up enough dough to fund Medicare, how could they possibly find the funds to give health care to all 304 million Americans? Maybe Obama should get Raul on the horn and order up a couple thousand Cuban doctors
And now that we see the direction things are taking we can only wonder what service of the fund will be cut next.
I’m sorry for the 290 layoffs. With people losing their health insurance and rising costs, they’re likely to have a hard time finding a similar job.
As a member of Local 700, I’d be willing to throw in $10/check to help support something like this. I’m just surprised it all came down to this so quickly– why wasn’t this brought up earlier when you could really DO something about this ahead of time? Instead, it feels like a fait accompli– and as such, smells fishy.
How sad is this? Millions spent on getting people elected to office but nothing can be spared for such a worthy cause as this? Banks and the auto industry are getting a bailout–why not here? Hollywood does not honor their own at all.
Having volunteered at the motion picture hospital throughout high school only to later be in the film business myself, this news is very, very sad. Is nothing sacred anymore in Hollywood?
Has the cult of efficiency in America really come to the point where we’re basically sending our elderly out on the modern equivalent of ice floes to die?
This is the first I’m hearing of this.
There are some unsung Hollywood legends in the Motion Picture Hospital who deserve better. Frankly, many of the patients will simply wind up in vastly downgraded facilities due to this decision.
I am surprised by the magnitude of the shortfall.
The only upside is the supposed promise of redistributing resources to community care – because even as comparatively great the MPTF facility is, its still a nursing home, and you don’t want to wind up there versus some sort of workable at home solution – if possible.
Frankly, and this is from someone who worked with the patients, those who are going to be most affected by this move will be those too far gone to completely understand what is happening – which is sad because its likely particularly dramatic on a late stage Alzheimer’s patients who don’t do well with change.
One reason given was a cut in state funding, but why the rush to close? There is strong support for including an increase in the federal medical assistance percentage (FMAP) in any upcoming economic stimulus package. Raising the FMAP would increase Medicaid funding to CA, which is threatening to cut Medi-Cal to make up for budget shortfalls.
Another reason was rising costs even though costs are falling around us daily, so why not renegotiate contracts, or look for alternative vendors?
Removing the most at-risk residents from their MPTF home and eliminating the long term program altogether seem like a last resort after all else fails. Where was the major fund raising campaign? Where was the cry for help? Nowhere.
Instead of attempting a viable solution, there is an abrupt disruption of lives, many more lives than the 100 stated. Why?
Let’s act now to stop this misdeed in its tracks and re-pledge to the commitment of taking care of our own.
Sad, but true..
I wish most ‘groups’ really ran their own retirement. India has group homes, for the infirmed/elderly…
My great-grandfather, silent film pioneer, Stanner E.V. Taylor and his wife, actress, Marion Leonard were among the first residents of the MPCH in 1941. Stanner wrote and Marion starred in the first film to be shot in Hollywood, D.W. Griffith’s “In Old California”.
They worked in NY and LA with D.W. Griffith, Mary Pickford and Lilian Gish and other early pioneers, forming their own production company and enjoying relative success. But like so many others they did not survive the transition to talkies and fell on hard times. The MPCH was a life-line to them and they spent the remainder of their lives there until 1948 and 1956 respectively.
It has always been a special place for me. This is very sad.
Rumor has it that it’s really all about the property’s valuable real estate potential! so sad…I have good memories visiting folks there…so lovely, with nice grounds…the only complaint I ever heard was the noise from motorcycles on Sundays.
Hollywood has never been a community that takes care of its own – it has always been a group of people who on a little luck and too much money make a career of taking care of #1. Look to the writers strike – how many writers who may be had some success 5, 10, 20 yrs ago and have been out of work too long, and never got a call or tossed a bone from a successful friend after they worked their butts off ‘on the line’? How many below the liners live in continuous fear that they will be thrown out on their ear because the “talent” decides to strike? How many struggling I-know-the-face actors either the ones on the upswing or the ones on the downturn ever get a helping hand by someone who got luckier?
Stars will throw millions at Obama, at their plastic surgeons, at their publicists, at their wedding planners for marriages that last a year or two but they ignore the down and out right under their noses.
Really makes me hope Mickey Rourke wins the Oscar – what it means to hit the skids in Hollywood needs a posterboy.
As a volunteer at the MPTF facility, I’m devastated. I spend time with people that processed the film, lit the stages, applied the pancake, played in the band. But that was then. Now, in old age, their commodities are dignity and time. The MPTF has been a godsend in providing comfort, respect, and attentive medical care.
I am gladdened by the sense of alarm that has been raised, but please don’t misdirect it at Messrs. Katzenberg, Spielberg, et al. They have taken a visible lead in supporting the MPTF. But they are not at fault for the ballooning cost of health care vis-à-vis a finite endowment. As we sometimes say on set, “all it takes is money”. We must seek greater contributions from our guilds, studios, vendors, distributors, exhibitors. If you are employed by this industry, there is a place for you (and your loved ones) at the MPTF….I mean there WAS a place for you. I’m an AD and I’ll be getting in touch with the DGA today. Who will you call?
please spare me, dont make excuses for hollywwod. they need to do something. I have lost all respect for hollywood if they dont save the home. rising health cost? well, I live in central florida and I never heard of any homes closing down due to the lack of money and hollywood has money. they are selfish and dont want to take care of there own.
Alright, so what do we do? Who can reverse this? How?
If anyone believes Jeffery “I never heard of Bernie Madoff” Katzenberg’s weak excuse for these closings, then they’re insane! I, along with thousands of others, have been voluntarily contributing automatically through our paychecks to this fund for many-many years…since 1960 myself. Who the hell put this little fox in our hen house! Immediately file for a complete and thorough audit of the books (both sets) and investigate the investment directions of the Chairman and the Board immediately and let the chips fall where they may!
This doesn’t look right. There’s no talk of closing some programs to keep others running. Just “it’s closing”, all of it. I’m disappointed and disturbed. This facility was one of the things that made me proud to be a member of the film community. All the people who are wealthy enough to pay for their own elder care are successful thanks to the work of the people who need this nursing home and services now or in the future. All those with money, knowledge, connections and resources to help this facility better keep that in mind.
So what are they going to do with the patients already there? Throw them out on the street like the cats and dogs that were given as Christmas gifts now that brat kids have tired of them?
In a perfect world, this whole fiasco would be deducted from SAG’s fees. Of course, that’ll never happen.
Yeah but if you do donate money to this, how are you going to know for sure that they money is going where it should? That’s the problem with this as well as most charities. There is no shortage of people “in charge” who grab the money the moment it comes it so it never gets to where it should. Someone said Jodie Foster just donated a fortune to them. Where’s that money? Someone needs to open the books and see WHERE the money went (and I seriously doubt it went to the patients). This is beyond disgusting. Meanwhile, Obama is spending a whopping $150 million on his porta-potty laden inauguration party in a few days.
What a bunch of Hollywood phonies.
“We take care of our own” what a bunch
of bull crap. That used to be the motto.
Maybe we should have another fund raiser
for Obama for president or prop 8 or
global warming or some such elitess
agenda. I’ll be happy to donate to a
“hollywood sucks” fund raiser.
Maybe we should have another awards show
so we can gawk and plaster our pathetic
pusses up on TV and tell everyone how
beautiful creative and caring we are.
Meanwhile we kick the people who are in
the worst shape and who have put there
all into this business out on the street
after being promised for years that we
had a safety net with the motion picture
hospital. I now hate to mention I’m at all
involved in this life sucking industry.
Great business if you’re one of the elite
at the top.
How shameless! What hypocrites
they need to look in the mirror. I don’t know
how they can live with themselves. I hope
they reap what they sow.
I don’t even know what to say. This is mind-boggling and wrong on so many levels. I just hope that the industry comes to their senses and support those that paved the way to their own success. I would love to see all the industry unions make provisions for the hospital as part of their contract talks. After all, once a union member, always a union member.
I’m sure that cutting 10% of the money Hollywood is spending to celebrate Obama’s inauguration could easily wipe out this deficit. I guess people only gripe about better ways to spend than political celebrations when it’s a republican being feted.
Park the gulfstreams and the yachts for a month and take care of your own.
This safety net was set up by people who *knew* how hard it was for creative people not to get shafted in the end.
Is this a lesson that needs to be relearned?
My father was in the industry for over 30 years. He did location process work and ending his career as the Chief Projectionist at Technicolor. He was also an industry member that paid into the fund when he was working. Five years ago, we placed him in the long term care facility. He has received wonderful care and there has always been a sense of family at MPTF! This is a horrific situation! There is a huge demand for long term care – from what I see they always have a full house. These are the very people who need MPTF the most! Those in the industry should stop this action! They are losing their safety net.
MPTF now wants to move these patients – this move alone could kill some of these patients. The vast majortiy these patients are relying on government assistance – what snake pit will that leave them to?
The industry needs to wake up and understand what is at risk here.
I agree. you need to keep fighting! my dad has dementia, I dare move him because no money, he lives in a nursing home in NJ. I live in florida and I never heard of any place closing down because “the lack of money”? please! HOLLYWOOD IS SELFISH AND THEY NEED TO KEEP THE PLACE OPEN!!
Absolutely heartbreaking. I have had the good fortune to utilize the services of this facility since I came to California 35 years ago. My 90 year-old grandfather spent his last months there and it was a very likely option for my 75 year-old father, who put in 40+ years in this industry.
As a “below-the-line” film worker I always looked at the “home” (as we in my family called it) as a shining example of how an American industry could manage to take care of each other.
But I guess the pigs at the trough are running scared. Contrary to what they most likely tell themselves, our industry’s proud legacy of commitment to the social welfare of the larger community of craftspeople and workers was junked long ago. It’s a sad, shocking sign of what we have all become.
It’s also ironic how those with the real power ($$) in this town don’t see themselves for what they really are; the mouthpieces and tools of corporate greed and an American dream gone awry.
The same people who never miss an opportunity to congratulate themselves on the world changing work they fool themselves into thinking they do.
These people, who fancy themselves so politically and socially enlightened, now turn their backs on the working class craftspeople and artists that have helped them amass their grotesque and obscene fortunes.
Should we really be that surprised?
When Jean Hersholt and his friends started the Motion Picture Relief Fund in 1939, it was funded by contributions from motion picture workers who dropped spare change into wooden boxes on the soundstages.
The studios saw the advantages of helping the Fund — too many negative newspaper stories about once-famous actors on skid row or in the charity wards — and so they came up with a system of automatic payroll deductions. Set it and forget it — one form, and money came out of your check for the rest of your career.
This was the money that kept the MPTF operating for years — and now it’s gone.
The Fund failed to propagate the payroll deduction system as Hollywood changed from a small number of large studio employers, to today’s diverse many-headed behemoths. The payroll companies do nothing to inform new employees of what the Fund is and why it’s important to give it money. People who want to give money from automatic deductions are stymied by payroll departments who don’t want to bother, or who have literally never heard of the MPTF.
And so the Fund became obsessed with big-money fixes — “Hey, Haim, give us $50 mill and we’ll name a building after you” is easier than setting up and maintaining a system of small-money deducted contributions.
The commenters upthread are absolutely right that a relatively small number of very rich people could donate enough to keep the Hospital and Home open for another year or so. But as we know, there a a limited number of rich people in Hollywood who give even enough of a damn to do that. And if we put the future of this important facility in their hands, we forget what made the Fund unique when it was founded … the principle that **WE** take care of our own.
What we need to do (those of us “foot soldiers” fortunate enough to be currently working in the industry) is to make sure we have MPTF donations taken out of our checks wherever and whenever we work. And if your employer doesn’t have an payroll donation system set up, make yourself obnoxious until they do.
The only way we’ll have any hope of getting a permanent solution, is to take the lead and Take Care Of Our Own.
Horrible, horrible news.
Why can’t Spielberg, Howard, Geffen, Horn, Lucas, Wolf, Pascal, Bewkes, Grey, Lansing, Kennedy, Bruckheimer, Grazer, Chernin, Iger, Cruise, Hanks, Streep, Ziskin, Moonves, Leno, Letterman, Smith, Pitt, Washington, Clooney, Roberts, Carry, Sutherland, etc. all chip in together to keep this place going?
How about those mega-lawyers who are pinching dimes?
How about the filthy rich agents at Endeavor, Morris, CAA?
Collectively, these people could make a stunning, immediate difference and keep all the facilities from closing.
What in the hell are they waiting for? An engraved invitation, or are they just insanely, penny-pinching cheap gorillas like the monsters at Wall Street?
Why the hell doesn’t one of these step up to the plate and make a loud announcement to all the others, “C’mon guys, here’s your chance!! DO IT.”
WHAT ARE THEY WAITING FOR???
Hopefully, someone is on the phone with the Feds, as we speak, and we’ll have some big name Perp-Walks in the very near future!
It would also be very helpful to see whose names are on those 100 checks from Madoff that were ready to be mailed out just before he was busted…
Come on people, don’t you get it? This isn’t about the money! They just opened the state of the art ten million dollar Saban center on campus last July! If this was about money then why are we all hearing about it as if it’s a done deal? They announce it yesterday and they’re letting people go today! Where was the community outreach? Where was the “Save the MPTF Fundraiser”? Clearly if you just read these posts you see that everyone literally everyone is willing to pitch in and save the Fund! The board doesn’t want it saved! They are going to tear down the hospital and sell the land! Wake up! And if you really give a crap the only thing that will stop this is public outrage. Get yourself and everyone you know, to let them know!
Who do we write??? What can we do?
Step one of the results of selling the Movie Making Companies to Industrial Corporations. Remove the Soul from the body.
Step two, eliminate ownership of the product.
and Step three is to make it so the “Actors” are paid like truck-drivers, hourly. No such thing as residuals.
Now “Actor” is just a job description.
If actor/writer/director/celebrities/whatever in Hollywood simply allow this to happen, then people outside Hollywood should never, ever give them a public forum on an international issue or an environmental issue or any other major issue without laughing in their faces. Tons of money for cars and private planes and drugs and alcohol and hookers and maybe even a gift wrapping room, but nothing for your elderly peers down the block, eh? Lecturing the rest of the country on their backwardness? Lots of the people in small towns and inner cities and quiet suburbs who will never see a six figure salary in their lives take care of their own when they become frail and elderly. Pathetic. If you don’t stand up here and now to stop this, then you should shut up later. This is just disgusting.
OR
“And people say that Hollywood has no soul…”
what Tom said much better in one sentence fragment.
PLEASE, PLEASE, PLEASE – to all members and industry leaders! Do not let this happen to current and future patients (which could be you). Visit this facility, and then go visit a facility that accepts government assistance programs (which the vast majority of your peers, co-workers, family members who are now in the MPTF long term care depend on).
You will understand why you would want to have this safety net! This is a wonderful facility!! The staff is terrific!!
You could end up in the same snake-pit that these patients could end up in.
Do not let the board ruin what has been something this industry can be very proud of!
My grandfather was a proud member for over 30 years – most of that spent with MGM. My father, a pround member, also for over 30 years as had the good fortune to be able to utilize this facility for the last several years. They now want to put him and the other 134 patients in long term care into other facilities. This is breaking my heart for my dad, for the other lovely patients we’ve come to know, and for the terrifc staff that will be losing their jobs. PLEASE HELP!! The board is throwing these patients and you under the bus.
2009 my mon lives at mptf this is pathetic . lets get on with show make it into the future with like it had up until jan 14 2009. it was wonderful peace at last until your last days with class….
this has made us ill no class for my mom in last days contant is were my mom is at peace with great nurseing staff gentle care what else is needed in her life drama drama now at 88 years old living in a wheelchair diapers leave her alone to be happy in peace love let it be.. what happen to we take care of own//// men without hearts or souls.please listen to the familys.
Why don’t all of those greedy hollywood stars, that demands tens of millions in salaries in benefits (that actually CUT the pay of the supporting actors and others on the set), reach DEEP into their pockets and help their own.
first to mind is Angelina Jolie and Brad Pitt, whose salaries squash those of the others on the set, the same people that help THEM look good. Instead of taking the money and pretending to use it for the needy (only in exchange for publicity), why don’t they each reach down and write a check for 10 million each. That would not even be the price of one movie for each of them.
Enough hollywood greed, enough self-absorbed stars. Take the example of Jodie Foster and put your money where your month is, otherwise close it.
Taking care of ones own means not throwing them on the street. Katzenberg better not sell that building. So what if he lost 20 million. He is worth over half a billion. That is peanuts.
Now HE should write a check of 100 million to get the fund endowed..
Disgrace….. and shame on the greed.
SAG, DGA, WGA, AFTRA, IATSE, and any other guild, union, or organization representing people in the entertainment business:
You need to step forward as a united front on this, and save this respite from the storm. It could be you.
You’ve learned the hard way that Hollywood is a throw away business. Are you okay with them throwing away the only real, decent safety net you have?
Put a stop to it. Take over the MPTF as a joint operation. Do not let rich people whose only concern is how much money they can save and keep the fund viable with land sales/leases of the MPTF. They’re never going to spend a day there, so they just don’t care or see why they should use their money when there are cheaper alternatives.
In other words, they either don’t care, or don’t get it. If they wanted to save the place they would have asked for help.
You need to unite, step forward, and take over this wonderful, real, benefit you’ve all worked hard for and deserve – dignity and safety in old age.
Is this the same change that Obama and the liberal Bollywood elitess plan for the country? They put a nice happy face on it and shove it down our throats.
I think they just signed my mother’s death sentence. May they reap what they sow. Very unhappy with them shoving this down our throats with no debate or input. What’s next? No heart bypass, no blood transfusions, no flu shots because they operate at a loss. Get a clue: medical operates at a loss, that’s why it costs the employees and employers so much. Hallelujah-let’s have another inaugaration party for ourselves so we can get all done up and get our sad pathetic pusses up on the TV so all us pions can gawk at you.
“We take care of our own”–BULL****
I still have a few questions. Why is this **** hole Jeffrey Katzenberg making life and death decisions about my Mom’s life and death and her childrens? I certainly didn’t give him that power. I guess he took it on himself as a humanitarian.
My next question is, if $10 million is going to bankrupt the fund then it’s in pretty bad shape. Maybe we should stop treating any members for any AIDS related medical condition or maybe drop all cancer treatments as I’m sure they must be a big drain on the fund? What would the media say to that?
Now for the important news: More stars to appear at Obama’s inauguration and two new gala ball’s. Also more post Oscar coverage and more gala parties with more Hollywood Elitess Pusses to be put on the screen.
Nikki:
Please keep the spotlight on this! Since we cannot depend on the compromised reporting of the Times (Remember the slanted Pellicano reporting?) or the Trades, we need this outlet!
THIS IS BIG – VERY BIG – AND CANNOT BE ALLOWED TO BE SWEPT UNDER THE RUG!
http://www.mptvfund.org/Join/ContactMPTF.php
Don’t just blog here. Contact the Foudation at the MPTF Hospital and let them know how you feel-
Protest Rally
We will be holding a protest rally on behalf of all the deserving residents who are facing eviction due to the closure of our unique facility.
LETS TURN OUR OUTRAGE INTO ACTION!
Please come and show your support
WHEN: Thursday January 22, 2008
WHERE: Wasserman Campus
23388 Mulholland Drive,
Woodland Hills, CA 91364
TIME: 3pm untill 5pm
The move to close certain portions of MPTF relieves me of my self-imposed obligation to make donations even while faced with economic hardship. Since contributions will no longer support industry members in greatest need, who are in their last
The move to close portions of MPTF relieves me of the self-imposed obligation to make donations even while faced with economic hardship. Since contributions will no longer support industry members in greatest need at the end of their lives, it is harder for me to justify giving to others that ‘have’ when I ‘have not’. Then to hear that no amount would save it now makes me wonder about the projected $ losses at MPTF versus the real $ losses of its most vocal board members late in 08. More going on here than meets the press release?
I am an RN who was trained in Alzheimers disease and psychology. I worked in the AD unit that bears the name of Michael Douglas in memory of his father. I can’t even imagine a more beautiful safe place for a person with this horrible disease. Shame on you to even think of shutting down this unit or any other part of this needed facility. If people would only donate $50. it will make a difference.
Will the MTPF continue to automatically take the percentage out of my checks that I have willingly been contributing all these years?
I smell Madoff! Madoff! Madoff!
As one of the staff members who has been given the difficult task of helping to relocate patients, let me just say this- During the WGA strike last year, the Fund gave out almost a million dollars to industry members out of work. Each person that applied for help was given up to $5000 to help make ends meet. I wonder how many of those people, once they returned to work and were making decent money again, bothered to repay the Fund for its charitable assistance?
It breaks my heart to watch MPTF long term care slip away. I was not an ‘industry member’ when I came to work here many years ago. And how proud of that work I am! We ARE a family at MPTF, a loving supportive family, unique beyond compare. These frail elderly residents depend on us, and we are happy to be here for them. This is the ONLY facility I have ever seen (and as a nurse I have seen many) that I would ever allow to care for my own aging parents. I am certain that our residents who are relocated to other ‘homes’ will face death sooner as a result of having to leave this wonderful, safe haven.
And despite this tragedy, I do not blame the board, or the administration. I thank them for making it possible to work in such an incredibly special environment. There are true financial hardships this organization faces. I have watched for several years as they have tried to creatively increase revenue while not cutting corners on the quality of care. Look at other facilities – do you think you will find a doctor and nurse practitioner on site? You will not. You will also see nurses caring for 10 patients each, with poorly trained ancillary staff. There will shortages of equipment, with little or no stimulating activity for those relegated to unkempt personal surroundings. MPTF has never allowed that to happen, and that quality of care comes at a price.
I will cry as the residents leave our doors, knowing that the next set of hands they feel will not be so caring, responsible, and committed. As staff, we truly do take care of our own. Can the entertainment industry save the MPTF? It would be a godsend. And if not, my condolences to you and your parents alike.
Ask why no one ever mentioned them losing money on LTC and why they didn’s do a capital campaign to raise money. Ask why this was so hush hush and everyone had to to be shocked. Ask why they aren’t waiting to see what Obama does with the healthcare system. Ask about their choices in who gets laid off in all this. Ask about how much in compensation the exec’s get. Ask about their bonus’s. I saw how they treat employees and am glad I left before this.
“Can the entertainment industry save the MPTF?” No “godsend” here… Too busy getting a tummy tuck and doing lunch. And, then there’s that pending script deal pending…and the Fund Raiser to save the penguins…Oh, yeah, I almost forgot…GLOBAL WAAAAAARMING!!! No…sorry…no godsend here…
As an employee at the hospital, we were told many things that are not in that press release. Some of which is 1. that part of the reason was due to the age of the buildings. They are in need of earthquake retrofittings/repair. 2. That a 20 million dollar donation would not help at this point.
As for the acute wing not usually caring for more than 10 patients at one time? They neglected to say that full capacity is only about 22. Other rooms are used for other puposes.
There was never any sign of cost reducing measures. We did not have a clue, there was redecorating, painting, remodeling. Why? so we could close in a year? Its obviously not related to reimbursement rates; its just the desire to change and this is an excuse for your viewing pleasure.
In the meantime, our more alert patients are scared, they are not eating as before. They are asking us not to make them leave. We have had falls. There are tears from staff, patients and families. But mgmt is not there to help them; it is the family of nurses and staff to console them. The social workers gave out letters and brief explanations, then left. We are a family, we care for our patients like they were our parents, We love them dearly, come see it for yourself. Ther is no finer LTC facility.
As a nurse other jobs can be found, but how do you turn your back on your family.
We need your help, so we can be there when you need us. We want to be there to welcome your family member; into our family.
They started the fund with a coffee can; save it with one!
Make calls, write letters, join the rally…do whatever it takes. We are begging you not to turn your backs on us.
INAUGURATION DAY 2009
Our new President made a speech today… “Hollywood” was in attendance… They all applauded… They all smiled and waved at the TV cameras… Some even volunteered their opinions… NONE of them heard the President’s message… “Hollywood” does not hear this message!
Jeffrey Katzenberg, chairman of the MPTF Foundation Board is planning to kill my Mother and more than a hundred others.
So much for the Motion Picture & Television Fund’s promise of “unwavering commitment” to the entertainment industry, and vice versa. This is a huge story with major ramifications for everyone who considered the Motion Picture And Television Fund facilities as their safety net in times of sickness and old age. What else might be closed next? I find it hard to believe that, with all the enormous wealth in the Hollywood, the community couldn’t look after its own better than this. “MPTF is initiating these changes because it’s the right thing to do, but the fact is that we have no choice,” Jeffrey Katzenberg, chairman of the MPTF Foundation Board, said in the statement. “Although we are in good shape today, the acute-care hospital and long-term care facility are generating operating deficits that could bankrupt MPTF in a very few years.” C’mon, there are fundraisers all the time, including that big-ticket Saturday “Night Before” the Oscars party hosted by Katzenberg himself. For crissakes, the old Motion Picture Relief Fund was founded back in 1921 by Hollywood luminaries Mary Pickford, Charlie Chaplin, Douglas Fairbanks and D.W. Griffith to help people in the entertainment industry who fell on hard times. How can this be happening now? I am really sick about this, just sick.
Is this the same change that Obama and the liberal Bollywood elitess plan for the country? They put a nice happy face on it and shove it down our throats.
I think they just signed my mother’s death sentence. May they reap what they sow. Very unhappy with them shoving this down our throats with no debate or input. What’s next? No heart bypass, no blood transfusions, no flu shots because they operate at a loss. Get a clue: medical operates at a loss, that’s why it costs the employees and employers so much. Hallelujah-let’s have another inauguration party for ourselves so we can get all done up and get our sad pathetic pusses up on the TV so all us pions can gawk at you.
“We take care of our own”–BULL****
I still have a few questions. Why is this **** hole Jeffrey Katzenberg making life and death decisions about my Mom’s life and death and her childrens? I certainly didn’t give him that power. I guess he took it on himself as a humanitarian.
My next question is, if $10 million is going to bankrupt the fund then it’s in pretty bad shape. Maybe we should stop treating any members for any AIDS related medical condition or maybe drop all cancer treatments as I’m sure they must be a big drain on the fund? What would the media say to that?
Could you please forward info for our members about the protest rally regarding the planned closing of the long term care facility at the Motion Picture Hospital in Woodland Hills. “We take care of our own”—Bull****
Protest Rally
WHEN: Thursday Jan. 22, 2008
WHERE: MPH
23388 Mulholland Drive,
Woodland Hills, Ca. 91364
This is an important rally for all IATSE members. Please forward to all members and our fellow locals.
It has been made clear that there is no amount of money that will save long-term care at MPTF. Not $10 million, not $200 million, not $500 million. Because, it is not a matter of money. It is a matter of power and vision. One man sees the future of MPTF as a resort and HMO; industry members see MPTF as the safe haven it was founded to be and to which they contributed their blood, seat, and tears. It is a matter of disrespect. I was appalled to learn that people are donating to the fund now, feeling they are doing their part to save it. Not only have the residents and staff of LTC and all other parts of the campus been betrayed, but the industry has been betrayed. Now good guys, the kind-hearted individuals are being betrayed – thank you but your donations will NOT help save those being evicted.
They claim the donations will not save LTC. As for acute, we have harbored many stars from the press over the years. When everyone is looking at Cedars, UCLA…they forgot to look here. And they were safe with us. These people should use the power they have to remove the current board and mgmt, who will allow the donations to save LTC and acute.
The Next Generation Council is filled with younger named people of the industry. Some of which are names, some are not. Why haven’t these people voiced an opinion. They are there for the photo-ops at golf tournaments!
We need to expand, yes. We need to update, yes. But not to close.
Unfortunately, “MPTF Donor” was probably right that this is probably a management decision to turn the Motion Picture Home into a resort and an HMO, rahter than the unplanned result of rising healtcare costs. When Jodi Foster donated millions a few years a ago for a beautiful indoor therapy pool, many were impressed at the architecture and new amenity, and some thought, “Wow, the MPTF has so much money, they can build a luxury pool!” Why did the management accept such a donation if, as the story is now being told, finances have been worsening in recent years? Why? Perhaps because the donation of a luxurious pool fits the new vision just perfectly. And as for the oldest folks, the neediest folks, the folks closest to the end of life and most in need of loving and palliative care? Get rid of them. Including my sweet grandmother, who has been paying for her care out of pocket since she moved in seven years ago.
I am absolutely horrified at this news. My father was in acute care at the Motion Picture Hospital in Woodland Hills for months – and they SAVED his life. His doctor was brilliant and compassionate. The nurses treated him as if he were family. I had transferred him form UCLA, where he was being completely neglected and at death’s door, and MPTF saved him. My father was one of the more fornutate in this business, and he could have gone anywhere. What about the thousands of industry members who do not have that luxury? How does something like this happen??!! How can we stop it?
As a former MPTF employee, I was always somewhat suspect of the MPTF financials. I think a good long look at the books might shed some light on this.
These patients gave up everthing they had to come to a place where they can get some help, and now this so called Dr. Tillman wants to kick them out…. Why???
It’s all about GREED…………………..
It’s about time! We had 2 family members here with industry background and lousy care. One was illegally accepted about 3 years “early” w/o any inability to live on their own. The doctor has over 300 patients and should have ordered a bypass for our other family member. Because they didn’t, this family member died. All along the industry tells their employees a bunch of lies that they will “take care of their own” w/o a lot of expense. Then when they get there, they pay an astronomical fee plus the monthly rate which is also outrageous. I witnessed the schwindling early on w/these people. The crux was the letter sent out stating rehab was being removed but somehow, miraculously, they still had $$ for the ridiculous Saban center; which the residents in other sections are prevented from using unless they pay…yup…another astronomical fee…if they are so lucky. MPTF also bilks all the $$ from these poor residents right at the time of mental instability making them think they are contributing to something so special for the facility. There are many other places w/in the surrounding neighborhoods which are superior to Motion Picture which is why they can’t “keep up.” They cheat residents, are poorly trained, serve crappy food for crazy prices and attempt to get away with illegal actions thinking they won’t be caught. One can only attempt to cover up such antics and this is a perfect example of what goes around, comes around. They state they will still be able to keep the pricey Saban center despite $$ dwindling…hmm…makes one wonder and realize that the residents are truly not the priority. I am thrilled to see them closing;only wish family had received the proper care…they would still be with us.
I find it inexcusable that the decision to close the facility was made without first trying to save it. I would like to see everyone come together and figure out how to raise 10 million a year. I am really disappointed in the leadership or lack there of. Don’t even get me started on the 400 qualifying hours. We used to have a health plan that was envied. Now it’s one of the worst out there. Next? NO PENSION.
A member for over 30 years
QUESTION 1.
To Dr. Tillman and the Board: How many elderly at Long Term Care have died since the announcement, as compared to the number of deaths in a week from all of last year?
If our understanding is true that 7 residents have died in an approximate 7 day period since they were all told they must leave their homes.
Question 2.
Are any of the elderly deaths linked to stress and fear from learning they must leave their homes?
Some sources understanding of the situation believe there to be a connection.
Question 3.
Does Tillman and the Board have any fear of legal ramifications if deaths are the result of their behavior?
Question 4.
What is the name of the company that conducted the study and gathered the facts for the MPTF’s decision to close the Long Term Care facility?
This is my understanding,
As the investigation will unfold, an inside source with information will expose the truth of David Tillman’s administration. The Board will find the irresponsible parties, and bring them to justice. Administration actually could be faced with convictions. Due to the understanding that there have been deaths since the poorly delivered news of the MPTF’s decision to close the Long Term Care (LTC) nursing facility. Innocent helpless residents have been subjected to fear and anguish, because of Tillman’s coverup. People inside know the truth and are coming forth secretly. Look to see the names of those being terminated by our present administration. This is going to be very bad for the immediate outlook of the MPTF. In the long run, the three Boards that make “ALL” the ultimate decisions will be more hands-on with the power they give to future CEO’s. The Board needs a watchdog to keep an eye on the highly paid administrators they employ. The most important action to be taken is to stop the eviction and let the residents calm down! Tillman with his immediate partners, created the ability to sell all of the people OUT! And by “ALL”, I mean “ALL”. This has been going on for years, and several people knew it. Get ready because here it comes. Let’s hope for the “BIG” guys sake, they step up and take immediate action. So far since the release of the closure, NO word from any of the Board members. If this doesn’t get defused within the next 5 days, the Board members names are soon to become front page news. Then lets see who can smile at the residents being told which van to get in when they are being taken from their homes.
As one caregiver said, “I NEVER THOUGHT I’D SEE THE DAY”!
Well it came. And for some inside employees, they say they KNOW why, and couldn’t believe it took this long for Tillmans’ administration to be exposed.
The boards should meet with the residents and families, and reach a solution to “Saving The Lives Of Our Own’.
It”s not too late.
This is truly a travesty that this has happened to this wonderful facility and organization. I think there is definitely a true hidden agenda to this.
Question:
Why is Dr Tillman’s salary 2x the salary of President Obama.
Why are the administrators of this facility salaries
more than most 900 bed hospitals?
Why have they already contacted contractors to tear these buildings down prior to even finding a facility
for these patients? Could it be this property is too valuable for a nursing home now?
And the people living in the Ray Stark Villas and the Country House, what happens when they are no longer
able to ambulate or dress and feed themselves, where do they go then? Back to their home that they have already given up, like these other 100 patients that are being thrown out.
What happens to the Alzheimers patients? There is only
one other facilty in the Los Angeles area and it has a waiting list.
And yes these long term patients are possibly only paying in their Medicare and possibly pensions, but there are facilities all over this country that patients are paying their stays this way, and these facilities are not going under. And do not say that it is due to staffing as the MPTF facility has been cutting their staffing for the past 4 years in nursing housekeeping and landscaping.
I think if MPTF could survive the Great Depression when
Mary Pickford and Douglas Fairbanks i am sure were not
making 10 million a picture, could survive. Then what
is the problem here. Once this place is gone, it will be too late.
Jeffrey Katzenberg and Steven Spielberg should be ashamed of themselves, yes they have plenty of money to take care of them, but the many workers that have worked on their pictures, like the grips, lighting, gaffers’ makeup artist have not made millions like they have.
Come on SAG, Directors Guild, Writers Guild and everyone, stand up and BE HEARD AND STOP THIS NOW.
I feel bad for anyone that suffers like this as a result of our economy…but…
GET OVER YOURSELVES, people…
Don’t give me this crap about people breaking their backs for years, etc. It’s acting. It’s not a real job. It’s getting paid to pretend, basically. Wow. How you can compare that to people who had TRULY back-breaking jobs and then faced health care cuts is beyond me. People wanted to be “stars” all their lives and chase a dream? Great. More power to them. But don’t make this out to be ANYTHING even REMOTELY CLOSE to what people with real jobs and real careers are facing.
“Rob” – please save your uninformed rants for some blog about Lehman Bros. or Fox News. Clearly you don’t have a freaking clue who MPTF serves (or is SUPPOSED to serve). As someone who has worked as a producer’s assistant, production secretary and publicist, I know all too well about TRULY back breaking work. I have worked my share of 16 hour days, 6-7 days a week with no overtime and no paycheck to make up for the time lost away from my real life & family. Those ARE real jobs and REAL careers, dumbsh*t. Take your bitterness and bi*ch somewhere else where they won’t care that you don’t know what you are even complaining about (again, Fox News comes to mind).
Jeff Katzenberg could underwrite that debt from his checking account.
This is a totally betray of the trust which build the Motion Picture Country Home.
Shame on them.
I have a small clue as to why the MPTF may be suffering deficits.
Last month, I visited a MPTF clinic with a minor but persistent condition that did not respond to over the counter treatments. No big deal, right?
I was referred for a thoracic and pelvic CT scan, and as as a result of these tests, a pelvic ultrasound.
Knowing the cost of such expensive medical imaging, I was truly conflicted about the necessity of these tests. I knew this was not a prudent use of MPTF resources.
Regretfully, I did not argue the point with the physician. But in retrospect, I truly wonder if the tests were ordered out of a legal concern more than good medical practice. I believe this is the crux of the matter. The practice of managed health care has become the practice of minimizing legal exposure.
No wonder they are running a deficit. Where are the internal audits to pinpoint the inefficiencies and waste?
This closure never would have happened if the caregivers were still under the old N-UHW union leadership. The SEIU union has forcibly taken over the local union of these workers. The workers need to get back with the union that has a proven track record of putting frail elderly patients first the National Union of Healthcare Workers not the SEIU union that has a proven track record of selling out elderly patients in tort reform deals and signing away a workers right to speak up about LTC abuse and neglect like the SEIU does. My prayers are with the residents, family members and caregivers. N-UHW is a fighting union and never would have allowed this travesty to move forward.
Would have been nice if sean penn spoke about this at the oscars instead…
For those of you thinking the best response is to contribute to MPTF to “keep them afloat,” think twice. All this song and dance by those who didn’t keep the place functioning properly, nor legally, only want you to cough up more dough to save their hide throughout their legal battles. One more teaser to entrap the ones who have already paid a bundle to them. These people(Wasserman & Katzenberg, especially) have been caught and are panicking. If they make a big enough stink they’ll get the weak to cave in and GIVE, GIVE, GIVE…….and then bingo! Give themselves all the pats on the back. We were dooped big time and had to watch the facility(all sections) like a hawk while our family members were there. They know most people don’t have the $$ nor the time to fight them so they just keep on with their games, and selfishness. I do feel terribly for those who lost family members on account of this news as our family members were not cared for well at all(see our Jan. 25th posting). We do know a family friend who works in the hospital wing and feel bad that they will have to seek employment elsewhere, but other than that…….forget it! MPTF does NOT take care of their own and family of current residents need to seek out alternative locate options. Perhaps, licensed group care homes.The proposal MPTF makes for “community” assistance/help is an absolute joke. DO NOT BUY THEIR TACTIC OF “NEEDING $$$” AND DON’T GIVE THEM ANY SUPPORT, THEY’LL JUST CONTINUE TO BLOW IT ELSEWHERE.
Last night I briefly watched Julia Roberts on David Letterman. It was announced that over her lifetime her films created/raised 5 BILLION dollars. That’s just one woman . She wasn’t even the producer of those films. I find it shameful that Hollywood cannot support this lifeline to once-upon-a-time actors. Didn’t the union cover their back?
Back then, the actors/actresses were paid a flat wage. No residuals. Who knew you could (now) get a percentage of the gross?
Shame.
Greed and excess. Methinks non-profit corporate raider Tillman saw an easy mark with deep pockets and a board of non-medical professionals. He got his team into place, set up the scenario and when his ego and salary were big enough, he brazenly went about what he thought would be the final coup. But the bigger they are, the harder they fall.
The debt MPTF has is from bonds issued to pay for its last two construction projects. Any kickbacks there?
All those consultants and outsourced contracts. Any kickbacks there?
The industry and board members are furious. When Tillman gets canned, let’s hope that the MPTF follows the money trail and sues him.
Everyone is forgetting the most basic of reaasons why the Motion Picture Home needs to, must remain and continue to go on – compassion, respect, kindness and morality. Does everything in this town, whether human or otherwise, have to be destroyed? Is there no respect for the past, Hollywood’s past, which, by the way holds all those men and women who worked their butts off and were an important part, if not “the” most important part, of moving making? If the Home needs money, give it; if the residents need better medical care, give it; and if the residents need human contact, visits from others, hugs or maybe just a kind word, give it. What is wrong with people?
Amazing! Consider the amount of money earned by actors, CEOs, etc. today in the great U.S.A. and their choices in spending their money. Yes, it is their money and it is their decision on how their money should be spent; however, when did we as a people miss the compassion boat for our “brothers and sisters”. Money is available for the mansions, clothes, jewelry, ….. stuff ….. stuff … and more stuff … stuff that no one needs to live or to be happy. True happiness can be found in helping our brothers and sisters in their time of need when they cannot help themselve. I pray to God that those individuals whom certainly can afford it will unite behind these great people and make a stand. You are in my prayers.
P.S. Keep it simple. You do not have to throw another fund raiser gala. Have we turned into a society that must receive something before we can give. Save the costs involved in throwing another party. Just run a large ad in a well circulated newspaper and/or magazine and ask for funding, supporters, etc. Remind people about the specific individuals that will be affected, their names and their contributions the current 100+ people who are being relocated. Put a name and face to those in need. Who can forget Hattie McDaniel, a past resident of the facility? PLEASE HELP !
Sharise Parviz an actress in Hollywood just put out a video about the selfishness of Hollywood and the closing of the hospital. excellent stuff.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BtqoQczI9ok
Mary Pickford would be turning in her grave. If they can set it up and maintain it back then, then how can we not now? I read that someone working for the hospital is taking like a $800,000 a year paycheck!!! Maybe he should take a pay cut, and have the coin box brought back, and instead of giving celebrities bags with like $100,000 worth of free gifts, cut the bags and give the money to the hospital to keep the fund running.
MPTF does NOT “take care of their own” as they so proudly publicize. Both my parents were residents and they still had to pay whopping bucks even tho’ the parent in the industry was lured into thinking they were contributing to their stay all along. Both parents were neglected, especially as their needs increased. Staff was rarely circulating around monitoring the residents,even though they had diagnosis like Alzheimers. They did not monitor the medication for the residents, just put it in a cup at their table. The skilled nursing section just plopped them in a chair, gave them mush for meals and made family visitors who wanted to take them on an outing feel rotten by giving dirty looks. Both parents would have lived much longer had they not been at MPTF. MPTF sadly was a main contributor to their decreasing health. Yes, it will be hard for current residents and their families to find an alternative spot but there are far better places than MPTF.